Barnegat Bay Ice Cream

515 N Main St, Barnegat

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Bill Perrini

Never a bad experience. Always great service. Can’t wait for you guys to reopen!

Deb Bower

Great ice cream, reasonable prices, friendly staff.

Shirin Patel

We bought the strawberry shortcake ice cream & it was heavenly! The slices of strawberries were nice & sweet! It was so good, I forgot to take a picture of it! My husband & I devoured the cup very quickly!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

G.T G.T.G

They're working amazing people friendly and respectable......

Atmosphere: 5

Art Peters

excellent ice cream

Carol Giustino

Yummy ice cream and water ice

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Toppings, Water Ice, Cones, Soft Serve Sundae

Crkt Disc Golf

Ice cream was great.

Fast service and good pricing.

A small is enough ?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Courtney Liszcz

The absolute best ice cream around! This place wows every time. Huge portions at a great price too. We love coming here

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Hard Ice Cream

Lauren Accaria

The best ice cream in town!

Susan Nocera

Had soft serve ice cream.... they only had vanilla n chocolate (or a mix) but it was delish. Very good prices. I got my granddaughter a small cone. It was a very nice size (larger than I expected) for only $3.75. Also ordered a kids cone and it came w a cup so they don't drip all over AND there was almost the same amount of ice cream as a small cone. They had a nice selection of hard ice cream for .25 more. They had sundaes available as well as milkshakes, banana splits, etc...see photo...

Atmosphere: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Classic Banana Split, Peanut Butter Topside, Cones, Hard Ice Cream, Soft Serve Sundae, Chocolate Ice Cream, Waffle Cone

Brittany Love

Cute and delicious! Definitely worth the stop. We tried the Brownie Bay Volcano and Nutella Sundae. Great serving size, priced well. The Nutella sundae was very rich and the Brownie Bay Volcano was a balance of yumminess.

They have Wheel chair accessibility with the ramp and convenient parking in the back. Plenty of shaded tables on the patio to enjoy your treat. Service was pleasant and quick - we’ll definitely be back!?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Douglas Price

Very good ice cream, but needs more "add-ins" (like the cookies in Cookies 'n' Cream) to rise to the top. Otherwise an excellent place to go to solve the ice cream hunger

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 5

Paul Mc Mahon

True ice cream the likes of which is never found any more .

Barbara DeFranza

Parking: Very best sofr serveBUT, hard to know where to actually pull in off the highway

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Soft Serve

Samantha Szyperski

Service is swift and the ice cream is tasty!

Loading...

Barnegat Bay Ice Cream

515 N Main St, Barnegat, NJ 08005