Have got my daughter’s birthday cake here the last 3 years. Not only do they look amazing, they taste amazing too. Never dry and very flavorful. Everyone is always very friendly and helpful when you come in and really helpful with answering any questions etc.
Have also enjoyed the cupcakes many times!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Bridget Owens
From the moment we first interacted with the wonderful staff at Sugar Love, we felt so lucky to have Mallory and her team. This bakery is inviting, fun, and the service is top tier. We had the most beautiful wedding cake that tasted INCREDIBLE thanks to this wonderful team. We can’t thank you enough!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Paige Corum
This bakery is great! I had customized sugar cookies made for my engagement party. I had sent inspo pics from Pinterest & she nailed it! Cookies were absolutely delicious too!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ashleigh Jamgochian
another great cake from sugar love! it was exactly what we wanted and it was delicious!
Mohammed Mansour
I don’t know why I got my order refunded when I was trying to ask for another cake a separate one and I got my cake refunded right after paying for it I don’t know who I was talking too but they were not complying and ignoring me choosing when to answer which was disrespectful I was trying to get a surprise cake for my moms birthday and I got it ruined
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Carolyn Champy
Sugar love baking saved our day. When you place an order for 36 baby shower cupcakes with an individual home bake shop and the order was never fulfilled, just come here. So very accommodating and friendly. Grateful from the bottom of our 💕
Alicia E
I needed a small cake for my son’s birthday and I felt it was super last minute but they got it done and it was perfect! Almost identical to the inspo pic I sent AND delicious. Thank you!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake
Corrine DiRuzza
I had ordered a cake for my son’s 6th birthday and graduation day. I had ordered a two tier shark cake with strawberry filling and cream cheese frosting which totaled too 150$ all together plus tip. Mallory was great from start to finish and had created a beautiful cake ( especially on short notice on my end ). Communication was amazing especially for the short few days we had spoke. The cake was a hit and my son had adored it. The only feedback I have aside from all the wonderful positives I have is that both cakes were unfortunately dry on the inside. I wasn’t sure if maybe there were over baked but under the frosting you could see the sides of the cake are over baked/ on the darker on the sides, which just made for a more denser cake vs spongy. Cutting into the first tier there wasn’t much of the strawberry filling which is an extra 10$ of charge, but cutting into the second tier of the cake there was definitely more filling ( and more cream cheese frosting, yum ! ). Over all Mallory was wonderful and the cake was fantastic, for the price of the cake I did wish that it wasn’t as dry and had a bit more filling.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
Super Taster
I always look forward to picking up my cakes, Sugar Love Baking always delivers! Execution is always top notch, they are always super friendly and the place is super inviting! I love it here 🤍 I forgot the most important piece cakes are delicious!!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
MAYHEM TATTOO
A client brought one of our artists in some of their baked goods in appreciation of his new tattoo and to die for! Excellent
I wanted to share my thoughts about the cake we ordered. Unfortunately, I don't think it's quite worth the $225 we spent—it seemed a bit basic and smaller than expected. We also tried the cupcakes this week, and while I was looking forward to them, the vanilla and confetti flavors were really dry. I probably should’ve noticed that earlier! Just wanted to give some feedback.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 2
Melissa Miller
I so wanted to love the cupcakes...but, I didn't. Went during the week around 2pm. Got a vanilla cupcake with buttercream/crisco frosting with sprinkles. The cupcake was TINY for $4.25! Not only that, but it was so dry! The frosting is made with crisco and boy you can taste it lingering in your mouth- not a fan..it was more shortening than butter, unfortunetly. And asking what the ingredients are because you have allergies isn't an unheard thing. And yes I did give my business card after I purchased the cupcake and well before I tasted it since I went next door and had a salad at Romano's!!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 4
Satin Austin
Amazing cake and staff! The cake came out exactly how I wanted, and tasted even better.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake
FoodPrincess
Service was friendly and place was nice. I get a strawberry pop tart, brown sugar cinnamon pop tart, 2 macaroons and one of those strawberry cookies with the buttercream frosting in this middle. The macaroons and the pop tarts were pretty good. My one complaint about the stuff I got is it was overall way too sweet. The frosting in the middle of the strawberry cookies was so sickeningly sweet I couldn't finish it. The cotton candy macaroon filling was also pretty overwhelming with sugar and I love to make everything I eat sweet. I offered everything to my boyfriend also and he thought the same.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
Artem Evdokimov
Stopped by to get a cake. People were nice polite, and helpful, overall great atmosphere.
Unfortunately the cake itself was meh. Maybe I am spoiled by the high level of European pastry that I am accustomed to, but this particular confection was far too sweet, far too lardy (as opposed to buttery), the flavor was very simple (basically just vanilla, the chocolate flavor was lost somewhere), and the dough was heavy and clung to the teeth. The buttercream frosting was not edible - none of the folks who tried the cake were able to actually eat the frosting. Sorry folks, you run a nice bakery but that cake was just awful.
Have got my daughter’s birthday cake here the last 3 years. Not only do they look amazing, they taste amazing too. Never dry and very flavorful. Everyone is always very friendly and helpful when you come in and really helpful with answering any questions etc.
Have also enjoyed the cupcakes many times!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
From the moment we first interacted with the wonderful staff at Sugar Love, we felt so lucky to have Mallory and her team. This bakery is inviting, fun, and the service is top tier. We had the most beautiful wedding cake that tasted INCREDIBLE thanks to this wonderful team. We can’t thank you enough!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This bakery is great! I had customized sugar cookies made for my engagement party. I had sent inspo pics from Pinterest & she nailed it! Cookies were absolutely delicious too!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
another great cake from sugar love! it was exactly what we wanted and it was delicious!
I don’t know why I got my order refunded when I was trying to ask for another cake a separate one and I got my cake refunded right after paying for it I don’t know who I was talking too but they were not complying and ignoring me choosing when to answer which was disrespectful I was trying to get a surprise cake for my moms birthday and I got it ruined
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Sugar love baking saved our day. When you place an order for 36 baby shower cupcakes with an individual home bake shop and the order was never fulfilled, just come here. So very accommodating and friendly. Grateful from the bottom of our 💕
I needed a small cake for my son’s birthday and I felt it was super last minute but they got it done and it was perfect! Almost identical to the inspo pic I sent AND delicious. Thank you!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake
I had ordered a cake for my son’s 6th birthday and graduation day. I had ordered a two tier shark cake with strawberry filling and cream cheese frosting which totaled too 150$ all together plus tip. Mallory was great from start to finish and had created a beautiful cake ( especially on short notice on my end ). Communication was amazing especially for the short few days we had spoke. The cake was a hit and my son had adored it. The only feedback I have aside from all the wonderful positives I have is that both cakes were unfortunately dry on the inside. I wasn’t sure if maybe there were over baked but under the frosting you could see the sides of the cake are over baked/ on the darker on the sides, which just made for a more denser cake vs spongy. Cutting into the first tier there wasn’t much of the strawberry filling which is an extra 10$ of charge, but cutting into the second tier of the cake there was definitely more filling ( and more cream cheese frosting, yum ! ). Over all Mallory was wonderful and the cake was fantastic, for the price of the cake I did wish that it wasn’t as dry and had a bit more filling.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
I always look forward to picking up my cakes, Sugar Love Baking always delivers! Execution is always top notch, they are always super friendly and the place is super inviting! I love it here 🤍 I forgot the most important piece cakes are delicious!!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
A client brought one of our artists in some of their baked goods in appreciation of his new tattoo and to die for! Excellent
Restaurantji Recommends
I wanted to share my thoughts about the cake we ordered. Unfortunately, I don't think it's quite worth the $225 we spent—it seemed a bit basic and smaller than expected. We also tried the cupcakes this week, and while I was looking forward to them, the vanilla and confetti flavors were really dry. I probably should’ve noticed that earlier! Just wanted to give some feedback.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 2
I so wanted to love the cupcakes...but, I didn't. Went during the week around 2pm. Got a vanilla cupcake with buttercream/crisco frosting with sprinkles. The cupcake was TINY for $4.25! Not only that, but it was so dry! The frosting is made with crisco and boy you can taste it lingering in your mouth- not a fan..it was more shortening than butter, unfortunetly. And asking what the ingredients are because you have allergies isn't an unheard thing. And yes I did give my business card after I purchased the cupcake and well before I tasted it since I went next door and had a salad at Romano's!!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 4
Amazing cake and staff! The cake came out exactly how I wanted, and tasted even better.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake
Service was friendly and place was nice. I get a strawberry pop tart, brown sugar cinnamon pop tart, 2 macaroons and one of those strawberry cookies with the buttercream frosting in this middle. The macaroons and the pop tarts were pretty good. My one complaint about the stuff I got is it was overall way too sweet. The frosting in the middle of the strawberry cookies was so sickeningly sweet I couldn't finish it. The cotton candy macaroon filling was also pretty overwhelming with sugar and I love to make everything I eat sweet. I offered everything to my boyfriend also and he thought the same.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
Stopped by to get a cake. People were nice polite, and helpful, overall great atmosphere.
Unfortunately the cake itself was meh. Maybe I am spoiled by the high level of European pastry that I am accustomed to, but this particular confection was far too sweet, far too lardy (as opposed to buttery), the flavor was very simple (basically just vanilla, the chocolate flavor was lost somewhere), and the dough was heavy and clung to the teeth. The buttercream frosting was not edible - none of the folks who tried the cake were able to actually eat the frosting. Sorry folks, you run a nice bakery but that cake was just awful.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 2
Service: 5
Loading...