The Bagelry

170 E Hanover Ave, Cedar Knolls
(973) 206-1208

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Rahul Agarwal

I think this place should be renamed “robbery” instead of “bagelery “
I ordered 1 omelette and two cream cheese bagel. That’s is and my bill after taxes and “tip” for picking up my own food is $30. $30 for an omelette and 2 cream cheese bagel. If this isn’t robbery what is. They charge 3% to use credit card. Then they beg for a tip. Like imagine robbing the customer of $30 and still it not being enough to pay their employees decent wages that they need to beg for a tip for a pick up.
To me this just sounds exorbitant and fleecing the customer with junk fees.
There is an equally average bagel place across the street and they won’t atleast charge you for using credit card.
Ps: I have filed a complaint the my credit card company for the fees they charge. I pay a lot of money for annual fees for credit card, if I have to pay another 3% each time I buy something then either the credit card company isn’t getting my money or I ain’t buying in the first place.
Everything has become a scam these days! Everything just sucks. A man can’t have a simple bagel and cream cheese without having to consider he he needs to sell his kidney

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 3

Service: 2

Janieth Norgrove

It is 8:42, I arrived at 8:16. I purchased one bagel with eggs and extra bacon. Only 2 people ahead of me, 3 behind me with various orders. All received their orders before me. I was the only person of color in the store.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 3

Service: 1

Ken Carson

Bagels are good, but I just had a BEC with two measly pieces of bacon—all on one side of the sandwich. Imagine biting into your $9.50 sandwich and it's just egg and cheese. I've gotten Taylor ham before too, and it's a similar issue. At that price, it feels like they just robbed me.

Hermes Frangoudis

Great bagel shop, their bagels are huge and made fresh so they are so tasty. Their breakfast sandwiches are delicious! Would highly recommend!

mabel moore

They know their regular customers and where they tend to sit. They will bring your order to your table.

Megan Brown

Bagel sandwich was a great portion size, enough for me to have breakfast tomorrow as well. The coffee area has a lot of different syrups to make a customized coffee.

Reynolds

I rarely write a review but felt that I should. My son visited the area this weekend and brought us home some bagels. They were the best bagels that I’ve ever had. I’ve always loved bagels from NJ/NY area but these were one of the best, even hours later. I just wish we lived closer !

stevenmcmeatballs

The bagel with plain vegan cream cheese was really good. Better than any of the store bought vegan cream cheeses. Updated from previous review on 2025-02-01

tom ryans

Food is good but $9.06 for a Taylor Ham, Egg and Cheese bagel is robbery. I'll find somewhere cheaper from now on.

Katelyn Anthony

Best bagels around! Friendly staff, and super quick service!

Eileen Egan

Taylor ham, egg & cheese bagels rock!

David Warner Photography

Very large bagels

LeveUpFitness Tech

Over priced, 8 dollars for a bagel with cream cheese and bacon. Good food but not worth the money in my eyes. Especially when there is cheaper better options around the corner.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 2

alexaabell44

The bagel was delicious! I was expecting store bought scallion cream cheese but it definitely tasted home made. The best vegan cream cheese I’ve had. The bagel was perfect too.

Dawn

I walked into this place yesterday for the FIRST and LAST time. I was having a really bad day and rushing to get something to eat to go back to work from my lunch break. After stopping at Nothing Bundt cakes. I walked over to the bagelry and I open the door and walked in and I was immediately told rudely that they were closed. So if you are closed-wouldn’t you lock the door.

Atmosphere: 1

Service: 1

Loading...