Nicholas Creamery

586 River Rd, Fair Haven
(732) 852-2033

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Brown Sugar Cookie Dough
Gelato

Menu

Featured items
Brown Sugar Cookie Dough Pint
Homemade Brown Sugar Ice Cream with tons and tons of Cookie Dough. Perfection.
PeanutButterpalooza Pint
We created the yummiest, peanut butter-iest Homemade Peanut Butter Ice Cream, tossed in a lotta Crushed Oreos and threw in handfuls of made from scratch Chocolate Peanut Butter Cups for good measure.
Mint Chocolate Chunk Pint
Delicious, refreshing, homemade, all natural Mint Ice Cream (its green hue is drawn from a leafy vegetable!!) with crushed Oreos tossed in. One taste and we knew it was MINT to be a Creamery classic!
Coffee Bourbon Chocolate Chunk
Homemade Bourbon Barrel Aged Coffee. Sweet Cream Ice Cream with Chocolate Chunks. (Contains dairy, egg)
Cookies N Cream Pint
Homemade Sweet Cream ice cream with lots of crushed Oreo Cookies. Simple, classic and so freaking delicious!
Tahitian Vanilla Milkshake
Good Ole Fashioned Chocolate Pint
When this flavor landed at the Creamery, it had us at first bite. Homemade creamy, dark chocolate ice cream- Chocoholics- you will LOVE this one.
Booskerdoo Coffee Crunch Pint
Our #1 BESTSELLER! Booskerdoo Cold Brew, Fresh Coffee Beans, Hazelnuts. Contains Nuts & Eggs.
Mint with Alotta Chip Milkshake
Mint chip ice cream, more chocolate chips, whipped cream & a hot fudge drizzle
Ooey Gooey Peanut Butter Milkshake
Vanilla ice cream, homemade peanut butter sauce, peanut butter cups, whipped cream, hot fudge drizzle, whipped cream & cherry
Chocolate Milkshake
Strawberries N Cream Pint
Homemade Sweet Ice Cream mixed with homemade Strawberry Jam. (Contains Dairy)
Classic Nickwiches (6 per order)
Housemade Chocolate Chip Cookies stuffed with Homemade Chocolate and Vanilla Ice Cream and Sprinkles.
Tahitian Vanilla Pint
Plain ol' Vanilla? Come on now... we can do better than that! We scrape the pulp from Tahitian Vanilla beans and soak them in vodka to create our own handmade vanilla extract. Then we churn the extract with milk, cream, eggs and sugar and, voila, an ice cream sent from Vanilla heaven is born.

Ice Cream Pints
Tahitian Vanilla Pint
Plain ol' Vanilla? Come on now... we can do better than that! We scrape the pulp from Tahitian Vanilla beans and soak them in vodka to create our own handmade vanilla extract. Then we churn the extract with milk, cream, eggs and sugar and, voila, an ice cream sent from Vanilla heaven is born.
Booskerdoo Coffee Crunch Pint
Our #1 BESTSELLER! Booskerdoo Cold Brew, Fresh Coffee Beans, Hazelnuts. Contains Nuts & Eggs.
Good Ole Fashioned Chocolate Pint
When this flavor landed at the Creamery, it had us at first bite. Homemade creamy, dark chocolate ice cream- Chocoholics- you will LOVE this one.
Mint Chocolate Chunk Pint
Delicious, refreshing, homemade, all natural Mint Ice Cream (its green hue is drawn from a leafy vegetable!!) with crushed Oreos tossed in. One taste and we knew it was MINT to be a Creamery classic!
PeanutButterpalooza Pint
We created the yummiest, peanut butter-iest Homemade Peanut Butter Ice Cream, tossed in a lotta Crushed Oreos and threw in handfuls of made from scratch Chocolate Peanut Butter Cups for good measure.
Cookies N Cream Pint
Homemade Sweet Cream ice cream with lots of crushed Oreo Cookies. Simple, classic and so freaking delicious!
Brown Sugar Cookie Dough Pint
Homemade Brown Sugar Ice Cream with tons and tons of Cookie Dough. Perfection.
Strawberries N Cream Pint
Homemade Sweet Ice Cream mixed with homemade Strawberry Jam. (Contains Dairy)
Coffee Bourbon Chocolate Chunk
Homemade Bourbon Barrel Aged Coffee. Sweet Cream Ice Cream with Chocolate Chunks. (Contains dairy, egg)

Creamy Dreamy Milkshakes
Chocolate Milkshake
Tahitian Vanilla Milkshake
Ooey Gooey Peanut Butter Milkshake
Vanilla ice cream, homemade peanut butter sauce, peanut butter cups, whipped cream, hot fudge drizzle, whipped cream & cherry
Hudson Jitterbug Milkshake
Hudson café coffee crunch ice cream & a hot fudge drizzle
Mint with Alotta Chip Milkshake
Mint chip ice cream, more chocolate chips, whipped cream & a hot fudge drizzle

Classic Nickwiches
Classic Nickwiches (6 per order)
Housemade Chocolate Chip Cookies stuffed with Homemade Chocolate and Vanilla Ice Cream and Sprinkles.

8" Cakes
Celebration Ice Cream Cake
Layers of HOMEMADE Rainbows and Clouds and Valrhona Chocolate Ice Cream with Homemade Fudge and Cookie Crumbs. Feeds 8-10
Cookie Dream Ice Cream Cake
Layers of HOMEMADE Brown Sugar Cookie Dough and Cookies n Cream Ice Cream with Homemade Fudge and Cookie Crumbs. Feeds 8-10.
Peanutbutterpalooza Ice Cream Cake
Layers of HOMEMADE PeanutbutterPalooza and Valrhona Chocolate Ice Cream with Homemade Fudge and Cookie Crumbs. Feeds 8-10.

Side Toppings
Rainbow Sprinkles Topping
Chocolate Sprinkles Topping
M&M's Topping
Mermaid Sprinkles Topping
Cookie Dough Topping
Peanut Butter Cups Topping
Brownies Topping
Cherries Topping
Gummi Bears Topping

Homemade Sauces
Homemade Hot Fudge
Homemade Salted Caramel Sauce
Homemade Peanut Butter Sauce

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: facebook
+19 photos
Photo credit: facebook
+18 photos
Add a photo

Order Online

Recent Reviews

Incredibly fresh and always so many seasonal/rotating flavors. Loved that they did the “battle of the schools” last year, a great way to highlight their connection to the community
September 2025
Overall, great ice cream. One of us had a brown sugar dough flavor that was great. The other had Peanut Butter Palooza (sp) mixed with plain chocolate. The plain chocolate was bland and not very chocolatey. Service at Tinton Falls was quick and friendly.
August 2025
My fiance and I are obsessed with the ice cream but they stopped doing party tubs which is kind of obnoxious. Just raise the price a little don’t force your fans to by pints at a mark up
May 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Over Easy Kitchen - Fair Haven - 588 River Rd
Brunch, American
No 1 Chinese Restaurant - 591 River Rd
Chinese, Vegetarian
Tavolo Pronto - 610 River Rd
Bistros, Pizza, Italian, American, Vegetarian

Nicholas Creamery

586 River Rd, Fair Haven, NJ 07704
(732) 852-2033