Three Sisters Cake Shop

I hate to leave low reviews. My experience with three sisters cake was awesome, the quick prompt communication, the cake in itself looked amazing but it was so dry. It is disappointing to spend so much money on a cake, to cut it open, serve the guests and they only take a couple bites because it was so dry and not good tasting. Other than that, I really loved everything else.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 2

Service: 5

Three Sisters Cake Shop was an absolute dream to work with and exceeded every expectation we had. From start to finish, the entire process was seamless, stress-free, and incredibly well organized — exactly what you hope for when planning a wedding.
They went above and beyond by offering excellent gluten-free options for my now husband, who has celiac disease. Knowing that his needs were not only accommodated but treated with such care and attention meant so much to us and gave us complete peace of mind on our wedding day.
And the desserts — truly unforgettable. Three Sisters created the most delicious and beautifully curated array of desserts we could have ever asked for. Every single item was fresh, flavorful, and absolutely loved by our guests. We received countless compliments on how incredible everything tasted, with many people going back for seconds (and thirds).
If you are looking for a bakery that combines professionalism, thoughtfulness, and exceptional quality, Three Sisters Cake Shop is it. We couldn’t recommend them more and are so grateful they were part of our celebration.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Wedding Cake, Sugar Cookies, Mini Cookies

Working with Holly is amazing! Not only is she quick to respond and reliable….but the baked goods are FABULOUS! Pumpkin whoopie pies and cake pops to die for! I hope to work with Three Sisters Cake Shop for many weddings in the future!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

We used Three Sisters for our wedding cake/cupcakes and could not be more pleased. From the very first meeting, they were accommodating and helpful. We had our tasting over the summer but were having a fall wedding and wanted to taste some fall flavors so they even made us a set of cupcakes with fall flavors to try. We ended up decided on a two-tier cake with two different flavors and two batches of cupcakes with two more flavors. We had chocolate/salted caramel, almond, spiced cake, and apple cider donut. Everything was incredibly delicious! Our guests commented on it several times, with one even saying that usually wedding cake is not anything to rave about but ours certainly was! Three Sisters was incredibly easy to work with, very communicative, and gave us wonderful cake! We couldn't be happier!

Food: 5

Service: 5

Working with Three Sisters Bakery has been nothing but easy and delicious! We first met for a consultation with Holly. This consultation was super easy and we were able to try a bunch of different combinations. We ended up ordering lemon bars, whoopie pies, brownies, cookies and cupcakes. Holly was super knowledgeable about how many to order and was spot on! Everything was delicious and we will definitely be working with Three Sisters Bakery again.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I called to get my father a treat for his 93rd birthday. Although they don’t do a retail shop, they agreed to provide one wee cupcake to make his daughter happy. There are such good people in this world! He shared it with me and the cupcake was ridiculous! Full disclosure? He ate all of the buttercream frosting first.🤣

Food: 5

Service: 5

We were smart enough to choose Three Sisters Cake Shop to make our wedding cake and they did not disappoint! They were incredibly responsive and organized, answering every question we had throughout the process. The introductory appointment was so helpful, not only getting to try slices of all of their amazing flavors but it gave us the opportunity to talk about our vision for the cake. They were all so delicious, we ended up choosing a different flavor for each tier! After sending a handful of pictures, they created the most beautiful and delicious wedding cake we had ever had! They made sure to deliver the cake promptly and ensure it was staged beautifully at the venue. The cake was exactly what we had envisioned and it was one of the first times we had ever seen guests ask for seconds. We can’t wait for our 1-year anniversary cake and cannot recommend them enough!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

They made us a cutting cake and cupcakes for wedding this August, not only were the gorgeous, but delicious and affordable! Couldn't recommend them enough if you need them for any event you may have coming!

My wedding was in April and I decided to go with Three Sisters for our cake. Cake was everything I wanted for my wedding cake and was absolutely perfect! I have celiac and this baker is the only one in the state that could do a gluten free marble cake. We decided on a small heart shaped cake for us and 3 large sheet cakes for our guests. It was so good and my guests had no idea that it was gluten free. I had sent references images and they created the perfect wedding cake! I also did not have a reaction after eating this cake and they assured me that they would take every precaution when making my cake.

Food: 5

Service: 5

We had Three Sisters Cake shop make our wedding cake a desserts, including cookies and whoopie pies. They were so amazing from start to finish- and everything was incredibly delicious. Their team was amazing. They worked within our budget, were super easy to communicate and make adjustments with. Our only regret is not ordering more whoopie pies because they were a hot commodity at our wedding!!

The hardest part of working with them was narrowing down what flavor cake and frosting to get. We loved Three Sisters and can't wait to go back and get treats for years to come! Thank you Holly and team!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I've never been disappointed coming here! The ladies are lovely to deal with and nail my order every single time! This is the second time we ordered a special cake from them. It's delicious and adorable!

This was my second time ordering but frst cookie order. Beautiful and delicious cookies. Great online ordering system and easy pickup. So happy fo have Three Sisters here in Dover!

We were visiting some cousins from Dover, NH and went into the 3 Sisters bakery. We noticed they have cakes to order.2
We asked them where we could find a bakery near y that we can buy cupcakes for. They were great !! They made a dozen of cupcakes for us and then ripped them off with a strawberry. We were very hrateful and then ripped them cupcakes were delicious.

The cupcakes were delicious and beautiful. The icing was super fluffy / not too dense. 10/10

Ordered a Birthday Cake for my 10 year old grandson. The results were awesome!