Theodore's Dining Room

301 3rd Ave, Medora
(701) 623-4444

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Cody

Typically we have a great experience with great food! My girlfriend is celiac and they have several options for her to safely eat.

Steven

Employees were wonderful, especially Roddick and his grandmother. Food and drinks were very good and very well presented

Sergio Contreras

Crab cakes were like hush puppies. No crab, no flavor. The sauce was too spicy.
The chicken dish ended up having raw chicken around the bone. $42 for a dish with raw chicken???
Not impressed at all...
The manager was reasonable, he's not the chef, not his fault.
Would I recommend it for the food?... No.
The sparkling wine was nice...

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 1

Service: 3

Terri

Exquisite dining! The food was absolutely delicious. The dining g room was beautiful. Service was outstanding!

Lana

Our server had great suggestions and was great! The Bison Osso Buco and roasted brussel sprouts were delicious!

John Ferreira

Excellent food and drinks! Very friendly staff and excellent bartender... What a pleasure

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Sharon

Everything was efficient and perfect from the water glasses to dessert! Looking forward to dining there again.

Stephen

Beautiful atmosphere. Excellent service. Delicious food. Really enjoyed our dining experience.

Gary

This is a great restaurant. Had the Bison OsoBoco, just spectacular. My wife had the Walleye it was great too. The only issue we have with the restaurant is that it's 1000 miles from where we live.

lauren

The room is cozy and warm and tables spaced apart. The prices are high but portions are large. Brussel sprouts were so good! The special prime rib was good but too much sauce and the potatoes were not very crispy. The ribeye was mostly inedible due to extremely high fat content. Hey did discount the meal due to the issue. Service was really the best part. The server wasn't rushed and food was properly paced. Decent wine menu but a $25 corkage fee seemed egregious.

Cindy Welch

Drinks before dinner were excellent. The dining room was very nice, we opted for the 4 course dinner special at $80 per person. First 2 courses were very good, the steak however was tough and smothered with toppings which we had to scrape off to find the meat which was a little disappointing. Desert was excellent and overall was a very nice experience

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 3

Service: 5

marilynl l Hatch

The service was great. Our meal was delicious. I had Crème Brûlée French Toast. I was fabulous. I left wanting more. Food was not over priced. We were well fed and well served.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Eric Clock

We had a great experience here. Definitely a place to eat at while in Medora. The staff did an amazing job which topped of the excellent food. I had their ribeye which as cooked perfectly. My partner had their bison which as so tasty. Luckily the portion was too big for my wife so I got to finish it off. Bread and butter was a great way to start as well.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Set Apart Spirit

I like a good cut of meat! Was sadden a filet wasn’t an option. Settled for an extremely fat ribeye. It was smothered in this coagulated marinade that was horrible. I wouldn’t recommend it.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 2

Service: 4

Paula Sorrels

All staff are amazing 👏 service was very quick. All around beautiful and great vibe atmosphere. Will eat again when visiting Medora

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...