1st time trying it was a huge disappointment the quality of the food is horrible and overpriced.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Wings, Soup, Sandwiches, Mac & Cheese
R.S. Marcus
The staff at Stoltzfus Bbq are about as nice as you'll ever meet in your life. They give you good food at a fair price. Those smoked turkey legs are to die for and I love the bbq chicken wings too.
Everything was delicious! There was so much to select from. I chose to get a BBQ wing platter with 2 sides which were Mac and cheese and roasted potatoes. The mac and cheese was just ok but I didn't expect it to be so much, it wasn't as cheesy it just takes like noodles with creamy cheese sauce and very wet in texture, but it was edible but I probably wouldn't get it again. The roasted potatoes were very good, exactly how it sounds. I also picked, a kielbasa, which was very good. A smoked turkey leg, delicious and juicy. A side of green beans, just tasted steamed or boiled a bit with maybe butter in it but it was just ok in my opinion, I liked the texture not the flavor as it wasn't much to it, just basic green beans. I also, picked a side order of wings, which I received the bbq and the plain smoked wings and my family and I enjoyed them, they were cooked just right and very juicy and the BBQ wings had a good smoky BBQ taste. That I would try again. But yhe lady who served me was very nice, friendly and professional, she was very helpful and patient as I really was amazed with such a huge selection. Everything was hot and fresh and they also gave me a large quantity. It was enough for I bought but lasted for 2 nights dinner. I also, got their fresh homemade Lemonade in a half gallon, that was delicious as well! I will definitely be back again! ?❤️
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wings, Roasted Potatoes
Riah L
Everything was super good and fresh. The mashed potatoes were outstanding. There’s always a long line but it moves pretty quickly. Highly recommend.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Isidoros "Steve" Ziakas
Great Ribs and their employees are very nice.
John Schoonejongen
The ribs and chicken are both fantastic. Love the roasted potatoes as well. Be prepared for lines on Saturdays, though. The place is very popular.
Enidza Maldonado-Arana
My husband and I stopped by and had brisket and mac & cheese. It's always busy but today was a nice quiet day to sit down and enjoy our meal. The staff are very friendly.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
jose gonzalez
The best American amish food ever
GoJasonGo
I love this place. The food, the people, the vibe.. all great. I would move in here if I could
my husband is a meat connoisseur. He was excited to try the brisket but said it tasted off. There was excessive fat and said it tasted like yesterday's meat. He threw about half a pound out after 2 bites. I've never seen this man trash a chunk of meat.
Rob Jacobs
Mmmmmm.
Wynette Jackson (shorty)
Always good food.
Jason W
I love this place. The food, the people, the vibe.. all great. I would move in here if I could
Mike Q
Got horrendous food poisoning from the brisket here, the whole family and a friend. It even got my dog sick, it's been like 7 days she's older and not doing well. I hope if this happens to someone else they call the CDC with a sample of the food this is unacceptable.
1st time trying it was a huge disappointment the quality of the food is horrible and overpriced.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Wings, Soup, Sandwiches, Mac & Cheese
The staff at Stoltzfus Bbq are about as nice as you'll ever meet in your life. They give you good food at a fair price. Those smoked turkey legs are to die for and I love the bbq chicken wings too.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wings, Kielbasa, Roasted Potatoes, Spare Ribs, Sandwiches, Babyback Ribs, Mac & Cheese, BBQ Chicken Whole
Everything was delicious! There was so much to select from. I chose to get a BBQ wing platter with 2 sides which were Mac and cheese and roasted potatoes. The mac and cheese was just ok but I didn't expect it to be so much, it wasn't as cheesy it just takes like noodles with creamy cheese sauce and very wet in texture, but it was edible but I probably wouldn't get it again. The roasted potatoes were very good, exactly how it sounds. I also picked, a kielbasa, which was very good. A smoked turkey leg, delicious and juicy. A side of green beans, just tasted steamed or boiled a bit with maybe butter in it but it was just ok in my opinion, I liked the texture not the flavor as it wasn't much to it, just basic green beans. I also, picked a side order of wings, which I received the bbq and the plain smoked wings and my family and I enjoyed them, they were cooked just right and very juicy and the BBQ wings had a good smoky BBQ taste. That I would try again. But yhe lady who served me was very nice, friendly and professional, she was very helpful and patient as I really was amazed with such a huge selection. Everything was hot and fresh and they also gave me a large quantity. It was enough for I bought but lasted for 2 nights dinner. I also, got their fresh homemade Lemonade in a half gallon, that was delicious as well! I will definitely be back again! ?❤️
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wings, Roasted Potatoes
Everything was super good and fresh. The mashed potatoes were outstanding. There’s always a long line but it moves pretty quickly. Highly recommend.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great Ribs and their employees are very nice.
The ribs and chicken are both fantastic. Love the roasted potatoes as well. Be prepared for lines on Saturdays, though. The place is very popular.
My husband and I stopped by and had brisket and mac & cheese. It's always busy but today was a nice quiet day to sit down and enjoy our meal. The staff are very friendly.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The best American amish food ever
I love this place. The food, the people, the vibe.. all great. I would move in here if I could
Delicious
Restaurantji Recommends
my husband is a meat connoisseur. He was excited to try the brisket but said it tasted off. There was excessive fat and said it tasted like yesterday's meat. He threw about half a pound out after 2 bites. I've never seen this man trash a chunk of meat.
Mmmmmm.
Always good food.
I love this place. The food, the people, the vibe.. all great. I would move in here if I could
Got horrendous food poisoning from the brisket here, the whole family and a friend. It even got my dog sick, it's been like 7 days she's older and not doing well. I hope if this happens to someone else they call the CDC with a sample of the food this is unacceptable.
Loading...