Absolutely love there work!! They've gonna above and beyond for my daughter's birthdays!! They will always have my service!!
R WG
Phenomenal!!! I ordered 2 custom large cakes and couldn’t have been more impressed. They were beyond perfect! Seriously just the most beautifully designed (they were silly SpongeBob and a Lego but still gorgeously done!) the level of detail was incredible. I knew that they were silly requests for a grown man’s birthday party but they had personal meaning to him so I really wanted these two very specific cakes and two other bakers had kind of mocked the themes because they were for a grown man so I was a bit sad I wasn’t really finding anyone to make what we wanted but a friend had recommended Beautifully Baked since they had done custom cookies for her. When I called they were amazing and were totally on board, didn’t try to convince me to do something more traditional, they were all on board. When we cut and ate the cake I kid you not I have never eaten a better cake! You need to get the cookie dough or the Reese’s they are phenomenal!! I also ordered a red velvet which our guests adored but I didn’t personally try it. It did look amazing though, perfectly moist without looking wet and the chocolate chips in between looked delicious!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Emily Godejohn
I ordered a birthday cake from them in June the interaction was mostly via email but they reached out over the phone to make sure they got absolutely everything correct on the cake. The cake was absolutely BEAUTIFUL and very delicious. They made some lovely recommendations which MADE the cake. 10 out of 10 recommend!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Emily Godejohn
I ordered a birthday cake from them in June the interaction was mostly via email but they reached out over the phone to make sure they got absolutely everything correct on the cake. The cake was absolutely BEAUTIFUL and very delicious. They made some lovely recommendations which MADE the cake. 10 out of 10 recommend!!
Justice Horvath
Cupcakes are really dry and crumbly. Fostering from Walmart is much better than whatever they wiped on the top of these. Very disappointed
Food: 1
Jennifer Higgins
She created such beautiful cupcakes and a custom cake for my daughter's baby shower. The cake was moist and the frosting were perfect. The cookies squares she sells in her shop are delightful. We have enjoyed everything we have tried.
Dora Ziranda
I couldn’t have been happier, except work❤️
Jessica Caban
This is one of my favorite places in Columbus. Whenever I feel like treating myself or my loved ones to an exceptional dessert I visit them. They have a variety of flavors that are guaranteed delicious! My personal favorite are their cheesecakes.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Taylor Eckholt
Here’s just a few of the cakes they have done for me over the years, and let me tell yah, they don’t disappoint!!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Hilary Muhle
We're never disappointed with any yummy treat from Beautifully Baked! My oung kids are honest critics and they are always over the moon with the fun themes, designs and of course, taste!
I’ve been using beautifully baked for the last few years.. and let me tell you they never disappoint in design and flavor!!!! Definitely recommend
Kaydie Brandl
Really delicious pastries, just wish there was a place to sit and enjoy them. Ended up having to eat in my car.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 5
Service: 4
kerrin thomas
I’ve only gotten cupcakes and they look so good but dry everytime ? .
Tiffany Ann Rose
my son ryekson cake was amazing from the looks to the taste:) thank you. 5 out 5 recommend
Sarah Angelia Oehlrich
Such a wonderful bakery with amazing flavors. They did an amazing job on my daughter’s 3rd Birthday cake! My 3 year old couldn’t stop talking about her special Ghost Spidey Birthday Cake!
Absolutely love there work!! They've gonna above and beyond for my daughter's birthdays!! They will always have my service!!
Phenomenal!!! I ordered 2 custom large cakes and couldn’t have been more impressed. They were beyond perfect! Seriously just the most beautifully designed (they were silly SpongeBob and a Lego but still gorgeously done!) the level of detail was incredible. I knew that they were silly requests for a grown man’s birthday party but they had personal meaning to him so I really wanted these two very specific cakes and two other bakers had kind of mocked the themes because they were for a grown man so I was a bit sad I wasn’t really finding anyone to make what we wanted but a friend had recommended Beautifully Baked since they had done custom cookies for her. When I called they were amazing and were totally on board, didn’t try to convince me to do something more traditional, they were all on board.
When we cut and ate the cake I kid you not I have never eaten a better cake! You need to get the cookie dough or the Reese’s they are phenomenal!! I also ordered a red velvet which our guests adored but I didn’t personally try it. It did look amazing though, perfectly moist without looking wet and the chocolate chips in between looked delicious!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I ordered a birthday cake from them in June the interaction was mostly via email but they reached out over the phone to make sure they got absolutely everything correct on the cake. The cake was absolutely BEAUTIFUL and very delicious. They made some lovely recommendations which MADE the cake. 10 out of 10 recommend!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I ordered a birthday cake from them in June the interaction was mostly via email but they reached out over the phone to make sure they got absolutely everything correct on the cake. The cake was absolutely BEAUTIFUL and very delicious. They made some lovely recommendations which MADE the cake. 10 out of 10 recommend!!
Cupcakes are really dry and crumbly. Fostering from Walmart is much better than whatever they wiped on the top of these. Very disappointed
Food: 1
She created such beautiful cupcakes and a custom cake for my daughter's baby shower. The cake was moist and the frosting were perfect. The cookies squares she sells in her shop are delightful. We have enjoyed everything we have tried.
I couldn’t have been happier, except work❤️
This is one of my favorite places in Columbus. Whenever I feel like treating myself or my loved ones to an exceptional dessert I visit them. They have a variety of flavors that are guaranteed delicious! My personal favorite are their cheesecakes.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Here’s just a few of the cakes they have done for me over the years, and let me tell yah, they don’t disappoint!!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We're never disappointed with any yummy treat from Beautifully Baked! My oung kids are honest critics and they are always over the moon with the fun themes, designs and of course, taste!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
I’ve been using beautifully baked for the last few years.. and let me tell you they never disappoint in design and flavor!!!! Definitely recommend
Really delicious pastries, just wish there was a place to sit and enjoy them. Ended up having to eat in my car.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 5
Service: 4
I’ve only gotten cupcakes and they look so good but dry everytime ? .
my son ryekson cake was amazing from the looks to the taste:) thank you. 5 out 5 recommend
Such a wonderful bakery with amazing flavors. They did an amazing job on my daughter’s 3rd Birthday cake! My 3 year old couldn’t stop talking about her special Ghost Spidey Birthday Cake!
Loading...