Papa Jay's Pizzeria

18 Broadway, Dover
(603) 750-7272

Recent Reviews Order Online Reserve

Customers' Favorites

Pepperoni Special Pizza

Teriyaki Steak Tip Sub

Fried Dough Ball Bites

BBQ Roast Beef Sub

Mozzarella Sticks

John's BBQ Burger

Spinocoli Pizza

Boneless Wings

Chicken Wings

Loaded Pizza

Photos

+26 photos

+25 photos

Add a photo

Order Online

Papajays

Doordash

Microworks

Trycaviar

Slicelife

Grubhub

Recent Reviews

After a recent experience, we had left a negative review for Papa Jays as opposed to reaching out to reconcile the issue. Jay had since reached out personally to remedy the situation and I will say I am very pleased with the response I received from Jay. My partner and I really appreciate the convenience and quality of Papa Jays and we will continue to be patrons of this establishment and highly recommend this eatery. I do apologize for my review as opposed to reaching out. Thank...

October 2025

Just got this with the wife, and hands down this is the best pizza we have had in New England. I’m not a food critic, but I have had a ton of pizza. And this is some of the best.

Not overloaded as to be unwieldy, crust was perfectly crispy and structurally sound, and all the ingredients were perfect. And even though they were busy, it was done in like, 20 minutes.

Incredible work, please keep making pizza like this. This is how it should...

September 2025

Tried for the first time tonight and the food was excellent. The service was great and my order was 100% accurate and VERY fairly priced. 1 pound of tenders and fries for $17.50 is awesome! I saw a handful of 1 star reviews and I have to say those are totally bogus they don’t accurately reflect this place at all. Will order again for sure

September 2025

More Reviews

Restaurants in Dover, NH

Papa Jay's Pizzeria

Customers' Favorites

Menu

Photos

Order Online

Recent Reviews

You May Also Like

Papa Jay's Pizzeria