This is the first time hiring Casertano's to make food for a party. Well, it was just great. All the different trays of food was amazing. My guests enjoyed the food. Cooked to perfection. Very generous portions and tasty. So happy with the food and service.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Krista
Casertano’s has been our go to for catering all sorts of events from family parties, our kid’s birthdays, and even our wedding! They consistently have wonderful and easy customer service. Ellen is wonderful to work with; she will accommodate your requests and come up with unique and delicious ideas. Our wedding in 2020 was catered by them, including our wedding cake!! It was amazing and we had so many compliments on the food. Most recently, we ordered our child’s birthday cupcakes from them (Minion theme) and they were a hit! Cannot recommend them enough. Plus, they are a family owned business that we love to support. 10/10! Thank you, Casertano Family!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake
Lisa Matz
If they got their delivery orders right it's very goodVegetarian options: Not enoug
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Fresh Garden Salad
stacy proebstle
What a great place for catering! Ordered a sub tray and a wrap platter for my son's 3rd birthday party. Everything was fresh and delicious, my guests were raving about the bread used for the sandwiches. You get 24 pieces in each tray which was the perfect amount. Will be our go-to place for catering in the future.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Carl Ricci
The Food is superb and service is excellent, staff are very friendly!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Fresh Garden Salad, Fresh Mozzarella and Tomato
Colleen Mueller-Sneyers
Casertano's catered our wedding. The food was delicious and the service was fantastic. Everything was perfect! Ellen you were my rock!!!!! Recommend 100%!!!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Pamela Moccia'Orland
I've been catering from here for 2 years now it's so hard to find a place to order from. We are very picky especially because we come from up north and we like food a certain way, BUT this place never disappoints. Food is always so fresh and delicious and you're always welcomed with a smile.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Suzan Mills
Our family has had the pleasure of their catering for years. We also love the dinners available fresh everyday and the sandwiches and homemade salads are unbeatable. When I order from Ellen I have no worries about any of the food or catering issues they are the best.
Andy S
Food and service were very good, but took longer to prepare than I was expecting. Some interesting people watching while I was waiting. Apparently, a couple were regulars, which explained the casualness of the conversations taking place. It made me feel like I walked into a private event. I will be back, but will likely order ahead going forward. Parking is limited.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
Laurie Howells
I had my husband's 70th birthday at Casertano's and I would give it ten stars if I could. They did a fantastic job and the food was fabulous. Our server was the best!! You can't go wrong with Casertano's.Laurie
We ordered the Thanksgiving Turkey dinner again (last year I needed to cook the turkey an additional 2 hrs) and this year I was shocked when I opened the Roasted Butternut Squash with carmelized onions and saw that it was burnt. The CHARmelized onions and charred PCs of squash, that was undercooked, was thrown away. I doubt that my container was the only one this way. I hope the butternut squash soup was better. I took a picture, but this website doesn’t provide access to share it.Do I follow the “3 strikes and you are out” or move on next year?
Stohrer Music
Real community type vibe with delicious, enormous sandwiches. The kind of subs that NJ does better than anywhere else. I got a large because I didn't know better- the thing was about the size of fire extinguisher. Fed me for two days.
Court P
Ordered food and a cake for our daughter’s first birthday. Everything was fantastic! The cake was incredible!!! Order the whipped cream frosting you won’t be disappointed!!! Pat was more than helpful with all of my questions. Will definitely be using them again! Thanks Casertanos!!!
J Ferico
The sandwiches are amazing. I will never again be able to have a sub somewhere without weeping, because nowhere will ever be as great as this place. The Italian was a work of art. Truly a place I’ll think of fondly every time I think of eating.
Helen U
Tried this food today for the first time. We had it catered for lunch today. The Food was amazing and strawberry cupcakes delicious. Will definitely be going to restaurant. I recommend this place to everyone.
This is the first time hiring Casertano's to make food for a party. Well, it was just great. All the different trays of food was amazing. My guests enjoyed the food. Cooked to perfection. Very generous portions and tasty. So happy with the food and service.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Casertano’s has been our go to for catering all sorts of events from family parties, our kid’s birthdays, and even our wedding! They consistently have wonderful and easy customer service. Ellen is wonderful to work with; she will accommodate your requests and come up with unique and delicious ideas. Our wedding in 2020 was catered by them, including our wedding cake!! It was amazing and we had so many compliments on the food. Most recently, we ordered our child’s birthday cupcakes from them (Minion theme) and they were a hit! Cannot recommend them enough. Plus, they are a family owned business that we love to support. 10/10! Thank you, Casertano Family!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake
If they got their delivery orders right it's very goodVegetarian options: Not enoug
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Fresh Garden Salad
What a great place for catering! Ordered a sub tray and a wrap platter for my son's 3rd birthday party. Everything was fresh and delicious, my guests were raving about the bread used for the sandwiches. You get 24 pieces in each tray which was the perfect amount. Will be our go-to place for catering in the future.
Food: 5
Service: 5
The Food is superb and service is excellent, staff are very friendly!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Fresh Garden Salad, Fresh Mozzarella and Tomato
Casertano's catered our wedding. The food was delicious and the service was fantastic. Everything was perfect! Ellen you were my rock!!!!! Recommend 100%!!!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I've been catering from here for 2 years now it's so hard to find a place to order from. We are very picky especially because we come from up north and we like food a certain way, BUT this place never disappoints. Food is always so fresh and delicious and you're always welcomed with a smile.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Our family has had the pleasure of their catering for years. We also love the dinners available fresh everyday and the sandwiches and homemade salads are unbeatable. When I order from Ellen I have no worries about any of the food or catering issues they are the best.
Food and service were very good, but took longer to prepare than I was expecting. Some interesting people watching while I was waiting. Apparently, a couple were regulars, which explained the casualness of the conversations taking place. It made me feel like I walked into a private event. I will be back, but will likely order ahead going forward. Parking is limited.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
I had my husband's 70th birthday at Casertano's and I would give it ten stars if I could. They did a fantastic job and the food was fabulous. Our server was the best!! You can't go wrong with Casertano's.Laurie
Restaurantji Recommends
We ordered the Thanksgiving Turkey dinner again (last year I needed to cook the turkey an additional 2 hrs) and this year I was shocked when I opened the Roasted Butternut Squash with carmelized onions and saw that it was burnt. The CHARmelized onions and charred PCs of squash, that was undercooked, was thrown away. I doubt that my container was the only one this way. I hope the butternut squash soup was better. I took a picture, but this website doesn’t provide access to share it.Do I follow the “3 strikes and you are out” or move on next year?
Real community type vibe with delicious, enormous sandwiches. The kind of subs that NJ does better than anywhere else. I got a large because I didn't know better- the thing was about the size of fire extinguisher. Fed me for two days.
Ordered food and a cake for our daughter’s first birthday. Everything was fantastic! The cake was incredible!!! Order the whipped cream frosting you won’t be disappointed!!! Pat was more than helpful with all of my questions. Will definitely be using them again! Thanks Casertanos!!!
The sandwiches are amazing. I will never again be able to have a sub somewhere without weeping, because nowhere will ever be as great as this place. The Italian was a work of art. Truly a place I’ll think of fondly every time I think of eating.
Tried this food today for the first time. We had it catered for lunch today. The Food was amazing and strawberry cupcakes delicious. Will definitely be going to restaurant. I recommend this place to everyone.