New York Pizza and Italian Restaurant

Really good food and very affordable. Thanks for a great meal!

The pizza, pasta and salads are great!! Everything we have ordered from here is delicious!!

06-12-2025 around 5pm. Family of 4. Waitress was overly friendly calling us all baby. The 2 pasta dishes ordered smelled funky and tasted unpleasant. Appetizer sampler platter we ordered- the mozzarella sticks and mushrooms were overcooked and melted together. The first 3 things my son asked for they didn't have available....so why's it on the menu. My other son ordered a personal pepperoni,onion and garlic pizza that was overcooked and not enough toppings. We were disappointed and we won't be coming back. 😔 Glad for those who have had a good experience though.

New York Pizza provided food for 70 people for our son’s wedding rehearsal dinner Friday night. HIGHLY, HIGHLY RECOMMEND!! Felicia was so great to work with…she helped guide us through their menu options and was very attentive to our needs. She was quick to respond and had everything prepared and delivered on time. We decided on pasta with meat sauce, chicken Alfredo and garlic knots. New York Pizza did not disappoint! We received many comments on how good the food was! There was more than enough in regards to portions and garlic knots were exceptionally awesome!! Thank you for providing an amazing meal for our special event! We will be singing your praises for years to come!

went in for our first time today and was not disappointed. Customer service was great, very friendly. Food was perfect. Can't wait to try more of the menu. Tried out the calamari, garlic knots, lasagna and German calzone. Yum!

Our pizza was excellent! Glad to have you in Hastings!

Beautiful owners! They made feel very welcome and made me my favorite dish linguine with white clam sauce, very authentic ~ well worth the visit!! Enjoyed the salad and cheesy garlic bread & bought a tiramisu for later ❤️

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Awesome food!!! Diamond in the rough!! Everything is SOOO good!!

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Hidden gem of a pizza place in southeast Grand Island.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Food was extremely slow despite the place being pretty empty. Do NOT order any pasta! Both pastas in our group were disgusting. The pizza was also poor quality. Nobody’s plate in our group got finished. Maybe their chef called in sick because they had no idea what they were doing. Will not be coming back.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

i came here to get some pizza and was very impressed! HUGE pizza slice for about 5 bucks and came in less than 5 minutes will come again

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Best Italian food between Omaha and

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Love the crunchy crust. Sauce could have had more taste to it. Toppings were average.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 3

Very slow service. Charged more than the prices listed on the menu. Refused to talk to me about lowering the price to what was listed. That is illegal and not a good practice to follow

Excellent attention. The place is very quiet and familiar. Very good pizza.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5