Anthony's Old Style Pizzeria

Hard to find thin crust was worth the trip

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Awesome Italian food for everyone 😋🥰

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I'm kind of biased being raised near New Jersey and Philadelphia,but I really liked their Sicilian thick crust pizza!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Great thin crust and super flavor

Delicious pizza! All fresh veggies! Wonderful sauce and crust!

Food: 5

Called last night to order a pizza and a calzone…. This place is NEVER my go to because I watched the owner berate an employee to tears the last (and my first time), but I had no other pizza choices. After waiting the 30 minutes or so I sent my sister down to pick up our order. The owner was rude and said we never called. I will NEVER order anything again. I’m honestly glad it happened because I was cringing at the thought of giving this guy my money.

love the pizza and cheesy garlic bread!

Food: 5

I just had one of the best sandwiches ever. Tried the turkey club on homemade bread. Amazing. If you are in the Wolfboro area, I highly recommend taking the time to grab a bite. You won't be sorry.

Always a decent pizza. I forgot how good their burgers were until I read a previous review, now I’ll have to get one the next time.
We had problems a few years back with not getting exactly what we ordered but it’s been pretty consistent since. A minor mistake here and there but no real recent issues.

This place is fantastic. Everything I have ordered has been outstanding. Best pizza shop in the area!

This is true greasy, cheesy, floppy NY style pizza!! I loved it.

They try hard to help, not as great menu

2 slices of cold, soggy, greasy pizza for ten bucks! Such a deal…. Never go there again😡 I just looked at the menu a whole pizza is ten bucks, no slices on the menu.

We ordered from Anthony’s the other night for the first time and opted to use a delivery app that we’d never used before (Slice). The restaurant was experimenting with using this service but unfortunately there were no delivery drivers in the area and our order ended up sitting for a while. When we chatted with the restaurant, the employee (owner?) let us know what was going on, that we should cancel the order and get refunded through the app, and that he would personally bring us the food at the end of his shift either way (which was super nice to offer since he was headed in the opposite direction). When we did eventually get our food delivered (Cesar salad, two pizzas, onion rings) everything was absolutely DELICIOUS and you’d never know it wasn’t “hot off the press” - you’ve got customers for life with this A+ food and customer service!!!

I got a cheeseburger and a pizza. When I tell you the cheeseburger was absolutely everything I was craving in a cheeseburger, what I mean is I devoured it in about 5 minutes and was making unholy sounds the whole time. The pizza was great too, tastes fresh and like these guys know what they're doing. Everything tastes the way you want it to, well worth the price. The guys working inside were friendly and nice when I ordered over the phone too. I'll definitely be back.