Mystic Sugar Bakery

Name: Mystic Sugar Bakery
Address: 28 Norcross Cir, North Conway, New Hampshire, 03860, US
Telephone: (603) 730-5026
Price range: $
Rating: 4.9

$ • Bakery, Custom Cakes, Cupcakes

Hours:
28 Norcross Cir, North Conway
(603) 730-5026

About Mystic Sugar Bakery

Mystic Sugar Bakery is a charming and whimsical bakery that offers an array of delightful treats. The decor is magical, creating a warm and inviting atmosphere. The menu features an impressive selection, including Chocolate Chip Cookies, Mount Doom and The Orc Cupcakes, Stuffed BLT, Chicken Salad, and Board-carved Ham and Swiss Sandwiches, as well as Mac and Cheese. The cupcakes are particularly noteworthy, with their moist texture and exceptional flavors.

Customers praise the bakery's friendly staff and the overall exceptional quality of their homemade offerings. They describe the muffins, scones, and cookies as absolutely delicious, with the cranberry walnut orange muffin being particularly moist and flavorful, and the blueberry lemon scones as not even a hint of being too dry. The chocolate chip cookies are considered the best customers have ever had, as the bakery does not overload their recipes with sugar, allowing the flavors to shine through.

The bakery also offers a variety of cupcakes with distinct flavors that are not overly sweet. In addition, the bakery hosts English Tea Time on every second Sunday, adding to the whimsical and charming experience. Customers describe the overall atmosphere as a "very beautiful cute little mysterious themed cafe" and a "must visit" for those in the area.