We hired Custodi to cater our wedding and we couldn't be happier with the experience. We had them provide a buffer appetizer/cocktail hour, as well as coffee and tea service during dessert. We live in Oregon and got married in New Jersey, but Chris made the long distance communication and logistics a breeze. Day of, he sent a great team, and they were able to navigate the day smoothly, and make it ever the more easier for my husband and I to just enjoy our day and not be asked a thousand questions. Everything was delicious, and I especially loved the stuffed mushrooms! Thank you again for making our day great!
Karen Crowe
I recently threw a party for about 40 people at our clubhouse and used custodi caterers. What an unbelievable experience from working with Chris on the menu to the details of coat racks! We had a bartender and 3 servers for passed hors d'oevres while Chris and his team worked their magic behind the scenes. They were on time, patient, professional, pleasant and cleaned up so well you wouldn't know we had a party. The food was AMAZING, I have zero complaints and will be using them again in the future for every catering event.
David Hinze
My girlfriend used Custodi Caterers to cater my birthday party. All the food was amazing and Chris is really pleasant to work with. His staff was very professional. If you are looking for high quality food at a reasonable price Custodi Caterers is your place.
Andrew Peluso
Excellent food and service! I always recommend Custodi Caterers. I have used them for years and they are always awesome
Carey Ostergard
I can't convey how amazing, professional and talented the Custodi Caterers crew is. We recently hired them for our large wedding reception and the entire planning process was delightful, stress-free and extremely professional from start to finish. Chris and his staff were a dream to work with, the food was incredible, the staff was efficient, friendly, knowledgeable and they left everything spotless. Everyone had a wonderful time and they truly made this the party of our dreams!
Laura Porcelli
Used them for our wedding!!! Food was phenomenal! Chris, the owner was awesome to work with! He answered all my questions(and I had a lot!) And all the servers were so personable and pleasant to have at our special day!! I will definitely use them again for our next occasion! Thanks again Chris and custodi staff!!! Five stars! The best!!!
Leanne Aciz Stanton
I cannot recommend Custodi Caterers enough. From start to finish, Chris was a dream to work with — he was very patient with my (many) questions and had great recommendations. Most importantly, the food — particularly the penne vodka, meatballs and eggplant rollatini — was PHENOMENAL. I had several party guests come up to me and ask who catered so they could hire them in the future. Highly recommend them for your next big event — you will not be disappointed!
Natalie Harris-Spencer
Custodi Caterers helped us out with some last-minute catering for our housewarming party. The food was ample and delicious! We had so many compliments from our guests. Chris was very responsive and flexible with our menu requirements. Mary Beth was honestly the best server - so attentive, went above and beyond, and stayed late to help clear up even though she didn't have to. This company is fantastic; we would use again in a heartbeat. Strongly recommend.
Jennifer Hernandez
Absolutely amazing. One of the best experiences I've had with catering. The people are absolutely wonderful, their energy and beautiful spirit. They accomodated EVERYTHING I needed, down to linen tablecover rentals! So convenient. The food tastes with so much love and is sooooooooo delicious! Everything on the menu was very tasty. Do not hesitate to choose Custodi Catering. They made my daughter's Sweet 16 a hit! Can't want to use them again!
Debby M
Always awesome service and delicious food!! Highly recommended for all your catering needs, small or large!
Custode Caterers is always my caterer to go to! Their food is very good and my company always complimented their food and they now use them!I wish they still sold individual dinners like they did during Covid!! They were the best like their catering!
Caitlin Schafer
Custodi Caterers catered our wedding this June. We did cold appetizers for cocktail hour and a buffet style dinner. Chris made planning our catering a breeze, he was friendly and easy to talk to on the phone, and flexible to accommodate our needs and the dietary restrictions of our guests. We received many compliments on the food, everything was hot, delicious, and well presented. The staff that served our event were pleasant, professional, and went above and beyond to take care of things on our special day! Every step of the way, I could not have asked for a better experience. I wouldn’t hesitate to recommend Custodi Caterers to anyone who is looking for event catering!
Jessica Lauredan Muro
Chris and his team catered my sons’ birthday party and did a FANTASTIC job. Everyone raved about the food, and I got several messages about the food even weeks after the party! Chris is the upmost professional - he helped me tailor my menu, made great suggestions, and was so responsive and easy to work with throughout. Janka, who worked the party, is so sweet and went above and beyond to make my guests feel welcome and comfortable. She took on responsibilities way beyond what I asked or expected her to do, allowing me to relax and truly enjoy the party. I highly recommend Custodi - honestly you won’t regret it. I’m looking for an excuse to throw another party so we can use them again :)
Kay Slavin
Custodi Catering catered my wedding for 170 people. Working with Chris was easy throughout the entire process. Prices were really affordable & the food was excellent. Guests raved about the eggplant rollatini, salmon, and shrimp. They were professional throughout the planning & the event. We did the alcohol ourselves (we should’ve used Custodi!) & we accidentally messed up the order. One of Custodi’s lead bartenders, Chelsea, noticed right away and coordinated a new delivery. All during cocktail hour! She saved the day. Would highly recommend them for catering large or small events.
Annmarie Nicolette
You did an excellent job for our Christmas this year!!! My favorite was the shrimp cocktail . I’m sorry I didn’t order a second tray. They were all gone in an hour. The chicken and vegetables were perfect and the meat and cheese tray was a first for us. Worth every penny. You are Nutley’s loss but Belleville’s gain. Thank you thank you.
We hired Custodi to cater our wedding and we couldn't be happier with the experience. We had them provide a buffer appetizer/cocktail hour, as well as coffee and tea service during dessert. We live in Oregon and got married in New Jersey, but Chris made the long distance communication and logistics a breeze. Day of, he sent a great team, and they were able to navigate the day smoothly, and make it ever the more easier for my husband and I to just enjoy our day and not be asked a thousand questions. Everything was delicious, and I especially loved the stuffed mushrooms! Thank you again for making our day great!
I recently threw a party for about 40 people at our clubhouse and used custodi caterers. What an unbelievable experience from working with Chris on the menu to the details of coat racks! We had a bartender and 3 servers for passed hors d'oevres while Chris and his team worked their magic behind the scenes. They were on time, patient, professional, pleasant and cleaned up so well you wouldn't know we had a party. The food was AMAZING, I have zero complaints and will be using them again in the future for every catering event.
My girlfriend used Custodi Caterers to cater my birthday party. All the food was amazing and Chris is really pleasant to work with. His staff was very professional. If you are looking for high quality food at a reasonable price Custodi Caterers is your place.
Excellent food and service! I always recommend Custodi Caterers. I have used them for years and they are always awesome
I can't convey how amazing, professional and talented the Custodi Caterers crew is. We recently hired them for our large wedding reception and the entire planning process was delightful, stress-free and extremely professional from start to finish. Chris and his staff were a dream to work with, the food was incredible, the staff was efficient, friendly, knowledgeable and they left everything spotless. Everyone had a wonderful time and they truly made this the party of our dreams!
Used them for our wedding!!! Food was phenomenal! Chris, the owner was awesome to work with! He answered all my questions(and I had a lot!) And all the servers were so personable and pleasant to have at our special day!! I will definitely use them again for our next occasion! Thanks again Chris and custodi staff!!! Five stars! The best!!!
I cannot recommend Custodi Caterers enough. From start to finish, Chris was a dream to work with — he was very patient with my (many) questions and had great recommendations. Most importantly, the food — particularly the penne vodka, meatballs and eggplant rollatini — was PHENOMENAL. I had several party guests come up to me and ask who catered so they could hire them in the future. Highly recommend them for your next big event — you will not be disappointed!
Custodi Caterers helped us out with some last-minute catering for our housewarming party. The food was ample and delicious! We had so many compliments from our guests. Chris was very responsive and flexible with our menu requirements. Mary Beth was honestly the best server - so attentive, went above and beyond, and stayed late to help clear up even though she didn't have to. This company is fantastic; we would use again in a heartbeat. Strongly recommend.
Absolutely amazing. One of the best experiences I've had with catering. The people are absolutely wonderful, their energy and beautiful spirit. They accomodated EVERYTHING I needed, down to linen tablecover rentals! So convenient. The food tastes with so much love and is sooooooooo delicious! Everything on the menu was very tasty. Do not hesitate to choose Custodi Catering. They made my daughter's Sweet 16 a hit! Can't want to use them again!
Always awesome service and delicious food!! Highly recommended for all your catering needs, small or large!
Restaurantji Recommends
Custode Caterers is always my caterer to go to! Their food is very good and my company always complimented their food and they now use them!I wish they still sold individual dinners like they did during Covid!! They were the best like their catering!
Custodi Caterers catered our wedding this June. We did cold appetizers for cocktail hour and a buffet style dinner. Chris made planning our catering a breeze, he was friendly and easy to talk to on the phone, and flexible to accommodate our needs and the dietary restrictions of our guests. We received many compliments on the food, everything was hot, delicious, and well presented. The staff that served our event were pleasant, professional, and went above and beyond to take care of things on our special day! Every step of the way, I could not have asked for a better experience. I wouldn’t hesitate to recommend Custodi Caterers to anyone who is looking for event catering!
Chris and his team catered my sons’ birthday party and did a FANTASTIC job. Everyone raved about the food, and I got several messages about the food even weeks after the party! Chris is the upmost professional - he helped me tailor my menu, made great suggestions, and was so responsive and easy to work with throughout. Janka, who worked the party, is so sweet and went above and beyond to make my guests feel welcome and comfortable. She took on responsibilities way beyond what I asked or expected her to do, allowing me to relax and truly enjoy the party. I highly recommend Custodi - honestly you won’t regret it. I’m looking for an excuse to throw another party so we can use them again :)
Custodi Catering catered my wedding for 170 people. Working with Chris was easy throughout the entire process. Prices were really affordable & the food was excellent. Guests raved about the eggplant rollatini, salmon, and shrimp. They were professional throughout the planning & the event. We did the alcohol ourselves (we should’ve used Custodi!) & we accidentally messed up the order. One of Custodi’s lead bartenders, Chelsea, noticed right away and coordinated a new delivery. All during cocktail hour! She saved the day. Would highly recommend them for catering large or small events.
You did an excellent job for our Christmas this year!!! My favorite was the shrimp cocktail . I’m sorry I didn’t order a second tray. They were all gone in an hour. The chicken and vegetables were perfect and the meat and cheese tray was a first for us. Worth every penny. You are Nutley’s loss but Belleville’s gain. Thank you thank you.