My wife really liked the flautas, chicken tamales, and the taco loco. The tamarind drink and memela chorizo were also very good. The ceiling decor reminds me of the Disney film Coco.
Ken Weston
Good stuff
JOSE “Jasek” C. Castillo
we order a chicken sandwich and we can't find the chicken 😕 and prices was so high $$$$😫 totally disappointed this time!!!
Brittany Kowalski
Excellent Mexican food and everyone there is so nice!
Connor
I love this place. The food is great, the atmosphere is so cozy, the people who run it are always lovely. Highly recommend.
Lizbeth Bautista
I live in Holmdel, and this is probably one of the best Mexican spots near me. The food is really good. I got two Memelas de Res(steak) and they were delicious. I will say though, if you love salsa like me - ask for additional.
Veronica Lopez
Went for dinner yesterday! Food was really good and tasty. Started with tamales, guacamole & chips.
Fajita, enchiladas, tacos, rice and beans. Food was very good and fresh! Would recommend!
a r
Real Mexican vibe ,decor, utensils, table looking pretty and colorful. Lively and cozy. Food was generous portion but a tad bland. No vegetarian rice ! In winter needs better warming. Was cold. Overall the ambience made up for it.
Earl Grosser
We picked this location based on ours proximity to our JerseyJoyride for the day. We parked in one of the spaces located to the right of the building, even though we weren't sure if that was parking for them as it's kind of connected to the Walgreens. However we didn't see any restricted parking signs. There was only one other take being used when we got there so we were able to pick almost any table which was great. Our waitress was fine, although I was trying to get a little more conversation and a smile out of her, any server not smiling serving food always makes me feel a little uncomfortable trying to enjoy my meal. Maybe she was tired from a long day? 🥱 But she did a good job bringing the delicious and fresh food so that was good.
We got the 2 Plain Memeles and the Combinacion Mexico plates and they were absolutely fresh and delicious. We also added the Salsa and Chips and the hot sauce was hot! 🥵
Our total bill came to over $100 which was a little more than we planned on spending but everything was priced so we knew exactly what it cost. 💰
The inside of the restaurant is heavily decorated including the tables which we've seen are a few other restaurants of the same style. Great for some photos. 📸
Overall a great tasting fresh meal and I would definitely recommend trying this location out.
#texmex #mexicanrestaurant #spicy
Sam Olsen
Amazing amazing magic burrito. We came with the whole family and everybody left with our expectations exceeded!
Extremely welcoming atmosphere and top-notch customer service! The food tasted amazing - the nachos were my absolute favorite! Highly recommend! Drinks were also super tasty. So glad I found the perfect spot for authentic Mexican food with my family
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
John Y
The Mexican cuisine and ambiance were outstanding and genuine. I started with the Tamales, which were absolutely delicious. I then had the Plato De Magico Chicken Mexican Platter. The service was impeccable, and the waiter was exceptionally friendly.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Fajitas Mixtas
Ollie Ludena
Food is amazing. Best authentic Mexican in the area. The restaurant has great service with beautiful Mexican decor. Somewhat of a wait because it’s not very big but totally worth.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kaitlin Corr
Sadly, Pueblo Magico’s quality has gone significantly downhill, while their prices have gone up. I just ordered takeout and not only did the food take 45 minutes longer than the time they gave, but it was the worst meal I’ve ever had. I ordered the Magic Combination and received unseasoned and overcooked steak that wasn’t even cut, just served as rubbery sheets. This was topped with a sad slab of cheese and an uncut scallion on top. No pico or guacamole were given, as described on the menu. My husband’s French fries were also stale and cold. This was our last time ordering there.
My wife really liked the flautas, chicken tamales, and the taco loco. The tamarind drink and memela chorizo were also very good. The ceiling decor reminds me of the Disney film Coco.
Good stuff
we order a chicken sandwich and we can't find the chicken 😕 and prices was so high $$$$😫 totally disappointed this time!!!
Excellent Mexican food and everyone there is so nice!
I love this place. The food is great, the atmosphere is so cozy, the people who run it are always lovely. Highly recommend.
I live in Holmdel, and this is probably one of the best Mexican spots near me. The food is really good. I got two Memelas de Res(steak) and they were delicious. I will say though, if you love salsa like me - ask for additional.
Went for dinner yesterday! Food was really good and tasty. Started with tamales, guacamole & chips.
Fajita, enchiladas, tacos, rice and beans. Food was very good and fresh! Would recommend!
Real Mexican vibe ,decor, utensils, table looking pretty and colorful.
Lively and cozy. Food was generous portion but a tad bland. No vegetarian rice !
In winter needs better warming. Was cold.
Overall the ambience made up for it.
We picked this location based on ours proximity to our JerseyJoyride for the day. We parked in one of the spaces located to the right of the building, even though we weren't sure if that was parking for them as it's kind of connected to the Walgreens. However we didn't see any restricted parking signs.
There was only one other take being used when we got there so we were able to pick almost any table which was great.
Our waitress was fine, although I was trying to get a little more conversation and a smile out of her, any server not smiling serving food always makes me feel a little uncomfortable trying to enjoy my meal. Maybe she was tired from a long day? 🥱 But she did a good job bringing the delicious and fresh food so that was good.
We got the 2 Plain Memeles and the Combinacion Mexico plates and they were absolutely fresh and delicious. We also added the Salsa and Chips and the hot sauce was hot! 🥵
Our total bill came to over $100 which was a little more than we planned on spending but everything was priced so we knew exactly what it cost. 💰
The inside of the restaurant is heavily decorated including the tables which we've seen are a few other restaurants of the same style. Great for some photos. 📸
Overall a great tasting fresh meal and I would definitely recommend trying this location out.
#texmex #mexicanrestaurant #spicy
Amazing amazing magic burrito. We came with the whole family and everybody left with our expectations exceeded!
Restaurantji Recommends
Great food and friendly service!
Extremely welcoming atmosphere and top-notch customer service! The food tasted amazing - the nachos were my absolute favorite! Highly recommend! Drinks were also super tasty. So glad I found the perfect spot for authentic Mexican food with my family
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The Mexican cuisine and ambiance were outstanding and genuine. I started with the Tamales, which were absolutely delicious. I then had the Plato De Magico Chicken Mexican Platter. The service was impeccable, and the waiter was exceptionally friendly.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Fajitas Mixtas
Food is amazing. Best authentic Mexican in the area. The restaurant has great service with beautiful Mexican decor. Somewhat of a wait because it’s not very big but totally worth.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Sadly, Pueblo Magico’s quality has gone significantly downhill, while their prices have gone up. I just ordered takeout and not only did the food take 45 minutes longer than the time they gave, but it was the worst meal I’ve ever had. I ordered the Magic Combination and received unseasoned and overcooked steak that wasn’t even cut, just served as rubbery sheets. This was topped with a sad slab of cheese and an uncut scallion on top. No pico or guacamole were given, as described on the menu. My husband’s French fries were also stale and cold. This was our last time ordering there.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 2
Loading...