First and foremost, if you’re hesitating, go for it!
I just hired Mystic Sugar Bakery for my wedding, and I could not be happier. We ordered our wedding cake as well as many small pastries for the event (brownies, cookies, and cupcakes). We had over a hundred guests and many of them with allergies or dietary restrictions, but Christy worked tirelessly and closely with me to make sure everything that was served at our wedding was safe for everyone. She was extremely accommodating and together, we were able to make sure every single guest got dessert, she even went as far as making some extra pastries for those guests who just had too many allergies to eat the regular desserts we had ordered. The cake looked beautiful and was delicious, and many of my guests came to us to tell us they loved their desserts and were really touched that we thought about them and their allergies.
Despite running a busy business, Christy was always very patient and available. I was able to reach her when needed and despite all the crazy requests we made, I never felt like I was burdening her, she was always nice and happy to assist, and even went out of her way to buy a specific brand of chocolate chips (the only brand one of our guests could have). It really made the wedding planning that much easier for us.
The desserts were delivered on time and set up very quickly! Christy worked with our coordinator to make sure everything was where and as it should be, I didn’t even need to be around for that part, but the final result was great! The table looked beautiful!
I would absolutely hire them again if I had the chance, and I would recommend them to anyone asking! Thank you Mystic Sugar Bakery, and thank you Christy!
P.S.: I don’t currently have any pictures, but I’m hoping some of my guests, and our photographer, were able to capture her work. I will update this comment with pictures if I can find any.
Becki Reitz
AMAZING!! Absolutely delicious and will be coming back for sure.
Jimmy Milanoski
So I've been to bakeries all over the country and this bakery is my favorite. The muffins, scones and cookies are absolutely delicious. I tried the cranberry walnut orange muffin, wow so moist and bursting with flavors. My wife loved the blueberry lemon scones, not even a hint of being too dry, they were delicious. My son said they had the best chocolate chip cookie hes ever had. The main reason is they don't overload their recipes with sugar, they actually use tastefull ingredients. You can actually taste the flavors and not a sugar sweet bomb like many other bakeries. We look forward to coming up to this bakery every summer. We also bought a dozen cupcakes and they also have distinct flavors and are not overly sweet . So many flavors to try We couldn't try them all. I did have to leave some cupcake icing off. We can't wait to go back.
Josh Hixson
The breakfast biscuit is crazy good!!
Jenna Hodge
My family and I made our first trip to Mystic Sugar Bakery today. We loved the creative Harry Potter themed names and the cupcakes are delicious! Perfectly moist cake with just the right amount of flavor and filling, topped with light and fluffy frosting.
The woman at the counter was very nice and even offered to hold our cupcakes while we had lunch so they wouldn’t melt in the car.
We will be back!
Soumya Khatri
Very beautiful cute little mysterious themed cafe! A must visit if you’re in town. Amazing cupcakes and sweet treats with coffee. Loved the vibe! They also do English Tea Time on every second Sundays!
Marissa Blake
OMGgggg the BEST chocolate chip cooking I have EVER had!!! This was our first time there, and everyone in my family got something different and we all loved what we got!
Mary Cain
Just go and thank me later. Treats are heavenly. 🧁🧁🧁🍪🍪🍪I'm not sure if they allow bringing food on the train ride next door but it's worth sneaking in these mouthwateringly good yummies!
Ashlee Scala
I almost walked right passed it after my train ride. I walked in and Pirates of the Caribbean was playing. All the cupcakes were themed to the movie. The cupcakes look wonderful, I can't wait to dig in.
Katelyn Colacchio
Such a sweet little bakery with delicious treats! Thank you so much
Fun little bakery. They change their theme every few weeks. During our visit, they were on a Willy Wonka theme. The new Willie Wonka movie was playing on a TV in the lounge/dining area, and all of the cupcakes were named after characters in the Willy Wonka world. We bought some Mocha Maccaroons, a Samoa brownie, a Salted Caramel cookie, and a "Mr. Bleacher" cupcake, which was lemon and blueberry. All were delicious. Nice little lounge area as well.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cupcakes
Erica Chamberlain
We got several cupcakes and loved every single one. Cooked perfectly. Perfect amount of frosting. Great selections. Thank you! We will be stopping every time we are in the area.
Isabella Monbouquette
I went here for the first time today and it was lovely! I got the chocolate cannoli cupcake (though it had a way more fun Harry Potter themed name I can’t remember now!). The chocolate cupcake was light and moist and delicious, probably the best chocolate cake I’ve ever had. The frosting was perfectly sweet, not overbearing. My friend got a cookie and a coffee and also loved hers! The cafe has a super cute vibe and the staff were friendly. I definitely recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Molly Hill
Ordered a chocolate overload cake for my moms birthday and first of all it looked AMAZING! Second of all everyone said this was by far the best we’ve ever had, the cake was moist and the frosting was light and fluffy.
First and foremost, if you’re hesitating, go for it!
I just hired Mystic Sugar Bakery for my wedding, and I could not be happier. We ordered our wedding cake as well as many small pastries for the event (brownies, cookies, and cupcakes). We had over a hundred guests and many of them with allergies or dietary restrictions, but Christy worked tirelessly and closely with me to make sure everything that was served at our wedding was safe for everyone. She was extremely accommodating and together, we were able to make sure every single guest got dessert, she even went as far as making some extra pastries for those guests who just had too many allergies to eat the regular desserts we had ordered. The cake looked beautiful and was delicious, and many of my guests came to us to tell us they loved their desserts and were really touched that we thought about them and their allergies.
Despite running a busy business, Christy was always very patient and available. I was able to reach her when needed and despite all the crazy requests we made, I never felt like I was burdening her, she was always nice and happy to assist, and even went out of her way to buy a specific brand of chocolate chips (the only brand one of our guests could have). It really made the wedding planning that much easier for us.
The desserts were delivered on time and set up very quickly! Christy worked with our coordinator to make sure everything was where and as it should be, I didn’t even need to be around for that part, but the final result was great! The table looked beautiful!
I would absolutely hire them again if I had the chance, and I would recommend them to anyone asking! Thank you Mystic Sugar Bakery, and thank you Christy!
P.S.: I don’t currently have any pictures, but I’m hoping some of my guests, and our photographer, were able to capture her work. I will update this comment with pictures if I can find any.
AMAZING!! Absolutely delicious and will be coming back for sure.
So I've been to bakeries all over the country and this bakery is my favorite. The muffins, scones and cookies are absolutely delicious. I tried the cranberry walnut orange muffin, wow so moist and bursting with flavors. My wife loved the blueberry lemon scones, not even a hint of being too dry, they were delicious. My son said they had the best chocolate chip cookie hes ever had. The main reason is they don't overload their recipes with sugar, they actually use tastefull ingredients. You can actually taste the flavors and not a sugar sweet bomb like many other bakeries. We look forward to coming up to this bakery every summer. We also bought a dozen cupcakes and they also have distinct flavors and are not overly sweet . So many flavors to try We couldn't try them all. I did have to leave some cupcake icing off. We can't wait to go back.
The breakfast biscuit is crazy good!!
My family and I made our first trip to Mystic Sugar Bakery today. We loved the creative Harry Potter themed names and the cupcakes are delicious! Perfectly moist cake with just the right amount of flavor and filling, topped with light and fluffy frosting. The woman at the counter was very nice and even offered to hold our cupcakes while we had lunch so they wouldn’t melt in the car. We will be back!
Very beautiful cute little mysterious themed cafe! A must visit if you’re in town. Amazing cupcakes and sweet treats with coffee. Loved the vibe! They also do English Tea Time on every second Sundays!
OMGgggg the BEST chocolate chip cooking I have EVER had!!! This was our first time there, and everyone in my family got something different and we all loved what we got!
Just go and thank me later. Treats are heavenly. 🧁🧁🧁🍪🍪🍪I'm not sure if they allow bringing food on the train ride next door but it's worth sneaking in these mouthwateringly good yummies!
I almost walked right passed it after my train ride. I walked in and Pirates of the Caribbean was playing. All the cupcakes were themed to the movie. The cupcakes look wonderful, I can't wait to dig in.
Such a sweet little bakery with delicious treats! Thank you so much
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cupcakes, Cinnamon Rolls
Restaurantji Recommends
Fun little bakery. They change their theme every few weeks. During our visit, they were on a Willy Wonka theme. The new Willie Wonka movie was playing on a TV in the lounge/dining area, and all of the cupcakes were named after characters in the Willy Wonka world. We bought some Mocha Maccaroons, a Samoa brownie, a Salted Caramel cookie, and a "Mr. Bleacher" cupcake, which was lemon and blueberry. All were delicious. Nice little lounge area as well.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cupcakes
We got several cupcakes and loved every single one. Cooked perfectly. Perfect amount of frosting. Great selections. Thank you! We will be stopping every time we are in the area.
I went here for the first time today and it was lovely! I got the chocolate cannoli cupcake (though it had a way more fun Harry Potter themed name I can’t remember now!). The chocolate cupcake was light and moist and delicious, probably the best chocolate cake I’ve ever had. The frosting was perfectly sweet, not overbearing. My friend got a cookie and a coffee and also loved hers! The cafe has a super cute vibe and the staff were friendly. I definitely recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ordered a chocolate overload cake for my moms birthday and first of all it looked AMAZING! Second of all everyone said this was by far the best we’ve ever had, the cake was moist and the frosting was light and fluffy.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chocolate Cake
Very charming place with delicious goods!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cupcakes
Loading...