The Pizza Shop

465 Main St, Chatham
(973) 635-2757

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Mark Victor

Great za but the rest of the menu really makes the Shop worthing checking out. The back room is great for intimate private parties or networking events.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Brian Shutlz

This place has really good pizza. Chief at the front counter seems to be known by everyone . As everyone says hello by name .

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Slice Main St

Zach Langowski

Been working in this area for 11 years, kind of disappointed I just found this spot. Very good pizza.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Lorraine Franz

Good NJ Italian restaurant. Fairly new interior decoration, so all is clean and new. Good service, good food, all in all a pleasant dinner experience.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Rogelio Carrasquillo

Great Pizza and service!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Christopher Bezzone

Friendly neighborhood spot, with excellent pizza and simple Italian pastas and sandwiches for any type of guest. Good place to bring the kids and take out. The private room in the back is perfect for any kind of family, friends or company party. Love it here!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Pizza - Sunday Gravy, Tomato Pie

Eric Williams

The Shop is awesome! I work nearby so I come here often for lunch.The pizza is delicious, everything from the plain to the elaborate. Thin crust, great sauce, and generous on the cheese. I highly recommend the Pesto Grandma and the Chicken Fresco. I watched the chef build the Chicken Fresco, and it was like watching an artist. The fresh mozzarella, tomaotoes, and basil are delicious; the drizzle of balsamic brings it to the next level.They have a great lunch combo during the week, any two slices plus a can of soda (or bottle of water) for just $7. Awesome.Shout out to Gustavo behind the counter, he's a good guy and is passionate about food.Update: Today I had the Italian Beef sandwich, and it was fantastic. Nicely spicy, but not overly. Really great cheesesteak with onions and hot peppers, and generous cheese on top!

Parking: Lots of free parking, but it is a 2 hour limit.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

War Crimes

Very gud. Paul Va happened to be here. 10/10. gus is nice. He hand squeezes very good water out of the grounds of chatham. It is refreshing. Gus also hikes to the chatham mountains and gathersexquisite water. it is 3$

Konrad Roslonek

Pizza is great, well priced. Working next door also helps with convenience. I would love to see a specialty pie rotated in maybe once a week or month in addition to their already great staples to add some more variety. They do great pesto sauce which would be an amazing addition to drizzle on their pizzas or perhaps a bruschetta pesto pie as a pie added to the rotation.

Alex Poelzing

Very clean establishment, and very nice. BUT; Italian Beef Panino is was overpriced and tasteless. Was basically a Philly cheesesteak smothered in oil. Didn’t taste very good.Will definitely try the other menu items for eventually and update my rating.

Unknown User

We had my aunt's repast held here and the service and food were horrible. Nothing was prepared or ready when we arrived. They were over an hour late serving us our food and people left without eating. They didn't even bring out the antipasto till after our "cold" dinner was served and they only brought it out because my cousin had to ask for it. Over all it was a terrible experience.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Kieran Bergin

This place has phenomenal pizza and service. One worker named Holby served me with horse legs and was an absolute beast.

laura salas

Pizza and pasta were good def

Aidan Tornberg

No change given back

Patrick McGowan

Delicious food

Loading...