The people here are super nice and considerate. We had a fun time in their cute nicely decorated shop and I loved their broccoli cheddar soup and cappuccino. They went out of their way by remaking the coffee that we accidentally spilled. God bless
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Dawn Robinson
Coffee cake was awful waste of my money.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 2
Fred H
Great place to get a fully loaded New York style bagelSalmon, cream cheese, tomato, onion and capers ?There's also a couple tables outside, definitely a hidden
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lily Althea
Good bagels!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Dale Matt
Bagels and really good. Service needs improvement. Stood at the register for over 5 minutes without a single employee acknowledging me. I get they were busy making sandwiches and coffee but could have been a whole lot
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 5
Service: 1
John Stuart
I went to the Bagel Mill for the first time the other and I was pretty upset that I had not already been here before ! This is the spot for bagels in Western NH. 5 stars across the board. The food , the service , the other people there, the spot all amazing. The people I talked to there made me feel like I’ve been going there my whole life. There’s vegan cream cheese options. Day old bagels to take home . forty cent bagels to take home to the dog! A changing station in the restroom. Just a super clean cafe. Will definitely be back and often ! Try the salt bagel ! All the bagels are vegan except for the egg bagel and the cheese bagel.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Madeline Hall
why have a phone number if you don’t answer the phone?
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 2
Lisa Martin
Great Pumpernickel bagel with garlic cream cheese was awesome.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
jay galgano
Ordered bagel with scrambled egg and cheese. They put the egg in a plastic cup and put it in the microwave.Bagel places usually cook the eggs on griddle, not in a microwave. The whole thing was tasteless…
Melissa Poulin
Greetings, we visited Bagel Mill over the weekend as a pitstop during our long motorcycle journey. It's a charming place with an interesting choice of music, and they serve incredible bagels along with good coffee. However, there is room for improvement in terms of service; it appeared somewhat disorganized, resulting in a rather lengthy wait for just 2 coffees and a bagel. Nevertheless, despite the wait, I would recommend the place, and I did enjoy my visit.
A gem in Peterborough's culinary crown. Delicious fresh bagels that can compete with any from anywhere. The knowledgeable and friendly staff can guide you through a myriad of scrumptious choices. The live music wraps the entire experience in warmth and comfort.
Robin Holland
It was our first time there. SO delicious with a friendly staff! We'll be back!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Will Holden
Stopped in driving through to grab coffee and a sandwich. We had heard about this place before and we’re expecting a lot more. Mocha latte tasted like chocolate milk, almost zero coffee flavor. Sandwich was not worth 10 bucks it was on a bagel and much smaller than expected, with very little in the sandwich and so little sauce you couldn’t even taste it. Sandwich would have been worth it if it was $5 or $6, although I know inflation is destroying everyone, at least make the sandwich bigger. I never leave reviews, I was just expecting a lot more! Tough to give even 3 stars, I feel bad to give a low review as I know this is someone’s business, but I am just being honest about my experience.
Ariel Sehr
We ordered bagels for our post-wedding brunch in Nelson, NH. Amanda was great to communicate with and helped us order the right amount of cream cheese and lox for our guests. Everyone LOVED the bagels, especially the egg bagels. Thanks Bagel Mill!
Seacoast Homes with Sharon Parker
We were on the road and getting hungry. I was looking for a good place to stop for a sandwich, and we found it! The bagel mill was perfect. We each enjoyed a fresh made sandwich on the bagel of our choosing, and sat outside to eat. The bagel was so good I bought some for the road.
The people here are super nice and considerate. We had a fun time in their cute nicely decorated shop and I loved their broccoli cheddar soup and cappuccino. They went out of their way by remaking the coffee that we accidentally spilled. God bless
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Coffee cake was awful waste of my money.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 2
Great place to get a fully loaded New York style bagelSalmon, cream cheese, tomato, onion and capers ?There's also a couple tables outside, definitely a hidden
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Good bagels!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Bagels and really good. Service needs improvement. Stood at the register for over 5 minutes without a single employee acknowledging me. I get they were busy making sandwiches and coffee but could have been a whole lot
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 5
Service: 1
I went to the Bagel Mill for the first time the other and I was pretty upset that I had not already been here before ! This is the spot for bagels in Western NH. 5 stars across the board. The food , the service , the other people there, the spot all amazing. The people I talked to there made me feel like I’ve been going there my whole life. There’s vegan cream cheese options. Day old bagels to take home . forty cent bagels to take home to the dog! A changing station in the restroom. Just a super clean cafe. Will definitely be back and often ! Try the salt bagel ! All the bagels are vegan except for the egg bagel and the cheese bagel.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
why have a phone number if you don’t answer the phone?
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 2
Great Pumpernickel bagel with garlic cream cheese was awesome.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ordered bagel with scrambled egg and cheese. They put the egg in a plastic cup and put it in the microwave.Bagel places usually cook the eggs on griddle, not in a microwave. The whole thing was tasteless…
Greetings, we visited Bagel Mill over the weekend as a pitstop during our long motorcycle journey. It's a charming place with an interesting choice of music, and they serve incredible bagels along with good coffee. However, there is room for improvement in terms of service; it appeared somewhat disorganized, resulting in a rather lengthy wait for just 2 coffees and a bagel. Nevertheless, despite the wait, I would recommend the place, and I did enjoy my visit.
Restaurantji Recommends
A gem in Peterborough's culinary crown. Delicious fresh bagels that can compete with any from anywhere. The knowledgeable and friendly staff can guide you through a myriad of scrumptious choices. The live music wraps the entire experience in warmth and comfort.
It was our first time there. SO delicious with a friendly staff! We'll be back!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Stopped in driving through to grab coffee and a sandwich. We had heard about this place before and we’re expecting a lot more. Mocha latte tasted like chocolate milk, almost zero coffee flavor. Sandwich was not worth 10 bucks it was on a bagel and much smaller than expected, with very little in the sandwich and so little sauce you couldn’t even taste it. Sandwich would have been worth it if it was $5 or $6, although I know inflation is destroying everyone, at least make the sandwich bigger. I never leave reviews, I was just expecting a lot more! Tough to give even 3 stars, I feel bad to give a low review as I know this is someone’s business, but I am just being honest about my experience.
We ordered bagels for our post-wedding brunch in Nelson, NH. Amanda was great to communicate with and helped us order the right amount of cream cheese and lox for our guests. Everyone LOVED the bagels, especially the egg bagels. Thanks Bagel Mill!
We were on the road and getting hungry. I was looking for a good place to stop for a sandwich, and we found it! The bagel mill was perfect. We each enjoyed a fresh made sandwich on the bagel of our choosing, and sat outside to eat. The bagel was so good I bought some for the road.