Misty's Steakhouse and Brewery

One of the best prime rib I have ever had Great spot

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

We had a party of nine and we had a show to attend at 7:30. Our reservations were at 5:30 and yet we barely made it to the show.

Our table was positioned in the middle of the room surrounded by empty tables, and yet we rarely received attention. Tables that arrived after us got their meals before we did.

Drinks were forgotten or made incorrectly. (Who puts a lime on a martini?) My wings were cold, soggy, and they did not bring the dipping sauce that was meant to come with them.

A party member ordered a salad and received a burger instead.

My wife's salmon was dry.

When a member of our party brought these issues to the attention of the manager, she was met with a defensive attitude and nothing but excuses.

Our server was very kind and was working hard. I do not at all blame her.

The back of the menu says "a Lincoln staple since 1963."

It's a wonder Misty's has lasted that long.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 3

Although our table of seven felt that the food was mediocre at best, the prices were equal to a top tier steakhouse which it certainly is not.

Service was amateurish, and the facility itself is badly worn and lacked cleanliness.

We certainly won’t return.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 3

Service: 3

Went on New Years Eve.
Everything was great.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Lobster Bisque

Came here to celebrate my brother and father’s birthdays. The place was busy at 5:30 for a lied center event. We had a reservation and our table was ready but we had to ask for menus. Service took forever and we had to request refills of water after waiting with empty glasses. Crab cakes were underdone and mush. Soup and salad were decent. Steaks were unimpressive. Overall the food quality compared to the price point is abysmal though. Service was so slow and server did not once proactively check on our food quality or if we needed anything.

This was my third visit in 1.5 years (family or work events) and I’ve been seriously disappointed every time. Misty’s seems to continue going based on a reputation that no longer exists. It’s been years since I had a high quality meal here.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 1

We went after the game…. Our party was all seated by 6:50. We ordered drinks and then a bit later dinner. Tables all around us that were seated AFTER our group received their dinner and left before our food ever arrived. A nearby table served three different groups and still no dinner for us
Talked to the manager and she said she would check. When food arrived it was cold. We finally ordered our own drinks from the bar…. Have been going here on game day for 20 years and this was the worst ever????‍♀️?‍♀️?‍♀️

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Sadly the quality does not live up to the prices. Had the queens cut prime rib, medium doneness. Very chewy faint flavor. Certainly not as excellent as the Havelock location in the 1980’s when Bob Milton ran the show. My impression is that the current restaurant is Misty’s in name only.

Been awhile since we had been to Misty’s, a few years. The prices have jumped quite a lot (somewhat to be expected). The unfortunate part is, the quality of food has dropped, quite a bit from previous. Our server, Kennedy was great! Just wish the food was worth the price.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 2

Service: 5

I was shocked. I have heard such great things about Misty's. It was really bad and almost $400 for a 4 top. We had the Lobster Tail, Scallops, Sea Bass, and a filet Mignon. We also had the Lobster escargot. The sea bass was small, smashed, about a quarter of an inch thick,, the scallops were straight out of a freezer bag from Walmart. They were small and extremely over microwaved. The lobster tail was over cooked and you couldn't eat the bottom part of the lobster tail because it was too tough. The filet mignon was really good. The lobster escargot was also good. Their most expensive items were awful though. I know people will ask "did you tell anyone?" No we did not, it was packed and I wasn't going to ask them to remake 3 of our 4 entrees and I'll bet the result would have been the same. I won't go back, wouldn't recommend this place unless you are going for steak only

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 2

I had the lobster bisque (excellent) and the steak of the day, which was (I forget the exact name) a Rib Steak with rosemary infused butter? It was melt in your mouth tender and one of the most flavourful steaks I’ve had. Unbelievable! Such a unique and enjoyable dinner with service to match the meal. I would have to recommend this be a regular menu item so others have the opportunity to enjoy it. It was that good!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I haven't been to Misty's in years and was looking for a great place to eat to celebrate a birthday. Sadly we will not be back. Started off with an espresso martini and fried artichoke hearts. The martini was great and the artichoke hearts were literally a blooming onion coating but on artichoke hearts. I was expecting something more. No big deal, I love artichoke hearts so I still ate them. I ordered the king prime rib with au gratin potatoes and French onion soup. I'll start with the soup because it was really good. The cheese topping was perfect and it tasted so delicious. My potatoes, were a potato salad consistency. I thought they'd be warm but they were not. They had a very noticeable shake of paprika on them and I was just surprised at how good they did not taste. I really had some high expectations of this food given the price point. My prime rib was also just ok. The juice was super salty. I asked for aujus and creamy horseradish and only got horseradish. Our server was not very attentive and didn't check on us again until our meal was done she finally asked how was everything. With a tip, 2 drinks , an appetizer and 2 meals it was $176. I expected to be wowed for a meal that expensive. We didn't complain or send anything back, we just wont be back unfortunately.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 2

We were shocked at how bad this was. It said it was a brewery, but only had non brewery beers (like Budweiser)- portions were small, expensive, bad presentation and not very good. The restaurant smelled like mildew. We were so embarrassed we brought out of town guests there.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

We were sat at a booth. We waited at least 15 minutes for someone to come over and take a drink order. As we were sitting there we both noticed a strong smell of mildew. I do mean strong. So we got up and sat at the bar. After waiting another 15 minutes we just walked out.

Atmosphere: 1

Lobster Mac was terrible

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 3

Stopped in site of low review, happy we did. Prime rib, chicken piccata, bisque were excellent. Service was fast. Atmosphere was good, a throwback to the old steak clubs. Very happy with the experience

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Blackened Prime Rib, Lobster Bisque