Best little gourmet snack/breakfast/lunch convenience store on the island! Delicious, made to order sandwiches, salads and drinks or premade snacks. Reasonable prices and cozy atmosphere. Stop in to hang with the locals and meet some new friends at the community table!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Julia
Great quick breakfast and lunch spot. Can order online and open all year round. Very friendly staff. The cold brew is delicious. A little pricey but reliable.
Christine Michelle
27.00 for one iced coffee that supposed to have cold foam and didn’t. Was told it melted? 1 poppi drink and 2 pieces of toast. The girls working there need to take a class on customer service.
Garrett Nann
My family just spent a week in Barnegat Light and went here every morning for coffee and a sandwich. The coffee and cold brew is great, the store is clean and they have a nice selection of food and some grocery/produce items as well. Overall a nice local business serving the Barnegat Light summer crowds.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jason D
When they fist opened they made great breakfast sandwiches. But every year since they have been on a decline while the price has risen. Now I don’t mind spending 8 bucks for a bacon, egg and cheese, as long as it’s good. Their version is not. Slightly hard/stale roll, with 1 maybe 2 pieces of thin, rubbery bacon, over cooked egg and a slice of cheese. Have tired a few times this season, thinking maybe it will get better. It has not.
Annie Silverstein
An Awesome place!! Super quick and great food!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Dustin Som
This place is largely overpriced. I understand the “at the shore” mark up but even with that in mind the prices are quite staggering. $14 dollars for a sandwich is outrageous especially for mediocre food at best. The only redemptive quality of this particular place was the courteous cook. Other than that other employees came off as posh and unwelcoming. Not to mention having dining space without a restroom to clean your hands before and after eating is mind boggling.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
AFrayedKnot
Disgusting sandwich full of oregano POWDER. The first bite had to be ejected. Waste of money
Kevin Cronin
Interesting food at a gas station! Good coffee.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Sparky
Definitely do not stop here for "regular" deli needs. Waste of gas driving to this place, zero "regular" products.
This place is fantastic and we love that there’s a convenient spot to get really nice stuff! Matt and his team totally “get it”.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Breakfast Sandwich, The Healthy Start, Hash Brown Patty 1, Spooky Brew
Caroline Longest
Nothing in the shop makes me feel compelled to actually spend my money there, other than hunger alone. Some sandwiches are good, but skimpy - i.e. 1 piece of bacon on the Gardenia? come on. For $14 you'd expect some finesse. This place lacks any sincere charm or welcoming atmosphere. It feels like an overpriced market when you walk in, and that's exactly what it is.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 1
Sparky Ny
Definitely do not stop here for "regular" deli needs. Waste of gas driving to this place, zero "regular" products.
Gary Kucsan
Just got two signature sandwiches at their new location in Harvey Cedars. Both were outstanding. Both were very large and stuffed with meat. Well worth the price which really was very reasonable. Staff very friendly too.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Alex Sprague
Nice lady at the cash register but the chicken was loaded with gristle. Oh and not that this is Agnello’s fault but if you’re gonna make a healthy alternative to root beer, you’re supposed to make it taste great.
Best little gourmet snack/breakfast/lunch convenience store on the island! Delicious, made to order sandwiches, salads and drinks or premade snacks. Reasonable prices and cozy atmosphere. Stop in to hang with the locals and meet some new friends at the community table!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great quick breakfast and lunch spot. Can order online and open all year round. Very friendly staff. The cold brew is delicious. A little pricey but reliable.
27.00 for one iced coffee that supposed to have cold foam and didn’t. Was told it melted? 1 poppi drink and 2 pieces of toast. The girls working there need to take a class on customer service.
My family just spent a week in Barnegat Light and went here every morning for coffee and a sandwich. The coffee and cold brew is great, the store is clean and they have a nice selection of food and some grocery/produce items as well. Overall a nice local business serving the Barnegat Light summer crowds.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
When they fist opened they made great breakfast sandwiches. But every year since they have been on a decline while the price has risen. Now I don’t mind spending 8 bucks for a bacon, egg and cheese, as long as it’s good. Their version is not. Slightly hard/stale roll, with 1 maybe 2 pieces of thin, rubbery bacon, over cooked egg and a slice of cheese. Have tired a few times this season, thinking maybe it will get better. It has not.
An Awesome place!! Super quick and great food!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This place is largely overpriced. I understand the “at the shore” mark up but even with that in mind the prices are quite staggering. $14 dollars for a sandwich is outrageous especially for mediocre food at best. The only redemptive quality of this particular place was the courteous cook. Other than that other employees came off as posh and unwelcoming. Not to mention having dining space without a restroom to clean your hands before and after eating is mind boggling.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Disgusting sandwich full of oregano POWDER. The first bite had to be ejected. Waste of money
Interesting food at a gas station! Good coffee.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Definitely do not stop here for "regular" deli needs. Waste of gas driving to this place, zero "regular" products.
Restaurantji Recommends
This place is fantastic and we love that there’s a convenient spot to get really nice stuff! Matt and his team totally “get it”.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Breakfast Sandwich, The Healthy Start, Hash Brown Patty 1, Spooky Brew
Nothing in the shop makes me feel compelled to actually spend my money there, other than hunger alone. Some sandwiches are good, but skimpy - i.e. 1 piece of bacon on the Gardenia? come on. For $14 you'd expect some finesse. This place lacks any sincere charm or welcoming atmosphere. It feels like an overpriced market when you walk in, and that's exactly what it is.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 1
Definitely do not stop here for "regular" deli needs. Waste of gas driving to this place, zero "regular" products.
Just got two signature sandwiches at their new location in Harvey Cedars. Both were outstanding. Both were very large and stuffed with meat. Well worth the price which really was very reasonable. Staff very friendly too.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Nice lady at the cash register but the chicken was loaded with gristle. Oh and not that this is Agnello’s fault but if you’re gonna make a healthy alternative to root beer, you’re supposed to make it taste great.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 2
Service: 5
Loading...