Super Secret Ice Cream

2213 Main St, Bethlehem

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Denise Ash

So delicious & such good flavors!

Rick Montoya

Large trans flag in the window.

We don't support people who push their left wing politics. You can have your opinions and you can keep them to yourself.

Camilla Sutter

A trip to the White mountains means a trip to this place. Totally delicious with fantastic flavors

Kevin Lewis Jr

The best ice cream I've ever had, including dairy free/vegan.

Randy Arborio

Great ice cream but even better waffle cone! I traveled 75 miles to try their ice cream. It was well worth the trip.

PAUL P

Great!

A.B. Hunter

Delicious, locally sourced unique flavors. A must visit in Bethlehem NH

K Payroll

I'm normally not an ice cream person but theirs is incredibly fresh with fresh fruit options. Knowledgable and fun staff, tons of great seating, outdoor patio games.... great little stop if you've spent the day outside. Great addition to our family vacation!

Daniela Wirth

Love love love this spot!! Their ice cream is DELICIOUS. I think my favorite flavor is their honeycomb but it's really hard to decide on just one. They have a good amount of seating inside and have cute ice cream themed books and coloring paper/crayons for kids too. I took my 4 year old there after school and he loved it. Highly recommend!!

Tony P.

Friendly staff. Nice inside and outside areas to eat. Unique ice cream flavors.

goonewman

We tasted all the choices today by sharing flights. It was fantastic!

Kelly Taranto

The honeycomb ice cream is a must.

Jea Kim

Wow. This might be the best ice cream I’ve had so far in the U.S.

At first, I thought the high ratings were just people riding a post-hike sugar high (and honestly, that might still be partly true). But most of the flavors I tried were genuinely fantastic. The ice cream flight came out to almost two pints, and even in shorts on a 50°F evening, we wiped it clean in under five minutes.

The flavors weren’t wild or experimental. Everything’s made in small batches, so the lineup seemed to change often. I didn’t see many of the flavors mentioned in older reviews, but 5/6 were hits. The sugar level was relatively restrained (by U.S. standards), so no sticky, sugary aftertaste. Also liked how they made the berry ice cream with yogurt.

Ranking the lineup:
Cantaloupe (my Melona bias) > Honey Comb > Mount Cabot Maple > Honey Berry Chip > Baa Baa Brambleberry >> Sugar Pie Pumpkin Chai (never been a pumpkin ice cream person).

David C

Best ice cream I have ever had, the honeycomb is a must try.

Amanda Richards

Busy, a little on the spendy side.

Loading...

Super Secret Ice Cream

2213 Main St, Bethlehem, NH 03574