Brooklyn Pickle Pinehurst

No public restrooms

Great sandwiches. They were huge.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Food was pretty good. Not the same as Burnett Ave . The quality was ok quantity was good. Staff was pretty good.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 4

Service: 4

Best NY deli in town! Sandwiches are YUGE! And dellllicioussss! 💯🥇😋 … Staff works fast together to make perfectly perfect sandwiches every time. Thanks!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Best Reuben sandwich I’ve had in a long time ! The BLT was okay, but the bacon was very thin and crumbly.

Excellent pastrami and macaroni salad.

I have never had a bad experience here. The staff is fabulous and the food is freat

Just ordered for the first time and received a massive loaded tuna sandwich. It was amazing. Very friendly and fast service. Worth every penny and everything was super fresh. Thanks!

Being new in town, my wife and I are eager to try as many new restaurants as we can. We went around 1pm on a Monday and were the only customers. The place is big, but the booths were not very comfortable, so we sat at a table. My wife had a 1/2 turkey sandwich with cheese on whatever their house bread is. She said it was very good.
I'm always on the lookout for a great Reuben. Unfortunately, this one was very disappointing. In their defense, most are. Being from north Jersey/NY I've had many true pastrami or corned beef sandwiches. It's all about the brine so, if you've never had a genuine one, you may not know the difference. The corned beef they used seemed straight out of a supermarket deli. It had no trace of what good, corned beef should be. They also used their house bread, and not rye, which is a no-no.
Also, they represent Brooklyn in name only. You will not find a generic sandwich shop like this in Brooklyn. The search continues...

I went here for the first time today and had no clue what to expect!
The young man taking my order was very professional, patient, and kind.
I had no clue what i wanted to order so I asked him what his favorite sandwich was and then asked him to make it like he’s making his own! This BLT is delicious the flavors the freshness of the ingredients 10/10 I recommend. If you’re new to the area like me and hesitant don’t be this establishment did not disappoint, ah yes don’t forget to try the sweet tea and their pickles!

Better than Subway (also, sadly similar), but definitely not a New York deli.

We tried this establishment because of a referral. As we walked in, I found it odd that no restrooms existed for the customers. The menu board wasn't the easiest to understand. I decided to try the whole pork sandwich on dark rye with Russian sauce. I decided to dress it with lettuce, tomato, pickles, and onion. The bread was tasty. However, it didn't hold up well to the juicy 8 ounces of pork. I had three different cheeses for an uncharge of 45 cents per extra cheese. I would eat here again if invited by friends. I probably wouldn't choose it again for myself. The dining area is very congested as well. The flow just didn't work that well.

Cuban sandwich was excellent and they had some different flavors cos to choose from

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Honestly such an incredible find. Sandwiches are delicious the staff was super helpful guiding us through the process and with recommendations. We have the Cuban and Brooklyn Pickle and they were both amazing! 10/10 recommend this place

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Brooklyn Pickle Special

First time visiting with family and we enjoyed our food which was prepared properly did not have to wait for a long time. Clean place.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Pickles, Pastrami Sandwich