The Atlantic House

67 First Ave, Atlantic Highlands
(848) 300-2408

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Kathi

Not my favorite: fish and Chips were awful, from the freshness of the fish to the breading and the weird and watery tartar sauce

Ed

Excellent meal and service and delicious cocktails. Another perfect night in a lively environment.

Barbara

A big disappointment...boneless chicken wings were delicious, coconut shrimp also good. Fish and chips dinner was absolutely horrible..over crusted, over fried and tasteless. Waiter was terrific! . The crowd talks over the loud loud music! Unfortunately we will not be returning😞

Steven Kieselowsky

Great food ,service and atmosphere

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Maryann

Making a reservation on my phone was very easy and quick. The doors opened 2 minutes early, which was nice. We were one of two tables sat upon opening. We were greeted by a friendly and welcoming young lady. We went upstairs, where it the windows were all open. The weather was beautiful and the temperature upstairs was very comfortable. The opening staff were extremely professional, polite and helpful. This was my first time visiting the Atlantic House. The food was outstanding, I got the chicken sandwich, and my brother-in-law got the fish. Both were incredibly delicious! I had a cocktail, which was very good. He had a sauvignon blanc which he said was delicious. Overall, it was a wonderful Sunday afternoon lunch. Highly recommend.

Alexandra McCahill

Love this place.
Ice cold dirty martini, TONS of gluten-free options (the wings, the calamari, and the fish and chips are fantastic).

very nice vibe too!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Rod

Amazing food, presentation and ambiance. Our waiter knew exactly how to treat us. One of the best experiences at the shore, by far. My daughter and I, loved it.

Steve

The presentation of the food and taste was great,drinks were perfect and Emily was very attentive.

ragul navaneethan

Food was awesome!. Server was too busy. Need more servers,but he was great! Interior was not bad but not the best but Overall great place!!!

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 2

John Cullinane

Went on Friday evening with wife and adult son. Sat downstairs because reserved table wasn't ready upstairs which I imagine is nicer and more open. Started with caprese salad and tuna avocado tartar. Salad was fine. Tuna tartar also fine but bland, which is not a good description of tartar. Main courses were the cauliflower wedge (wife said was ok) birria tacos (son said pretty good) and lobster roll. Pretty large lobster roll with nice big chunks. Not seasoned properly or not at all leaving that bland as well. Cocktails were very good. Strawberry spicy margarita and a mezcal one. Noth above average. Here is what bugged me the most. Used plates and empty glasses were not removed on a timely manner. Pet peeve of mine. To the point where there were used plates and glasses there when new food and new drinks arrived and still there for duration of meal. That said the staff was very pleasant but needs some extra training. Wouldn't rush back as there are many better options, but since I like the location and setting i may try again for lunch or take in a football game in the fall.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 3

Sheri

One of our favorite places.. sitting Al Fresco in the upstairs area on a beautiful night was just perfect

Emily Tantuccio

So glad my family finally had the chance to make it to The Atlantic House. The food was fresh and our service from Dylan was top notch!! She was super friendly and did such a great job looking out for us. I'm gluten free and it was really nice to get to enjoy gf calamari and fish and chips. Next time I'd probably order the salmon but it was really nice to be able to eat that dish safely after normally not being able to partake. Multiple staffers checked on us throughout our meal and it was really cozy downstairs and nice and airy upstairs with the exposed rooftop situation. We'll definitely be back! My only suggestion would be to please stock dairy free milk for the coffees. Califia is available wholesale and it's very shelf stable!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

janessa

Amazing views, great atmosphere, friendly staff, clean restaurant, reasonably priced food! The rooftop is a beautiful unique feature for this area as a local. Although the food took a little while to come out, it was fresh when it did and was so worth the wait. We got the spicy rigatoni and replaced the sausage with chicken instead and pork chop. 10/10 recommend!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Katie Nalbone

my food is so good and the place is really nice

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Robert

Great spot and atmosphere on the top deck. Nice drink specials. House pinot noir is terrible tho. We had the smash burgers. They were just ok....kinda dry and disappointing. Would cone back for drinks but skip the food and wine. Probably just beers.

Loading...