I wish I could give more than 5 stars honestly. I moved down from North Jersey and was unable to find a good pie. Today, my husband and I went here. I can't rave enough about it.
I will start with the atmosphere. It has a really cool vibe and there are different themes to the rooms.
The staff was incredible. So friendly and helpful and patient.
Now the food. I can't say enough. If you over look the salad (yes I said salad), you are missing out. It was top 2 best salads I ever had. It was simple but delicious. The pizza, is the best I have had in South Jersey. The crust is thin and the flavors of the sauce is amazing. I highly recommend the original pie as well as the buffalo chicken. Don't forget the homemade ranch and Bleu cheese. Desert is made in house and was just as incredible as everything else.
Only thing to be mindful of, parking is a little tricky and they only take cash or venmo.
You guys have gained customers for life. We will absolutely be back soon!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Tomato Pies, Famous House Salad, Buffalo Chicken Pie
Lucas Matthew
Had pizza for the first time from here today and it was exceptional!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Sarah MacDougall
Best local pizza and very family friendly!
Bernard Coval
Really excellent pizza, the crust is thin and sometimes has a little crunch in spots. Salads are great for sharing too!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Kara
This is the best restaurant you will ever eat at in your whole life. This is not an exaggeration. Every single thing on the menu is delicious. The staff are all so cool and welcoming, are happy to see you. The interior is decorated so unique and always changing a little bit, filled with art. I come here every time I visit Jersey. My favorite ❤️ 🍕
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Drew Kulis
Holy tomato is certainly one to write home to about. Consistently 100% from the time Tom welcomes you at the door. Whether it’s a special date night, a quick dinner run, or a large get together it’s a night to remember. We’ve yet to recommend to someone and receive a poor review. Certainly a place we will take our future kids and share all the fun memories we had here.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
lillynbilly5 stewart
I have been a patron of this establishment since it used to be called alfreds, when it was opened and owned by the original owner Alfred when he owned it, the tomato sauce was crushed tomatoes, real garlic. The crust was so thin that it would fall when you would lift it, he used all quality products from double zero flour from Italy, real Italian sausage the minute he sold it to the now owners of holy tomato pie. They changed it. All of the products quality has gone downhill. There is nothing original of what it used to be other than the way they cut the pizza the way Alfred did. The sauce is like Ragu The sausage taste almost like borderline breakfast sausage and the crust is tough. The garlic taste more like garlic powder, not fresh garlic. After nearly 20 years. I won’t be coming here anymore. I’m sorry but the prices they’re charging don’t add up to the quality and has completely changed. People ate here because the recipe Alfred came up with so why did you change it all?! Should’ve started your own establishment with your own original recipes!
Chrissy LV
Ricotta pie special was delicious!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Edward Zooby
The best. It’s the only pizza I enjoy eating in the area. More expensive but you’re getting genuine pizza. Dominoes at the bottom tier, other places mid tier, and this place is at the top. I just had their white pizza special. Never heard of it here before. Phenomenal. What! It was delicious. I ate the whole thing myself. Left some scraps for the wife. Sorry darling daddy had to. Order it right now before it’s gone.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Renee Conway
Best place ever, innovative desserts,pizza and appetizers. The atmosphere is comforting and staff are great my favorite spot.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Famous House Salad, Tomato Pies
I went to this place with family and they were telling me how amazing it was. I was skeptical but wanted to give it a fair try. This place did not disappoint! The salad was generously dressed and seasoned, the BLT tots were nice and crispy, and the pizza blew me away. I live down the shore and was expecting something like Pete & Elda’s, but this was so much better! The crust had some substance, but still had a nice crunch. All of the toppings on the pizza were fresh and great quality. I will definitely be making the drive out the next time I want a really, *really* good pizza
Nicole Deming
Place is amazing! It is the place we go when I’m visiting my friend. Everything is delicious!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
dawnia garnett
The hype was a lie!! Someone referred them and I show up on time and the red sauce is cold??? Pizza?? Cold?? Yea I’m good don’t feed me someone left overs #soldusoldfood #coldpizza
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 5
Snake Plissken
Possibly best pie ive had, was not what i was expecting, pickle pizza had fried onions and hot honey? Normal pie sauce was crab sauce? Not entirely sure but i would reccomend 10/10 will order again. This place wont dissapoint.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Eric Zeises
Absolutely the best! Boardwalk pie with pepperoni was delicious! We had the best dessert ever. Fried Pound with homemade whipped cream and fresh strawberries and blueberries! The staff is great too!
I wish I could give more than 5 stars honestly. I moved down from North Jersey and was unable to find a good pie. Today, my husband and I went here. I can't rave enough about it.
I will start with the atmosphere. It has a really cool vibe and there are different themes to the rooms.
The staff was incredible. So friendly and helpful and patient.
Now the food. I can't say enough. If you over look the salad (yes I said salad), you are missing out. It was top 2 best salads I ever had. It was simple but delicious. The pizza, is the best I have had in South Jersey. The crust is thin and the flavors of the sauce is amazing. I highly recommend the original pie as well as the buffalo chicken. Don't forget the homemade ranch and Bleu cheese. Desert is made in house and was just as incredible as everything else.
Only thing to be mindful of, parking is a little tricky and they only take cash or venmo.
You guys have gained customers for life. We will absolutely be back soon!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Tomato Pies, Famous House Salad, Buffalo Chicken Pie
Had pizza for the first time from here today and it was exceptional!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Best local pizza and very family friendly!
Really excellent pizza, the crust is thin and sometimes has a little crunch in spots. Salads are great for sharing too!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
This is the best restaurant you will ever eat at in your whole life. This is not an exaggeration. Every single thing on the menu is delicious. The staff are all so cool and welcoming, are happy to see you. The interior is decorated so unique and always changing a little bit, filled with art. I come here every time I visit Jersey. My favorite ❤️ 🍕
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Holy tomato is certainly one to write home to about. Consistently 100% from the time Tom welcomes you at the door. Whether it’s a special date night, a quick dinner run, or a large get together it’s a night to remember. We’ve yet to recommend to someone and receive a poor review. Certainly a place we will take our future kids and share all the fun memories we had here.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I have been a patron of this establishment since it used to be called alfreds, when it was opened and owned by the original owner Alfred when he owned it, the tomato sauce was crushed tomatoes, real garlic. The crust was so thin that it would fall when you would lift it, he used all quality products from double zero flour from Italy, real Italian sausage the minute he sold it to the now owners of holy tomato pie. They changed it. All of the products quality has gone downhill. There is nothing original of what it used to be other than the way they cut the pizza the way Alfred did. The sauce is like Ragu The sausage taste almost like borderline breakfast sausage and the crust is tough. The garlic taste more like garlic powder, not fresh garlic. After nearly 20 years. I won’t be coming here anymore. I’m sorry but the prices they’re charging don’t add up to the quality and has completely changed. People ate here because the recipe Alfred came up with so why did you change it all?! Should’ve started your own establishment with your own original recipes!
Ricotta pie special was delicious!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The best. It’s the only pizza I enjoy eating in the area. More expensive but you’re getting genuine pizza. Dominoes at the bottom tier, other places mid tier, and this place is at the top.
I just had their white pizza special. Never heard of it here before. Phenomenal. What! It was delicious. I ate the whole thing myself. Left some scraps for the wife. Sorry darling daddy had to. Order it right now before it’s gone.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Best place ever, innovative desserts,pizza and appetizers. The atmosphere is comforting and staff are great my favorite spot.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Famous House Salad, Tomato Pies
Restaurantji Recommends
I went to this place with family and they were telling me how amazing it was. I was skeptical but wanted to give it a fair try. This place did not disappoint! The salad was generously dressed and seasoned, the BLT tots were nice and crispy, and the pizza blew me away. I live down the shore and was expecting something like Pete & Elda’s, but this was so much better! The crust had some substance, but still had a nice crunch. All of the toppings on the pizza were fresh and great quality. I will definitely be making the drive out the next time I want a really, *really* good pizza
Place is amazing! It is the place we go when I’m visiting my friend. Everything is delicious!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The hype was a lie!! Someone referred them and I show up on time and the red sauce is cold??? Pizza?? Cold?? Yea I’m good don’t feed me someone left overs #soldusoldfood #coldpizza
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 5
Possibly best pie ive had, was not what i was expecting, pickle pizza had fried onions and hot honey? Normal pie sauce was crab sauce? Not entirely sure but i would reccomend 10/10 will order again. This place wont dissapoint.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Absolutely the best! Boardwalk pie with pepperoni was delicious! We had the best dessert ever. Fried Pound with homemade whipped cream and fresh strawberries and blueberries! The staff is great too!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Holy Tomato Caesar Salad
Loading...