American Restaurants in Rushville

“A Hidden Gem Worth the Stop

Don’t let the humble exterior fool you—Fireside Inn is a true hidden gem. Tucked away in a very small town on the reservation, this place is clearly a local favorite and run with heart. The woman managing the establishment was incredibly kind and welcoming, instantly making us feel at home.

Inside, everything was clean, cozy, and inviting. It’s the kind of place where locals gather, and during our visit, we saw several members of the Lakota community come in to dine. There’s something special about being welcomed into a space that clearly means something to the people who live there.

The food? Absolutely fantastic. Every bite was delicious, and the coffee was hot and served with real cream—none of those little plastic cups. It's a small detail, but one that made a big difference.

Honestly, from the outside, we might have passed this place by—and that would have been a big mistake. If you're passing through, do yourself a favor and stop here. You'll be glad you did“