Food is scarce, checkout the dumpster for the Marie Callender boxes and Stouffer trays. Unclean.
Michael Bowen
Every single bad review is absolutely true, the food taste like garbage. We saw several roaches climbing the wall to the ceiling. I would never take my guest here again. Pure dollop slop. You will be disappointed and grossed out.
Efrain Ruiz
Best Pizza in New Jersey hands down. We live in Elizabeth N.J. & drive all the way to Fabio's if we want the Best Pizza in Jersey. The food and service are something else.. 😉😉👍👍💪💪
Food: 5
Service: 5
Flava Dave
The most delicious pizza I had in a long time. And the owner blessed me with the veggie slice. That is now my new favorite. Best pizza around. No competition.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Veggie Pizza
lu la
Met my cousins here yesterday 2/17/25 for the first time and everything was delicious! I drove one hour from Easton, PA and would do it again in a heartbeat!!! We ordered a large pizza and it was fantastic. Cooked to perfection and absolutely no flop! Service was great and spoke to the owner who was extremely attentive to his customers. Will definitely be making a road trip to come back again.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
N R
Ordered fries for delivery and they were greasy and quite frankly, gross. The chicken California sandwich was tasteless. And by the way, if you’d like onions on that sandwich, it will cost extra. Very disappointed with the overall quality of the food.
William Wittenberg
Some of my favorite pizza in the area!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Anthony Ottati
I order a ham and cheese calzone and added peppers. I’ve eaten two thirds of the calzone and have not gotten to any ham or peppers. There’s a small pile of ham and peppers on one end of the calzone. If I wanted a cheese calzone I would have ordered one. If you are going to sell a ham and cheese calzone fill it with ham. This is not the first time this has happened to me at Fabio’s, but it is the first time I’m reviewing it.
Food: 1
Chanel Lowery
Whatever initiatives are going on at the counter of this restaurant I support (T-shirts, donations, etc.) and I don't even reside in Fanwood. I also tip often and well. Unfortunately, more times than not my order is wrong and it's never the same price for the same two things I've been ordering for almost 2 years, unless the kind, young Latin woman with the glasses is working. Tonight took the cake. I was going to leave because it was so busy, but I was convinced to stay. My total came to 29 something for the same thing I ordered a few days ago that came to 24 something. I got home to find little to no dressing on my gccs and there's a cucumber in it. Over it.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 2
Jeremy Van Dunk
I ordered some food waited over an hour when I was told 30 min called back was told it was on the way called again then was told it was sitting there horrible service for sure
We have ordered Fabio’s a few times in the beginning it was great the last two times we ordered the pizza was super oily and pizza fell apart and last night order the cheese slid to one side the drive must of drove like a mad man he definitely pulled pizza out of the trunk so it had be sliding all over the place highly disappointed
Food: 1
got2600
I ordered a large cheese pie at 5:16pm, they said 1 hour. I show up at 6:30pm the pizza is not even in the oven and the order is buried under other orders on their wall. I know it's Friday night but that's ridiculous. This is not the first time. They forgot my order before. After an hour waiting. To make up for it they rushed to cook me a pizza and it was undercooked and gross, no thanks! I did not want that same result so I took my business elsewhere.
Service: 1
MATCH611
The majority of my meals here are delicious. This time, not so much. My to go order was horrible! 2 very bland veggie slices and stale garlic knots.
Food: 1
Service: 4
eva McNally
Good pizza, but never go on a Friday night! It’s too frustrating to deal with the masses of people there.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 3
Greg S
Absolutely outstanding, homemade, fresh, hot, delicious, authentic, Italian food and pizza, at ridiculously inexpensive, 1990's pricing. Very casual, and a BYOB to boot. Ronnie and his team run a classy establishment, and everyone knows it. You'll always have some idiot, like the guy who wrote the recent 1-star review before me, who can't be pleased, no matter how good something is. This place is the real deal. A perfect example of how and why you don't need to spend $100 for dinner on two people. And the portions are so huge, you get two meals in one. Be prepared to take home leftovers. Very highly recommended. A+++++
Food is scarce, checkout the dumpster for the Marie Callender boxes and Stouffer trays. Unclean.
Every single bad review is absolutely true, the food taste like garbage. We saw several roaches climbing the wall to the ceiling. I would never take my guest here again. Pure dollop slop. You will be disappointed and grossed out.
Best Pizza in New Jersey hands down. We live in Elizabeth N.J. & drive all the way to Fabio's if we want the Best Pizza in Jersey. The food and service are something else.. 😉😉👍👍💪💪
Food: 5
Service: 5
The most delicious pizza I had in a long time. And the owner blessed me with the veggie slice. That is now my new favorite. Best pizza around. No competition.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Veggie Pizza
Met my cousins here yesterday 2/17/25 for the first time and everything was delicious! I drove one hour from Easton, PA and would do it again in a heartbeat!!! We ordered a large pizza and it was fantastic. Cooked to perfection and absolutely no flop! Service was great and spoke to the owner who was extremely attentive to his customers. Will definitely be making a road trip to come back again.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ordered fries for delivery and they were greasy and quite frankly, gross. The chicken California sandwich was tasteless. And by the way, if you’d like onions on that sandwich, it will cost extra. Very disappointed with the overall quality of the food.
Some of my favorite pizza in the area!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
I order a ham and cheese calzone and added peppers. I’ve eaten two thirds of the calzone and have not gotten to any ham or peppers. There’s a small pile of ham and peppers on one end of the calzone. If I wanted a cheese calzone I would have ordered one. If you are going to sell a ham and cheese calzone fill it with ham. This is not the first time this has happened to me at Fabio’s, but it is the first time I’m reviewing it.
Food: 1
Whatever initiatives are going on at the counter of this restaurant I support (T-shirts, donations, etc.) and I don't even reside in Fanwood. I also tip often and well. Unfortunately, more times than not my order is wrong and it's never the same price for the same two things I've been ordering for almost 2 years, unless the kind, young Latin woman with the glasses is working. Tonight took the cake. I was going to leave because it was so busy, but I was convinced to stay. My total came to 29 something for the same thing I ordered a few days ago that came to 24 something. I got home to find little to no dressing on my gccs and there's a cucumber in it. Over it.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 2
I ordered some food waited over an hour when I was told 30 min called back was told it was on the way called again then was told it was sitting there horrible service for sure
Service: 1
Restaurantji Recommends
We have ordered Fabio’s a few times in the beginning it was great the last two times we ordered the pizza was super oily and pizza fell apart and last night order the cheese slid to one side the drive must of drove like a mad man he definitely pulled pizza out of the trunk so it had be sliding all over the place highly disappointed
Food: 1
I ordered a large cheese pie at 5:16pm, they said 1 hour. I show up at 6:30pm the pizza is not even in the oven and the order is buried under other orders on their wall. I know it's Friday night but that's ridiculous. This is not the first time. They forgot my order before. After an hour waiting. To make up for it they rushed to cook me a pizza and it was undercooked and gross, no thanks! I did not want that same result so I took my business elsewhere.
Service: 1
The majority of my meals here are delicious. This time, not so much. My to go order was horrible!
2 very bland veggie slices and stale garlic knots.
Food: 1
Service: 4
Good pizza, but never go on a Friday night! It’s too frustrating to deal with the masses of people there.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 3
Absolutely outstanding, homemade, fresh, hot, delicious, authentic, Italian food and pizza, at ridiculously inexpensive, 1990's pricing. Very casual, and a BYOB to boot. Ronnie and his team run a classy establishment, and everyone knows it. You'll always have some idiot, like the guy who wrote the recent 1-star review before me, who can't be pleased, no matter how good something is. This place is the real deal. A perfect example of how and why you don't need to spend $100 for dinner on two people. And the portions are so huge, you get two meals in one. Be prepared to take home leftovers. Very highly recommended. A+++++
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...