Sugar Plum Fairy Bakery

I've used Sugar Plum a few times for desserts and cookies and everything has been amazing so far! Holly is a great baker. My cookie/bar tray was gone in minutes at the last party. I think the almond croissant bars were my fav. Ill continue to look forward to getting to hire Holly for my special occasions :)

Just got their lemon sugar cookies today!!! Omg!!!! Outstanding!!!!

The entire process from ordering to pickup was as easy and convenient as the food was delicious! If you're in the market for something sweet and love supporting small, independent businesses, there's no better choice in this area.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Overall wonderful experience! Holly was so kind with my requests and created a memorable experience for our family event! Thank you so much for coming through and making it happen! Her artistic creation and sweets was absolutely delicious 😋

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Ordered a cake and cupcakes from out-of-state for a baby shower. We provided pictures and what we needed, and the results were awesome. Absolutely recommend!

Food: 5

Service: 5

Ordered a cake and cupcakes from out-of-state for a baby shower. We provided pictures and what we needed, and the results were awesome. Absolutely recommend!

Food: 5

Service: 5

As a fellow baker, let me tell you these treats are absolutely DELICIOUS! I personally tried FOUR different goodies (Churro Bars, Snickerdoodle Bundt Cake, Lucky Charm Cookies & Cookie Monster Cookies) and each one surpassed my expectations... and again, being a fellow baker, that's REALLY hard to do. **Cookies Monster cookies are definitely my favorite 🫣** Bonus fact: it's been 3 days, and the Cookies are still super soft and perfectly chewy & the bundt cake still has plenty of texture and is most certainly NOT dried out... and I didn't even bother putting them away, they're just on the counter in the containers she used... nothing air tight... so that right there is just.. FANTASTIC Bottom line, if you're in need of some sweet treats, look no further!

Some really outstanding fudge! Can’t wait to try more!

Ordered a cake through Holly and it was such an easy experience! Requested a funfetti birthday cake for a friend and it was SO good! You can totally taste the difference when something is homemade with quality ingredients. Thanks Holly! The cherry almond cookies were a special treat too.

Cute delicious

The best way to describe the birthday cake I ordered ...is WOW! Got a chocolate cake with chocolate truffle filling and chocolate ganache frosting. It truly is death by chocolate. Great communication. Highly recommend.

The best way to describe the birthday cake I ordered ...is WOW! Got a chocolate cake with chocolate truffle filling and chocolate ganache frosting. It truly is death by chocolate. Great communication. Highly recommend.

Omg. The brownies....mouth drooling,soft, amazing.

I ordered an 8' chocolate cake with chocolate truffle filling and a chocolate ganache frosting for my husband's birthday. WOW!!! WHAT A CAKE!!! Moist, decadent, not too sweet!!! It was rich n creamy!!! Best chocolate cake I've had in a long while. I'm so glad I ordered the same cake for my daughter's engagement party next month!!!I cant wait to try MORE of Sugar Plums delicious selection of cakes and baked goods!!!

Just tried the banana cupcakes with peanut butter frosting & the brown sugar peacan cookies. Delicious!! Would definitely reorder both, but so many more things I'd like to try.