Ninety Acres
200 Natirar Dr, Peapack and Gladstone
(908) 901-9500
Recent Reviews
Sort by
Atmosphere: {{ item.info.Atmosphere }}
Food: {{ item.info.Food }}
Service: {{ item.info.Service }}
Recommended dishes: {{ item.info['Recommended dishes'] }}
Everything was perfect! Staff and service were impeccable. The presentation of food and drinks was also top notch. They were great with my food allergies (gluten, legumes) and the food was delicious. I was actually able to have a dessert that I loved! While it is a little pricey you get what you pay for. We will definitely be retuning.
We frequent Ninety Acres and just finished an amazing cooking experience a week earlier when we made a reservation for 1-24 26 birthday dinner. Our reservation was 8:30 for 6 guests. The open kitchen area was chilly and we have never had such poor service. 2 wines came out at 9:00 and 9:10 4 other cocktails came with apps. Burrata was frozen inside , brioche ran out and pork chop and pasta was cold and had to be warmed. No apology. It was only when a manager looked over at the table did the drinks come. Almost end of dinner were we asked if we wanted a 2nd drink. Bill over 800$. I usually tell people about Natirar but sadly it was a huge disappointment for my husbands birthday.
The service was wonderful, good and wine amazing. The only downside was we were seated next to the kitchen. It was less intimate and felt less elevated than the main dining area. We would have preferred to be in the main dining area.
Absolutely delicious from start to end with great service! We have some left overs which I cannot even wait to eat!
Megan was an awesome server! So personable and attentive! Would like to have her again next time!
One of the best dining experiences we have had. The staff was very cordial, ambiance was great and food was out of this world. If you want a nice dinner out, this is the place. Will definitely return.
We enjoyed our birthday celebration. We felt that service was above average and the food was excellent.
The entire experience was just average and did not justify the price. The servers were rushing us, the food was cold and they ran out of some menu items. Just ok overall.
Excellent meal for New Year's Eve. Service was fabulous - so attentive. Food was delicious - fixed menu but great variety in choices. Great evening - nice to not be rushed given the upcoming new year.
Great venue and ambience. Food was good but prices are really high - paid similar prices for Michelin star in NYC so I do feel the prices are a bit too high. But overall good venue.
Restaurantji Recommends
We celebrated our anniversary at Ninety Acres. Food and service were both good. Ambience was ok. Dress code on website said jackets preferred and no jeans, but the majority of the men were wearing jeans. There were also a lot of young children, even at 8:30pm.
First strike-$20.00 to valet park! Lukewarm greeting by hostess and no offer to check our heavy coats. Escorted to our seats, through the cozy dimly lit restaurant to a brightly lit table near the kitchen. Tells us there's no other table and we had requested this room. (I did not) She offered to dim the lights but did not. We asked our waitress twice and it was finally done, making it far more pleasant. Our waitress spoke very quickly, with well rehearsed phrases. No attempt at any warmth. The food is very pricey but fine. Certainly not among the best meals we've ever eaten. The runner who served the food literally dropped the plates and ran. We couldn't even ask for an explanation of something. When he presented two of us our birthday desserts, he put them down, candles burning, without a word. My husband asked for coffee three times when the rest of us had already been served our beverages and finally flagged down another waiter to bring it. This reservation was made in October to celebrate a milestone birthday. I had talked about it and looked forward to it with great anticipation. I (and my companions), were all very disappointed in the whole experience.
Great experience it's our second time here. The ambiance the food options and drinks are crafted wonderfully
X/Mas Eve 2025 early seating 4:30p. Parking was a tutorial on how to in advance get your car - what an Easter if holiday family time. Seated promptly, screaming children allowed for these prices in the restaurant. It was normalized. Immediate water service, and table waiter introduction. Price fixed menu 4 selections 3 courses. The interior had no holiday decor, no music. The bar was empty @ 4:30p. Constant waiter trying to get us to eat fast to change courses to stay in task to turn over the table if two against the wall with long to the floor window drapes causing un comfortability. My dessert was not good at all, my cold appetizer very good served in a warm plate - coffee lukewarm at dessert, entree filet was dry & I asked for medium rare & it was medium. My companion had same filet just prepared right. The moral here is it looks good but highly disappointed & consistently inconsistent - our table was turned over in 90 min. Bathroom for females was fair not great in cleanliness. So , events here maybe outdoors was not open using heat lamps on patios & lights. No snow it was 40 degrees. No fireplace indoors , just plain Jane uneventful not a memory & not my first rodeo here . Choose wisely& this place isn't it! Over priced not delivered - could have been a diner -
This used to be an amazing restaurant and dining experience. It was one of our family's favorite five dining restaurants. We were sorely disappointed last night. Will NOT be returning.
Loading...