The Bagel Store

I got a bacon, egg and cheese with extra cheese. Saddest bagel sandwich you ever seen, and if there was extra cheese I didn't find it! On top of it, they charged me $12 for it.
Probably the worst sandwich I ever had!

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 2

$5 for a cream cheese bagel, $4 dollar for a butter bagel. I ordered 3 bagels. they messed up a 3 bagel order and put the Cream Cheese on the wrong bagel and the butter on the wrong bagel. My son is allergic to cream cheese, and had an allergic reaction. I call them up to tell them this, shes telling me its an accident. It's not accident, im paying $5 for a bagel with creamcheese and a bagel with a butter that cost you guys $1, at least with a $3 to $4 markup, make the correct order. Shes telling me i dont know how did it, im like theres 3 people in the store, its not hard to figure it out. Just excuses that it's an accident. Not what i want to hear. If your messing up a simple 3 bagel order, your messing up a lot of orders.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 1

Service: 1

Best damn bagels hands down. These guys know how to make them. Sorry Ess-a-bagel (NYC), you’re a sorry second. I travel out of my way to visit this place because it’s worth it. Long live Colts Neck Bagels.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

This place is literally the worst. $10 for a bacon egg and cheese and this is how they cheap out.

What a disgrace. The owners should be ashamed of themselves.

Gross, avoid.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Very delicious! Got the Mexican breakfast wraps and they did not disappoint

It's ok, but what got me to write this review is the bacon egg and cheese. These folks *must* be making money selling a slice of bacon, an egg and a slice of cheese for $10.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 3

$7 for a bagel with olive cream cheese is a little ridiculous.
$10 for a bacon egg and cheese is also very ridiculous.

And, finally, the bagels are mediocre at best. I pop in here when I have no time and need breakfast. Otherwise, I would never go out of my way.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 4

Always out of muffins

$7 for just 1 bagel and cream cheese?!? No price written on the board either. Crazy expensive. Bagel was ok but not worth the price at all.

I was charged $8.98 for an everything FLAGEL with cream cheese. Never in my life have I paid this. I should have just gotten breakfast in NYC when I got to work. To be honest, it was just mediocre. This is robbery and never again.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 2

Service: 2

i’m so sorry but it was the worst bagel i had in a very long time.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 1

Service: 5

Came in looking to take my daughter on a random Thursday morning (today) for bagels before we went to the park. I was going to order a plain bagel with Cream Cheese and my daughter was going to get an Egg Bagel with Cream Cheese and a coffee they tried telling me it was going to be 18 dollars. That is the most ridiculous prices I ever seen in my life. Go the other direction into freehold and get the same bagel for 3.50 or what’s even crazier do yourself this favor like we did and go over to colts neck Eatery in the same parking lot and get the 2 egg platter with pancakes or toast and home fries for 7 dollars. I much rather have a full meal like we did then go to this bagel store and have 2 bales and a coffee for a ridiculously expensive price. Can’t wrap my head around 2 bagels and a coffee could be more expensive than 2 eggs platters with pancakes lol this places pricing is a joke. Do not go

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 3

The food is very good and quite cheap

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 3

I work at a small business myself, but I legit got robbed. I was nice kid was eating behind the counter, not friendly at all. I get it bad days, but I got charged $3.50 for A CAN of seltzer. When the orange juice bottle was under $3. I asked nicely, Maybe there was a larger bottle or something I got mistakenly charged for. I got ignored and handed a bag then a "have a nice day".

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 3

Service: 1

Beware, there are no prices on the menu 👻