Sam I Am Bagels

Do yourself a favor and don’t ever order from here. They overpriced everything, the food went delivered will be wrong and the staff doesn’t do anything.

Probably the worst experience I have had with a restaurant/food place in a long time. And it’s multiple times over and over.

If you give basic instructions, not to have certain things on a sandwich and it still comes that way, and then they can’t reconcile, don’t ever order from here.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

I picked up 11 mixed bagels from the "to good to go " app. So far tasting good w/ cream cheese 🥯.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Regular Bagel

My go-to bagel spot in town for over ten years, consistently fresh and delicious!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Bagels were OK. Made on site

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Amazing bagels! Grew up in BH and I love their French Toast bagels.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

The bagels were wet. That’s how I would describe them. I got a dozen and they were all stuck together as if they didn’t get enough time to cool separately. Also they all smell of onion. The everything bagel is too onion forward in my opinion. Wouldn’t reccomend.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 4

Solid bagel joint. I come here on the weekends for a lox and cream cheese, and they never disappoint.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Nice delicious fresh bagels. the staff was very friendly and everything was reasonably priced too

Worst bagel i’ve had in Jersey. I asked for extra toasted and they didn’t toast my bagel at all. Got a french toast bagel and I think it was just a plain bagel with powdered sugar on it.

The bagels I got from this place are an embarrassment to NJ bagels. Tiny and look like frozen bagels you'd buy at the grocery store with some stuff added on top.

As nurses we are hungry for breakfast. As a supervisor I like to treat the staff.They have great variety and gave utensils and plates no extra fee. Very nice place.

Paid 14$ for a bagel with cream cheese and sliced Lox. I understand that is a higher priced item and I also understand the current times and inflation but I pretty much got a bagel with cream cheese with 1-2 slices of lox. Very disappointed

Very small bagel store, no frill interior. I believe they have a couple small tables at most and a wall hung flat panel. Tables may have been removed during peak COVID. Parking is pretty decent, I can typically get a parking spot without issue. Some bagel varieties do run out quite early in the morning. Typically everything bagel, salt, egg, wheat, blueberry are available later in the day. I do feel these bagels are some of the best in the immediate area, not bready, with enough chewy and crispy parts and moist. They have basic variety of bagel flavor selection but not a huge variety. Bagels have always been spot on consistent. Friendly staff and typically quick service.

Great breakfast sandwiches and bagels (they go fast so get there early). And of course lovely staff!!

As nurses we are hungry for breakfast. As a supervisor I like to treat the staff.They have great variety and gave utensils and plates no extra fee. Very nice place.