Cotardo's Ristorante Italiano

Brought my daughter and dad in for their first times at Cotardos. The atmosphere is very nice and cozy. The staff is friendly and the food is good. The only issue was with how long it took to come out. The soup came out, then the salad and then the entrees. But that was all within an hour. Not sure if this is the norm or if it was due to the large party they had that evening. However, i do recommend dining here

Always excellent.

Went for a lunch with my ladies group. Great server and food.

Food was excellent. Service excellent also. We went early so did not have to wait. Eight of us and we all enjoyed our meals. We all had enough for leftovers 😋

My wife and I love this place the decor reminds me of old school Italian. The garlic bread was amazing. The portions were generous. Our waiter, Sean was polite and very attentive even though he had lots of tables. I ordered the Pasta Dario my meal had too much marinara sauce. Ait seems it was cooked healthy not alot of salt which I liked.
I will definitely be back.

It was a little expensive!!! But for the quality and taste of the food it was worth the price!!! I got the Gnocchi Alfredo with chicken!!! I have never tasted an Alfredo as good as I tasted here!!!

What an excellent experience dining at Cotardo's! The atmosphere is pleasant and is beautifully designed. The waitstaff Donna and Raul were attentive and courteous throughout the entire 2 hours we were there. They certainly helped make the birthday celebration extra special. Majority ordered one of the dinner specials that night- the Crab Pasta. It was delicious and generously portioned and all of the entrées come with both soup and a salad! Keep in mind that it is BYOB which is favorable especially when dining with a group. I will be back again and will absolutely recommend Cotardo's to anyone looking for superb food, service and an overall satisfying experience!

We can’t say enough about the great meal we had at Cotardo’s this evening! We celebrated a very special friend’s 76th birthday and it was so nice. We were warmly greeted by Sean and seated quickly . Our servers Donna and Raul went above & beyond to make our celebration perfect! They could not have been any better! The food was outstanding . Dario you have an awesome restaurant. Thank you !

Was there tonight for a surprise birthday party
Food was excellent
I had the special of the day
jumbo lump crab over Linguine
Meal came with soup and salad
Huge portion and fairly priced
Donna and Raul took great care of us
I’ll definitely be back
Highly recommend this place

Our waitress Arly was absolutely AMAZING!! She was so pleasant and the best sense of humor! This was our first time here, and we will be coming back just for her! On top of the amazing service, the food was outstanding! Also want to give a shout out to the bus boy Aurolo (not sure if that is spelled correct) but he was also very accommodating! Thank you again Arly for being amazing we will see you soon!

Our waitress, Arly is the absolute best waitress. Her bright personality just made us laugh. The food is excellent. Would highly recommend. A plus food and service. Our busboy Autoro could not have been more pleasant as well.

Food was super delicious from the creamy tomato soup. To the chicken and flounder parmigiana. The garlic bread was the best I ever had. Arly was an awesome waitress that delivered superior customer service. Will most definitely be back!!!!!!

I ate here last night with my sister and her friend from work. Donna was our waitress. Another very good restaurant hidden in a New Jersey strip mall! Your meal comes with very yummy garlic bread for the table as well as soup and salad. The only reason I'm not giving the food 5 stars is because my shrimp fra diavolo wasn't spicy enough for me (but I'll give credit to the hostess when I mentioned this and she said just let us know and we'll make sure it's to your liking next time!). I'll definitely eat here again! My sister had the fettuccine Primavera with shrimp, and her friend had the Berscani. They really enjoyed their meals! Shrimp were large and perfectly cooked! Staff was very attentive. Didn't know it's a BYO - there are limited beverage choices - so pick up a nice bottle of wine before you go. Buon appetito!

Never fail to have an excellent time here with my family! Immensely appreciate Matt and the other staff for being so patient and helpful, especially on our takeout orders, so well made and convenient !

very nice and very friendly host, matt! best customer service i’ve had in a while. also very clean and the food was delicious. 10/10 would go again!!