Papa Jay's Pizzeria
18 Broadway, Dover
(603) 750-7272
Customers' Favorites
Pepperoni Special Pizza
Teriyaki Steak Tip Sub
Fried Dough Ball Bites
BBQ Roast Beef Sub
Mozzarella Sticks
John's BBQ Burger
Spinocoli Pizza
Boneless Wings
Chicken Wings
Loaded Pizza
Menu
Photos
+19 photos
+18 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
Tried the rib-eye steak and cheese sub. One of the best tasting steak and cheese subs I've had in a LONG time! No need for salt and pepper. Cheese was perfectly melted and mixed in with the shaved steak.
I’ve tried them twice now and will continue because they are pretty good!
The pizza is good but could be better. The dough was great, the cheese was great but the sauce was a little bland. I ordered mozzarella sticks and the sauce that came with those seemed to have more flavor so I spread it over my pizza and when I did that, the pizza was really good! Maybe it was just off for the pizza sauce those times but I’ll keep trying it to see…..
The...
The pizza is good but could be better. The dough was great, the cheese was great but the sauce was a little bland. I ordered mozzarella sticks and the sauce that came with those seemed to have more flavor so I spread it over my pizza and when I did that, the pizza was really good! Maybe it was just off for the pizza sauce those times but I’ll keep trying it to see…..
The...
Exactly what a pizza place should be, the beer tenders are great, service is exactly as expected, nothing fancy, but they aren't charging an arm and a leg either, their subs are good
You May Also Like
Moe’s Italian Sandwiches - 8 Pierce St
![]()
Sandwich Shop, Italian
Slow Burn Lounge - Dover - 505 Central Ave
![]()
Bar, Speakeasies, Cocktail Bar
Thai Taste - 499 Central Ave
![]()
Thai, Vegetarian