I paid 13.75 for an italian sub. That had 2 slices of meat and 3 soggy tomatoes and it was a stale roll. This wasn't my first bad experience and it definitely will be my last. Place charges way to much for not so good of food. I'll will never be going back ever agian.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 2
JHS
Unfriendly atmosphere. Walked up to the counter to buy a coffee but was told I had to buy it first because them's the rules.
Linda Froelich
Service was ok outrageous charges buyer beware !! I bought some sandwiches 2 8 inch a burger and two pork roll sandwiches yesterday with a few drinks for my work crew and was charged 162.00!!! For what ? It was not that great barely any meat in the sandwiches .. My fault I didn’t look at the credit slip no break down provided . What I heard and what I was charged definitley 100 plus different !!I went to go back they were closed . Never should have gone over 80 bucks maybe ! Crooks 100% !!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 1
Kyle Jolley
under no circumstance will i ever be spending another dollar at this place, sky high prices and i don't know if you can call yourself a deli and serve cold cuts from a package on stale old bread, terrible experience
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Brian K
Everything i go here I pay like 15‐16bucks for a sandwich with hardly any meat. Its basically wawa but more better quality.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 5
Jane Martin
This store sells good sandwiches, however the entire place needs a good going over. There is a ridiculous amount of wasted space which could be used to stock better options. There is a North End folks don’t mind spending, fill those shelves with goodies. If this shop and Agnello’s did a better job with their merchandising, I’d never go to Neptune. I don’t know why they aren’t taking full advantage of their space.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 5
Service: 3
Jay R
Ordered a 14 inch Italian sub. My girlfriend got an 8 inch sub. They’re about half an inch in difference. Waste of money and my time. Don’t bother lol. Rip whites at least they didn’t lie about the size of their sandwiches.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 4
Matt Gaynor
terrible customer service Wouldn't give me a paper bag For my sandwich Even though They had plenty by the muffins plus it was 21.67 for a sandwich and a drink
Joseph Funk
Maybe it was just a bad day but the woman owner could not have been more rude. Just lost a long time customer
Food: 3
Service: 2
Ben Chalfin
Best on the island. Staff is always there to help and are friendly. Be sure to say hi to Cathy
Early morning stop for breakfast while at the lighthouse. Owner was VERY friendly and helpful.We will definitely stop back next time we are on LBI.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Karina Raupp
The cashier was lovely, sweet, friendly and helpful. The food was good. The owner was really awful. I have a medical condition which causes me to have frequent uti's and no ability to " hold it" I was fishing with my boyfriend and had to go. I told him I was going to walk to the bathroom at the lighthouse. He asked me to get him a breakfast sandwich and I figured I could go to the deli get breakfast and per. I walked in placed my orders (so they knew I was a customer). I asked for a restroom and was told no. I was told I had to walk over to the lighthouse. At this point I was waiting for breakfast sandwiches to cook and couldn't just leave but it was getting urgent. As I grabbed a few drinks ( for later!) And a coffee for him I was quite obviously doing the dance. I asked the cashier if there was anyplace closer as I didn't think I was going to make it. She told me I could use their restroom. I walked back and the owner blocked the door. I said.the cashier said I could. She said " I'm the owner and I say no" I said "please I have a UTI" She said no again. I paid and had to walk over to the restroom which became a very painful and embarrassing situation. I could understand if I just popped in and expected to use the facility. I was a paying customer with an emergency and she wasn't able to show me compassion. or basic humanity I literally left in tears of humiliation and pain. I do appreciate the kindness and compasion of the cashier. I wish she was the owner.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 4
Service: 5
Matthew Cusack
Great local deli in the heart of a vacation area…coffee cake is fantastic and they’re one of the few delis around that still sell bologna.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Micah Burtchell
A bit pricy, but there aren't many options nearby. Decent food. Good coffee.
Rodrigo Alarcon
Mediocre deli at best. They have a captive audience, and their bread is not the best. On this visit, they got the order wrong. I am looking forward to trying their breakfast menu.
I paid 13.75 for an italian sub. That had 2 slices of meat and 3 soggy tomatoes and it was a stale roll. This wasn't my first bad experience and it definitely will be my last. Place charges way to much for not so good of food. I'll will never be going back ever agian.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 2
Unfriendly atmosphere. Walked up to the counter to buy a coffee but was told I had to buy it first because them's the rules.
Service was ok outrageous charges buyer beware !! I bought some sandwiches 2 8 inch a burger and two pork roll sandwiches yesterday with a few drinks for my work crew and was charged 162.00!!! For what ? It was not that great barely any meat in the sandwiches ..
My fault I didn’t look at the credit slip no break down provided . What I heard and what I was charged definitley 100 plus different !!I went to go back they were closed . Never should have gone over 80 bucks maybe !
Crooks 100% !!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 1
under no circumstance will i ever be spending another dollar at this place, sky high prices and i don't know if you can call yourself a deli and serve cold cuts from a package on stale old bread, terrible experience
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Everything i go here I pay like 15‐16bucks for a sandwich with hardly any meat. Its basically wawa but more better quality.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 5
This store sells good sandwiches, however the entire place needs a good going over. There is a ridiculous amount of wasted space which could be used to stock better options. There is a North End folks don’t mind spending, fill those shelves with goodies. If this shop and Agnello’s did a better job with their merchandising, I’d never go to Neptune. I don’t know why they aren’t taking full advantage of their space.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 5
Service: 3
Ordered a 14 inch Italian sub. My girlfriend got an 8 inch sub. They’re about half an inch in difference. Waste of money and my time. Don’t bother lol. Rip whites at least they didn’t lie about the size of their sandwiches.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 4
terrible customer service Wouldn't give me a paper bag For my sandwich Even though They had plenty by the muffins plus it was 21.67 for a sandwich and a drink
Maybe it was just a bad day but the woman owner could not have been more rude. Just lost a long time customer
Food: 3
Service: 2
Best on the island. Staff is always there to help and are friendly. Be sure to say hi to Cathy
Kid-friendliness: Cathy is the sweetest
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Early morning stop for breakfast while at the lighthouse. Owner was VERY friendly and helpful.We will definitely stop back next time we are on LBI.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The cashier was lovely, sweet, friendly and helpful. The food was good. The owner was really awful. I have a medical condition which causes me to have frequent uti's and no ability to " hold it" I was fishing with my boyfriend and had to go. I told him I was going to walk to the bathroom at the lighthouse. He asked me to get him a breakfast sandwich and I figured I could go to the deli get breakfast and per. I walked in placed my orders (so they knew I was a customer). I asked for a restroom and was told no. I was told I had to walk over to the lighthouse. At this point I was waiting for breakfast sandwiches to cook and couldn't just leave but it was getting urgent. As I grabbed a few drinks ( for later!) And a coffee for him I was quite obviously doing the dance. I asked the cashier if there was anyplace closer as I didn't think I was going to make it. She told me I could use their restroom. I walked back and the owner blocked the door. I said.the cashier said I could. She said " I'm the owner and I say no" I said "please I have a UTI" She said no again. I paid and had to walk over to the restroom which became a very painful and embarrassing situation. I could understand if I just popped in and expected to use the facility. I was a paying customer with an emergency and she wasn't able to show me compassion. or basic humanity I literally left in tears of humiliation and pain. I do appreciate the kindness and compasion of the cashier. I wish she was the owner.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 4
Service: 5
Great local deli in the heart of a vacation area…coffee cake is fantastic and they’re one of the few delis around that still sell bologna.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
A bit pricy, but there aren't many options nearby. Decent food. Good coffee.
Mediocre deli at best. They have a captive audience, and their bread is not the best. On this visit, they got the order wrong. I am looking forward to trying their breakfast menu.
Loading...