Scalini Fedeli

63 Main St, Chatham
(973) 701-9200

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Roger

Fabulous restaurant especially for special occasions. Great menu, tasty dishes beautifully served, by experienced, polite, and friendly staff. The pre-fix menu is unique and given the range of dishes, though on the expensive side, is non—the less reasonably priced. If you try it, you will not be disappointed. It is one of our favorites.

Yana

Was not our first time. Classic ambiance, professional and friendly stuff. Delicious food.

June

Celebrated our son's birthday here for dinner. We did not realize it was prix fixe only. Service has always been attentive here, despite the fact that the restaurant was full. Our dinner had a nice selection & was wonderful - I enjoyed my chocolate souffle dessert (available for dinner only). Drinks were excellent and our family will be returning. Highly recommend!

IM

Insanely good Italian food!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

J Dgn

Have been to this place many times. Service this time was rushed, the food undercooked, and the service was inattentive.

Hans Thorsted

Very nice 🇩🇰

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Kevin

We asked for table nine we were ignored . Restaurant sat a two and then a three at that table which is a four . Major fail for a restaurant that was a regular once a month destination for us for twenty years . We said it was our anniversary so your loss we won't be back . Service was slow and kitchen has taken a step back good luck .

Carin

The prix fixe menu had many options. They also had daily specials from which to choose. The food was absolutely incredible. This restaurant has been around for years. It's been quite awhile since I was last here and now I regret taking so long to come back! Cocktail and wine list were also great. This is a wonderful place to go for a special occasion as it's a bit pricey. But it's worth every penny!!!

Terrence

We've been going here for 20+ years and I have to say I'm disappointed. We used to enjoy great service from the veteran waiters. The staff seems decidedly less experienced now. I had to pour my own wine. And – please check my reservation notes. I requested some sort of commemoration of my wife's 50th birthday, and our 25th wedding anniversary. No one bothered to mention anything. We used to love this place.

robert nathan

An excellent all around meal, an enjoyable experience

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

christopher

Very old and dated inside. Dust on curtains so thick looks like years have gone by without cleaning them. Food was tasty, service was marginal at best. Once dining room filled up we never saw server again

Sam Alnabulsi

Wow good All over

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

JohnF

The prix fixe menu was varied in wonderful dishes. It was my wife's birthday and the staff was very nice in celebrating it. Gus , who was our waiter was very friendly and attentive. It was a definite 5 star experience

We have eaten at Scalini Fedeli many times, and have always enjoyed it. However, our most recent visit didn't measure up to prior standards. My wife ordered a lobster special as her main course. It came over done and not very tasty. The service was also not up to the usual standards. It took a long time for our main course to arrive. I'm not sure whether this was just a single bad night, or whether the quality at Scalini Fedeli has declined from their prior high standard.

SPF3730

Excellent food, amazing service and a great atmosphere made a very enjoyable anniversary dinner. It is a fixed price, 4 course meal but offered a great variety of options for all courses.

Loading...