Pizza flavor is decent but wished the guy who took my order told me they use beef sausage vs pork. The sausage used did not look appetizing (red colored) and tasted like cardboard. I called back to give him feedback and he was dismissive and tried to rush me off the phone. It's a shame because the pizza is good and I've been going there for years since before new owners took over.
Food: 3
Service: 3
Graphic Impulse
Pizza is simply not NJ pizza. Closer to a national chain style of pizza.
David Demianicz
The food is okay, not great. The guy I called was a little rude when trying to order on the phone. I got the 2 pies with garlic Knotts special and the pie have no flavor too it, but the Knotts were atleast crispy. A cheap place for a meal but not my favorite to go.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
Frank Ranu
Was looking for a new pizza place in the Clifton area and this was not it. I’ve had frozen pizzas with more flavor. The pizza looked very generic and like it was made from a template. No unique shape to it and it had very little sauce on it. Extremely disappointing and I won’t be ordering from here again.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 3
Abdullah Al Jaber
Really good pizza with excellent customer service.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mohammad Omar Sadat
Nice experience with Carlamia, thanks to their Manager for his prompt service…Highly
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: White Pizza
SUAT Kılıç
We wanted one pizza. It was also burnt and we wanted to change it. They gave us another customer's pizza and we couldn't eat it because it had too much BBQ sauce, they didn't replace it for us, we were not satisfied at all.
Yajaira Ruiz
Service was good,friendly staff. Food not that good. The fries taste like if they used old oil, and the pizza was flat not too much taste. The cheesesteak was ok.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 5
Paul Tomasheski
Stopped in for lunch. We had the pepperoni pizza. Good deal for $10.99. The pizza was very good, lots of cheese. The owner was very nice. I will have this again when I’m in the area.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
Laura V.
We were visiting friends in NJ for the 1s time and ur air b n b was in Clifton. I saw Carla Mia Pizzeria was in walking distance. I'm glad I checked it out. The service was great and the food was awesome. Thank you Carla Mia Pizzeria.
Imagine being yelled at by the owner in the parking lot to move from the owners spot. (ZERO SIGNAGE) Ok, I’ll move and never come back. Then called 3x about picking up pizza after you already said you won’t be going back there the first two calls.Never again. There’s plentyOf pizzerias in the area, learn to not be garbage to your customers.
Atmosphere: 1
Service: 1
Jamielee G.
After a bad day, order pizza from your favorite place. Pull into parking lot and get screamed at by the owner to move from a parking spot for the restaurant. No markings for owner, but he claims it was his. Told him I'll never go back. Got called 3x even after I said first time I'll never go back after the owner talked to me as I was garbage. There's plenty of other restaurants in the area that want my business and won't talk to me like garbage and harass me after. Good luck w your business and your awful customer service. I was there twice this week....
Syed Yaser Hussain
I have ordered the white pizza added, chicken, mushroom and olives and I loved it to the perfection.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: White Pizza
Jeff Z
Okay, I wish I had taken pictures not as if you need to take pictures of chicken wings with or without barbeque sauce. The chicken was done perfectly better than wings chicken wings because wings chicken wings are all dried up. My problem is wings that should have barbeque sauce on it should be drenched, not leaving the person to place it on . And if for some reason you need more, then get more. The plain wing was fine but needed to be drenched in barbeque sauce. Another problem was that the worker hardly spoke good English. It is very hard to communicate with him. I understand new management new workers that's fine but if you are going to do business with the public you need to effectively communicate to the public. One more problem was I just received a brochure from the establishment on Saturday in my mailbox. The coupons were already expired. 6/30/23. Don't know who placed three brochures in my mailbox, but when I saw that they had chicken wings with and without barbeque sauce, I thought this was good. But when I told the man behind the counter that I had these coupons he told me that he would have to talk to the manager asked were the manager was he told me in broken English that he was not there. I feel as if some of these issues are taken care of, and the place would be a better place. I'm not going to say I'm not going to be back, but I'll be watching. Please fix some of these issues. You're better than wings.Vegetarian options: There are plenty of vegetarian dishes. Please go and see what you would like.Kid-friendliness: Very children friendly bring the children.Parking: Handicap accessible wheelchair accessible walker accessible handicap people bring them on.Wheelchair accessibility: Wheelchair and handicap accessible please don't shy away cause you are handicap.Dietary restrictions: If you have a dietary problem I would explain to the staff your needs and hopefully they will help you out. If you talk Spanish, perhaps you have a better chance of getting what you need. I would give it a shot.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
wizardpower
This is the second time that they messed up my order. The second time around I ordered an eggplant parmesan and the guy insisted that's eggplant parmesan. When I got back home I noticed they just took up cut up meatballs and flattened it like eggplant parmesan... never going there again...
Pizza flavor is decent but wished the guy who took my order told me they use beef sausage vs pork. The sausage used did not look appetizing (red colored) and tasted like cardboard. I called back to give him feedback and he was dismissive and tried to rush me off the phone. It's a shame because the pizza is good and I've been going there for years since before new owners took over.
Food: 3
Service: 3
Pizza is simply not NJ pizza. Closer to a national chain style of pizza.
The food is okay, not great. The guy I called was a little rude when trying to order on the phone. I got the 2 pies with garlic Knotts special and the pie have no flavor too it, but the Knotts were atleast crispy. A cheap place for a meal but not my favorite to go.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
Was looking for a new pizza place in the Clifton area and this was not it. I’ve had frozen pizzas with more flavor. The pizza looked very generic and like it was made from a template. No unique shape to it and it had very little sauce on it. Extremely disappointing and I won’t be ordering from here again.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 3
Really good pizza with excellent customer service.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Nice experience with Carlamia, thanks to their Manager for his prompt service…Highly
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: White Pizza
We wanted one pizza. It was also burnt and we wanted to change it. They gave us another customer's pizza and we couldn't eat it because it had too much BBQ sauce, they didn't replace it for us, we were not satisfied at all.
Service was good,friendly staff. Food not that good. The fries taste like if they used old oil, and the pizza was flat not too much taste. The cheesesteak was ok.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 5
Stopped in for lunch. We had the pepperoni pizza. Good deal for $10.99. The pizza was very good, lots of cheese. The owner was very nice. I will have this again when I’m in the area.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
We were visiting friends in NJ for the 1s time and ur air b n b was in Clifton. I saw Carla Mia Pizzeria was in walking distance. I'm glad I checked it out. The service was great and the food was awesome. Thank you Carla Mia Pizzeria.
Restaurantji Recommends
Imagine being yelled at by the owner in the parking lot to move from the owners spot. (ZERO SIGNAGE) Ok, I’ll move and never come back. Then called 3x about picking up pizza after you already said you won’t be going back there the first two calls.Never again. There’s plentyOf pizzerias in the area, learn to not be garbage to your customers.
Atmosphere: 1
Service: 1
After a bad day, order pizza from your favorite place. Pull into parking lot and get screamed at by the owner to move from a parking spot for the restaurant. No markings for owner, but he claims it was his. Told him I'll never go back. Got called 3x even after I said first time I'll never go back after the owner talked to me as I was garbage. There's plenty of other restaurants in the area that want my business and won't talk to me like garbage and harass me after. Good luck w your business and your awful customer service. I was there twice this week....
I have ordered the white pizza added, chicken, mushroom and olives and I loved it to the perfection.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: White Pizza
Okay, I wish I had taken pictures not as if you need to take pictures of chicken wings with or without barbeque sauce. The chicken was done perfectly better than wings chicken wings because wings chicken wings are all dried up. My problem is wings that should have barbeque sauce on it should be drenched, not leaving the person to place it on . And if for some reason you need more, then get more. The plain wing was fine but needed to be drenched in barbeque sauce. Another problem was that the worker hardly spoke good English. It is very hard to communicate with him. I understand new management new workers that's fine but if you are going to do business with the public you need to effectively communicate to the public. One more problem was I just received a brochure from the establishment on Saturday in my mailbox. The coupons were already expired. 6/30/23. Don't know who placed three brochures in my mailbox, but when I saw that they had chicken wings with and without barbeque sauce, I thought this was good. But when I told the man behind the counter that I had these coupons he told me that he would have to talk to the manager asked were the manager was he told me in broken English that he was not there. I feel as if some of these issues are taken care of, and the place would be a better place. I'm not going to say I'm not going to be back, but I'll be watching. Please fix some of these issues. You're better than wings.Vegetarian options: There are plenty of vegetarian dishes. Please go and see what you would like.Kid-friendliness: Very children friendly bring the children.Parking: Handicap accessible wheelchair accessible walker accessible handicap people bring them on.Wheelchair accessibility: Wheelchair and handicap accessible please don't shy away cause you are handicap.Dietary restrictions: If you have a dietary problem I would explain to the staff your needs and hopefully they will help you out. If you talk Spanish, perhaps you have a better chance of getting what you need. I would give it a shot.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
This is the second time that they messed up my order. The second time around I ordered an eggplant parmesan and the guy insisted that's eggplant parmesan. When I got back home I noticed they just took up cut up meatballs and flattened it like eggplant parmesan... never going there again...
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1