Joe's New York Pizza

1981 Woodbury Ave, Portsmouth
(603) 766-5566

Recent Reviews

Dina Barrera

Prices here are ridiculous, I placed an order and for 3 large pizza it was a total of $75??????. On top of the fact there pizza is gross. Almost 30 for a Buffalo pizza??? Gotta be kidding. And if I could not give any stars I wouldn't. Because 1 star is still too much for them.

Food: 1

Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza, Chicken Pizza

Theresa “Terry” Thibodeau

One of the best tasting pizzas in the area.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Favorite Pizza

Larry Kindberg

Pizza slices were old and

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 4

Nicholas Boynton

I've been to a couple locations and unfortunately this one has been by far the worst. The website items are inconsistent with what is available at the location, and the food that is available was not quality. The chicken bomb calzone had next to no chicken, and was tasting off. The fried dough balls were a couple cinnamon knots that were dusted with so much cinnamon I gagged when trying to swallow some. The garlic knots were just overly oiled bits of dough that tasted subpar. We also tried a bacon pineapple pizza that was just a mess in general. I won't be trying this location out again, as I have had better experiences with their other locations, and recommend you consider elsewhere. Friendly staff, just not food worth the price.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 5

A C

A little local pizza joint that gets the basics just right.Ordered a half and half pizza, buffalo and 4 cheese to test it out.The buffalo sauce was tangy with heat and complimented the four cheese given its basic presentation.Crust is great, breads just right and the dough is a little on the softer end given its NY styling.Overall, great lil spot to grab a fast slice. We will be back.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Angela L.

The employees keep their glove on to handle money and answer phone but never put clean ones on before handling food again. One employee don't even bother to wear gloves. Wings are bone in with batter and very fatty. Pizza sauce had absolutely no flavor yet pizza was extremely salty.

Greg Taylor

Pizza was good and the people were

Food: 5

Service: 5

THX 1138

NOT NY pizza not even

Food: 1

Christina Jacobs

First time ordering the basic cheese pizza. I never rate anything but I have to on this. SAUCE? Either they forgot to put it on or you have to pay for extra to get some. I won't order frome this place again.

Food: 2

Anthony Rivera

I went in here and bought 4 slices which were $30 the food was cold and the slices were hours old I don't recommend this

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 3

Ravi Kommajosyula

Stopped to get a slice of pizza driving up to Maine and this really hit the spot!! Will totally come back again

Abigail Bachhuber

Went for garlic pesto knots and mozzarella sticks. The knots have fresh garlic, but is not potent. For looking well seasoned, I only tasted the pesto. The mozzarella sticks were crispy on the outside and in a 5min drive they were almost solid. Overall, not too bad. Not sure I'd go for these two appetizers again.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 3

rj r

Great service. Pizza by the slice, with good selection to choose from. Family got 6 slices and drinks on a Sunday afternoon, price was decent, and every slice tasted great.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Four Cheese Pizza, Veggie Pizza, Pizza by Slice, Pepperoni Bacon Pizza

Franco S.

Ordered a chicken finger sub with mayo, tomatoe, lettuce, pickles and provolone cheese today on 7-30-23 I got it with no cheese and tomatoe all for a rough total of 12.75.. who charges that ridiculous amount of money for a 5-6 inch sub with items that were requested and paid for and never received on order... most sub shops I've been to I normally take the other half home ... this was more like a slider !!!!! The owner should be embaressed and should RE-VISIT food prices ...a total disappointment

Andrew Kelly

Only one employee was there. He was very very busy. Pizza was undercooked but the taste was good. Ownership should take more Ownership.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 3

Load More