Mystic Sugar Bakery

28 Norcross Cir, North Conway
(603) 730-5026

Customers' Favorites

Menu

Photos

+28 photos
+27 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

First and foremost, if you’re hesitating, go for it!

I just hired Mystic Sugar Bakery for my wedding, and I could not be happier. We ordered our wedding cake as well as many small pastries for the event (brownies, cookies, and cupcakes). We had over a hundred guests and many of them with allergies or dietary restrictions, but Christy worked tirelessly and closely with me to make sure everything that was served at our wedding was safe for everyone. She was...
So I've been to bakeries all over the country and this bakery is my favorite. The muffins, scones and cookies are absolutely delicious. I tried the cranberry walnut orange muffin, wow so moist and bursting with flavors. My wife loved the blueberry lemon scones, not even a hint of being too dry, they were delicious. My son said they had the best chocolate chip cookie hes ever had. The main reason is they don't overload their recipes with sugar, they actually use...
My family and I made our first trip to Mystic Sugar Bakery today. We loved the creative Harry Potter themed names and the cupcakes are delicious! Perfectly moist cake with just the right amount of flavor and filling, topped with light and fluffy frosting. The woman at the counter was very nice and even offered to hold our cupcakes while we had lunch so they wouldn’t melt in the car. We will be back!

More Reviews