Anthony's Old Style Pizzeria

We went in and ordered a chicken Parm sub and a stuffed shell dinner that came with a side salad and garlic bread. My husband wanted to get a chicken for dinner, but they informed us that there was no fried food tonight because of the heat. We spent about $35 on our two items and 220 ounce sodas.
As soon as you walk into the restaurant, there is a very small counter where you order and pay for your meal. There is no waiting area so you either have to wait outside or wait inside at one of the four tables. Each table seats for people and one of the tables had pizza boxes stacked all the way up to the ceiling. The staff was friendly and the food came out pretty quickly after we ordered it. We brought it back to our house to eat, and it was still hot when we got there.
The stuffed shells were delicious. There was about four of them in the homemade marinara sauce. I also got garlic bread, which unfortunately had just a hint of garlic and was very soggy and soaked with butter, although still hot. Besides salad was in a soup container that was stuffed with limp lettuce topped with one slice of Cucumber sliced in half, one slice of tomato sliced in half and one very small piece of red bell pepper.
The chicken Parm sub according to my husband was great. There was enough cheese sauce and chicken..
We would definitely go here again!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Best traditional Italian pizza in the lakes region, also great Italian sandwiches. I have been coming here for years and have recently seen a positive turnaround in customer service. Workers/owner have not been friendly in the past but today were very welcoming and friendly. If you have been turned off to this place in the past due to bad customer service I would give it a second chance.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Like stepping into a place somewhere in New York city. Great Sicilian pizza! Really good subs!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Absolutely amazing! We order from here all of the time and we just ordered a Margherita pizza and it was perfect, crispy, flavorful, and just great. Thank you!!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Great good!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

This little place makes Italian/New York style pizza. In my experience, it's harder to come by Italian style pizza in New England. Many pizza restaurants are Greek style in this part of the country. I love both styles, so it's nice to have found this place! They also have the option to make your pizza with vegan cheese, which made the restaurant even more of a rare gem!My spouse and I shared a small vegan cheese pizza with a few veggie toppings and a Sicilian style pizza, which is rectangular and has a focaccia-like crust, they were very tasty and substantial. Our neice got a salad and spaghetti with garlic bread. They looked great, and the portions were large. She seemed to enjoy them. Our nepew got a small pepperoni pizza, and it really looked and smelled fantastic! He also enjoyed it. My sister-in-law got some kind of veggie sandwich, but I don't remember specifically what kind. I know she enjoyed it.So, they have a good range of dishes, the portions are good, the food is delicious, and the staff are very friendly. The restaurant is quite small but not in a negative way. I'm guessing most people probably get takeout anyway. It's decorated with images of NYC, which I thought made for a nice atmosphere... kind of homey/cozy.

Vegetarian options: They have vegan cheese that you can get on any of their pizza options. Lots of veggie toppings. It's great!

Dietary restrictions: They have gluten-free and vegan options!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Sicilian Pizza, Hawaiian Sicilian Pizza, Garlic Bread

What are the large vegetable lovers Pizza and a small Hawaiian pizza the only thing they put adequate amount on the vegetarian pizza with yellow onion there was hardly any broccoli mushrooms or anything else very sad will not be going back heard great reviews about the place was very disappointed very little Hawaii Pizza ham or pineapple

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 1

Service: 4

Phenomenal pizza... great subs.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Sicilian Pizza

I called to place a good size order. The rude lady couldn’t hear me (I do NOT have a lil girlie voice) I had to yell my order in the phone. 5 salads and 3 large pizzas and 2 small ones. They said and hour and 10 min. I said ok. I called 15 min before it was suppose to be ready and asked how the order was coming along. She said rudely “did I give you a time?” I said yes I just wanted to make sure it was on time thank you. Got down there on time, I told them my name and they said I’m not allowed in the kitchen! I was right out front just making my presence known. After waiting 10 min my friend went in to inquire where the order was and they said it was just put in the oven?. Then they told us no salads . So all they had to do was tell us when I called-they were running late. So we wound up cancelling our pizzas and walking out! I don’t think I’ve ever been to such a rude restaurant before. Between the attitude on the phone and then when we arrived-the ladies attitudes-we will go some where else.

Some of the best sandwiches in wolfeboro. The homemade bread is perfect.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 5

Love this place <3

Parking: Lots

Best buffalo chicken pizza around !

Thin crust delicious!

NY style pizza

Best pizza around. White pizza is amazing. Got four girls with four different tastes, and all of them can't get enough.