Cassidy's Fish Market

1801A Bayview Ave, Barnegat Light
(609) 494-8140

Recent Reviews

Sort by
william O'Fallon

Year in year out the best fish on the island. Service is amazing. Great guys.

Diane D'ercole

I ♥️ seafood & Cassidy's is one of the Best around

Charles Rose

Very fresh fish, much of it local. Not cheap but worth it.

Jim Christman

I may sound biased because I am a Captain in the fleet . Robbie gets the freshest and best quality product he can. Ask what was caught locally and you will never find a fresher product unless you catch it yourself. Oh,and if you think the prices are high,it will cost you about a thousand dollars a pound to catch your own.

peter williams

The BEST fish market on LBI. I practically live here when we come down for 2 weeks every September. Owner Rob is super knowledgeable & staff under him are great also. Have been getting my LBI fish & scallops from here for last 27 years.

Ed Sisson

Fresh seafood right off the boat, scallops,clams, fluke, mahi, tuna, striper, bluefish, never disappoints.

Ryan Hicks

Local fish selection is as fresh as it gets! You can literally watch the boats come into Viking Village with todays catch! ? Clams, scallops, tilefish, fluke etc. Staff is knowledgeable on all fish including preparation for cooking. Also good selection of non-local fish as well (ie. Alaskan Salmon)

Chris Garber

Best Fishmarket in NJ! Can’t be beat!

Chris Garber

Best Fishmarket in NJ! Can’t be beat!

Ruth Bailey

I knew the fish was fresh by how good it smelled walking in to the market. We had some flounder and some shrimp. Both were excellent! We were encouraged by watching the commercial fishing boats unload right behind the shop.

Melanie Tisdale

Selection is great, staff is wonderful and I love that they don’t use plastic or those awful netting bags. Our oysters came in brown paper bags and our fish was wrapped in butcher paper - fantastic!

Tom O

The best!

Alexey Panchekha

Fish caught today 20 min ago

Susan

Go here every vacation. Pleasant helpful people.

Terry Marsh

Tasty salmon fillet but a little expensive

Loading...