The Barnyard

1 Wantage Ave, Branchville
(973) 948-0780

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Jeff Colarusso

I've eaten at the Barnyard twice in the last 2 weeks, and its fantastic! The Stampede Burger is amazing. Lots of layers of flavor, always cooked to order, great meat, great bacon, and very filling. Plus, the new location has a bar, so you can get a beer with the burger. Awesome service, and I'll keep going back for more. Highly recommend!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Hamburger

Anna Gencarelli

Unfortunately we have to give a negative review. This was our third time here, because we wanted to support our local restaurants. Every time we came in which was a total of 3 the place was empty and we were the only customers. The service is extremely SLOW! today they didn't have the air on I did mention to our waitress she agreed, but nothing was done about it. The food was absolutely terrible today and we ordered the same exact every time. A south west salad for me the tortilla chips were stale and the Mexican shell was greasy and under cooked which made it soggy, Unfortunately im a diabetic so I had no choice but to eat half to stabilize my sugar. My husband ordered the fried crispy chicken sandwich and unfortunately the batter was extremely greasy and soggy and under cooked. Once again this was strike 3 and we won't be returning back!

Heather Davey

Loving the new location!!
Food is delicious!!
Drinks are fabulous!
Owners are always present and the staff is great!!

We can’t say enough about this restaurant and on top of their delicious drinks and dynamite food… they are ALWAYS giving back to the community!!!
A++++

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Matt Baran

Place has a sign up inside of the stadium to order takeout, but does not tell you that it will take 1+ hour and that you can't take the food into the stadium. No where near the sign or on the website does it mention this crucial detail. Then after 1+hour, the burger was overdone and the fries were sad. This is disingenuous marketing. I did not see a single other takeout order go out and there was only like 2 tables seated. They must hand chop the meat with toothpicks or something. Then they have me a hard time about ordering my child a Shirley Temple like it's a crime to order a soda at the bar. Terrible service. Mediocre food.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 2

Julian Evanchik

Good food, took over an hour 45 to be ready while the restaurant was empty.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Kristy Zierenberg

Came in and sat at the bar for a to go order. I was told I would need to order it online. Didn't even ask if I wanted a drink. Took my business somewhere else. Parking lot is huge and I was told I couldn't park because of a car show but there were no signs.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Stephanie Ruzicka

Once the barnyard moved to the stadium, their online ordering policy changed you’re not able to order food because they will process only the dining room orders before doing any online orders. The regular customers who support them all year get put on the back burner for the stadium visitors. I feel like they should do away with online ordering if they can’t process the orders when they’re busy it was disappointing to see that we didn’t count as customers and were told That the dining room needed to be serviced first before takeout could be processed and to keep trying back until the online ordering came back on once the dining room was clear. There should be a system that allows online orders to be processed in order with the dining room orders a lot of those dining out are people who support the restaurant all the time and not just during events.

Stephanie Ruzicka

We loved going to the barnyard when it was in the center of Branchville and then it moved to the stadium and became a 20 minute ride for us. They do have really good burgers and we do go back there but when there are games and the stadium is busy, People like us, the regular customers that did business with the barnyard before they moved to the stadium no longer get service. You can’t justorder online for takeout because they focus only on the dining room and the baseball crowd. This was really frustrating to us when we drove to the restaurant during a game Because he kept saying on my ordering was not available and we were told just keep trying online and eventually it will become available. I do understand that it’s busy because there’s a game but customers who are not at the game who are loyal customers and go all the time regardless should be able to still order and their order should be placed in line with those sitting in the dining room like most restaurants. If you’re not going to process online ordering at certain times, you shouldn’t have online ordering. Again it was really disheartening for regular customer to not be needed during baseball season but needed other times. Like I do understand it’s a business and you’re trying to make money but then do away with online ordering and make it first come first serve. I bet you after baseball season business won’t be the same without those online customers that you’re putting aside for the time being.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 5

Service: 1

Benny's Bodega

The best food! With the best staff! NOW with a new amazing location with a full bar!!! We can’t love this place enough!!! The food is always perfect and the crew is always amazing! The owners are so kind and generous! They are HEAVILY involved in EVERYTHING that goes on at their restaurant, you often see them working side by side with their staff!

Always a welcoming feel! A+++

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

John Dane

Came in last minute. Met Owners and loved the place and friendly staff. You have to try the BBQ!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Ryan Daly

Definitely really good burgers and sweet potato fries, thank you

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Just Me

So my husband and I went on a wild adventure. We were starving and since we’re not familiar with the area we came across this place…. Let me tell you everything was phenomenal- the onion rings as an appetizer was Banging with that dipping sauce. WOW .
I had the Texas burger which was ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
And the stampede burger!!!!! 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥

Everyone should stop buy and try their food !!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Kristen Ruscetta

Terrible planning on an event night. Here for a middle school game, and you can't get any food, was told they don't have enough servers to order, nor enough food.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Shawn’s Hungry

Had a chicken sandwich form their new truck and it was massive ! Cannot wait for the restaurant to open back up.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Ainslie O

The food was delicious. I loved the Mac and cheese and chicken tenders. Also loved our French fries. 5/5 stars

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Fries

Loading...