Great Island Eatery

116 Morgans Wy, New Castle

Recent Reviews

Sort by
lkgfred

Great views of the marina. Great place if you like to wait!! Waited over 5 minutes for soft drinks. .Very disorganized. Didn’t know who our waitress was. Waited over 30 minutes for our food when others who sat down after us were served and finished their meals because the waitress forgot to put our order in. Husband and I both got the fish and chips. The food was warm at best but the fries were cold and the cole slaw tasted sour. I bet this meal is really good when served hot. Gave 2 stars because they comped our meals due to the delay.

Marge Zimmer

Could not get my car through security gate and park in the handicapped space, both myself and my guest do not walk well, on a hot day do not walk far, there is a new gate in both directions preventing restaurant guests from entering, signs said something about parking elsewhere for the other restaurant, nothing about handicapped parking for Great Island Restaurant. I used to bring visitors to eat at The Green Bean and there were no gates then.

Parking: No parking available, just a sign about Latitudes parking, elsewhere, the lot is not paved so difficult to walk or push a walker over, this could be illegal barring customers from the handicapped parking spaces, if not should be illegal under the ADA regulations, not good for business

Wheelchair accessibility: My guest and myself both have walkers and I have a handicapped plate on my car, we were barred from the handicapped spaces today , we were there for lunch but did not get to the restaurant, not worth getting a broken hip for.

Tucker Blosser

The people there were sweet and caring

Kid-friendliness: Nice and open for kids to run around

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Sheila Taylor

Delicious food, great views and friendly service. They even have gluten free bread when requested. French fries are in a separate fryer, so they are also gluten free!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Shane Smith

A great little New Castle secret!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Johanna Hansen

Best fish and chips, plus a great view

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

zippo46

The view is great. The menu is extremely limited. There are three fish entrees; four burger entrees; and four other entrees, which includes three entrees for kids. The food is average. I had the “Burning Down the House” burger, which was nowhere near as spicy as I expected.

Pascal Evans

Architecture et design parfaits dans cette auberge élégante, chic et raffinée sur une île où absolument tout est beau et harmonieux. Les lits sont ultra-confortables et chaque chambre offre un intérieur spacieux et très élégant. À quelques pas de l'auberge, une superbe plage nous invite à la contemplation. Great Island Inn nous a offert des vacances de rêve, dans un lieu enchanteur et parfait à tout égard. C'est désormais notre rendez-vous annuel du mois de novembre. N'hésitez pas, réservez!

Gordon Manson

We had a lovely night, and can’t wait to go back. We stayed in one of the King bed rooms which are really studio apartments in size. A short 3 minute walk down to a great small rocky beach. There is also a fantastic breakfast/lunch spot nextdoor called The Islander Cafe.

Stephanie McCabe

My husband and I travel quite a bit and I think this is the first time I've ever heard him say he'd miss a place. The Great Island Inn gets everything right. Seriously, everything. It's quiet, it's cozy, it has all of the amenities you'd need and is in a beautiful area close to the beach. We were fortunate enough to stay for 4 days and loved our time at the Inn. We will definitely be back. It was one of my all time favorite places to stay! Thanks so much for all you do to make the Inn so lovely!

Loading...