Normally I wouldn’t write a review but I feel as though I had to this time. My mother went and picked up a Giant #13 for us for dinner. Upon opening it, right away I noticed it didn’t look as full as it normally does. For it being the “giant” size, there should’ve been more meat for sure, and I didn’t even see two of the meats that were supposed to be on there. Now I will say we didn’t get cheese, onion, or tomato, however that does not take up much room on the bread. I always order it like this and today it was so disappointingly thin. Not to mention the balance for the oil and vinegar to go cup was way too oily. The taste was still great, but the bread wasn’t totally up to par. I normally go to the Clinton location as it’s closer and I am never disappointed, but today we gave Flemington a shot because it was more convenient. Don’t think I will be coming back to this location especially if the amount of meat on a $20 sub is so sparse.
Nadia Jones
Excellent customer service. I love how sweet your workers are. Thank you!
Fruit of Life Creations
Thank you for offering gluten free option. Your staff was amazing and took such great care in ensuring no cross contamination. The bread was pre wrapped. They used new gloves, new utensils and they have no contact condiments. What attention to detail. Makes eating out a pleasant experience when staff is so well informed and is caring. Most amazing sub I’ve had in such a long time. 5 starts to the staff 😁
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Debbie V
Has gotten better
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Daniela Perez Gonzalez
Went there and got R43, asked for banana peppers and not getting it at the end. Staff lack of kindness, 4 people working but only 1 took our order, made it and brought us up. As someone that worked for Jersey Mike’s before, very disappointing. Not to mention also the whole place was dirty, there were no customers around and staff was not doing side work, very unfortunate.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 2
Keith Streeter
Meets Jersey Mike's Standards
Barbara McGrath
My first time at JM’s in Flemington. Great and friendly service and the sandwich was perfect. Well done!!!
Susan Hilfreiche
I asked for sauce on the side, and bacon on my sandwich. I didn’t get either the sauce on the side and the bacon on the sandwich. The bacon is a two dollar up charge. Do your job right.
Brian Decker
What to expect from the chain, a good solid sub
A T
The older lady putting toppings on starts wrapping my sandwich up before its done , doesnt ask if i want anything else then gives outrageous attitude when i try to stop her and let her know the sandwich was not done I come here every other week with no problem . Ridiculous
I rolled up ten minutes before closing for my son’s Big Kahuna and saw an employee cleaning the grill. A different employee greeted me, and I asked if the grill was closed. He smiled and said, “No, the grill is open. How can I help you?” He took my order and reminded me I had a free sub that I could use. I asked his name, and he politely said, Grant. He even asked my name and thanked me for coming in. Way to go, Grant, for making my late-night food run possible!
Vegetarian options: My go-to is the #14, where I request the early morning cheese that they cut and store separately before they slice the meats on the slicer.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Big Kahuna Cheese Steak
Terry Gartland
So I love Jersey Mike's sandwiches, trying not to eat these too often as I want to drop a few pounds. So "it's a treat" when I order here via the app. Sandwiches tonight were good, BUT . . . more often than not when I order at this location via the app, they ignore the request for whole wheat or garlic rosemary bread, as they did tonight. And ignored my request for banana peppers. It would not take much to do this right. When you're filling orders, how about reading details, and giving customers what they asked for? Consider that for some customers, they might eat one good sub per month and look to Jersey Mike's for that ultimate sandwich experience. Not in Flemington. Meh.
IzzyT t
Great subs made to order
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mark Winey
Great classic sub sandwiches... high quality deli meats, fresh rolls.... get it "Mike's Way".
Normally I wouldn’t write a review but I feel as though I had to this time. My mother went and picked up a Giant #13 for us for dinner. Upon opening it, right away I noticed it didn’t look as full as it normally does. For it being the “giant” size, there should’ve been more meat for sure, and I didn’t even see two of the meats that were supposed to be on there. Now I will say we didn’t get cheese, onion, or tomato, however that does not take up much room on the bread. I always order it like this and today it was so disappointingly thin. Not to mention the balance for the oil and vinegar to go cup was way too oily. The taste was still great, but the bread wasn’t totally up to par. I normally go to the Clinton location as it’s closer and I am never disappointed, but today we gave Flemington a shot because it was more convenient. Don’t think I will be coming back to this location especially if the amount of meat on a $20 sub is so sparse.
Excellent customer service. I love how sweet your workers are. Thank you!
Thank you for offering gluten free option. Your staff was amazing and took such great care in ensuring no cross contamination. The bread was pre wrapped. They used new gloves, new utensils and they have no contact condiments. What attention to detail. Makes eating out a pleasant experience when staff is so well informed and is caring. Most amazing sub I’ve had in such a long time. 5 starts to the staff 😁
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Has gotten better
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Went there and got R43, asked for banana peppers and not getting it at the end. Staff lack of kindness, 4 people working but only 1 took our order, made it and brought us up. As someone that worked for Jersey Mike’s before, very disappointing. Not to mention also the whole place was dirty, there were no customers around and staff was not doing side work, very unfortunate.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 2
Meets Jersey Mike's Standards
My first time at JM’s in Flemington. Great and friendly service and the sandwich was perfect. Well done!!!
I asked for sauce on the side, and bacon on my sandwich. I didn’t get either the sauce on the side and the bacon on the sandwich. The bacon is a two dollar up charge. Do your job right.
What to expect from the chain, a good solid sub
The older lady putting toppings on starts wrapping my sandwich up before its done , doesnt ask if i want anything else then gives outrageous attitude when i try to stop her and let her know the sandwich was not done
I come here every other week with no problem . Ridiculous
Restaurantji Recommends
Always great sandwiches in Flemington!
I rolled up ten minutes before closing for my son’s Big Kahuna and saw an employee cleaning the grill. A different employee greeted me, and I asked if the grill was closed. He smiled and said, “No, the grill is open. How can I help you?” He took my order and reminded me I had a free sub that I could use. I asked his name, and he politely said, Grant. He even asked my name and thanked me for coming in. Way to go, Grant, for making my late-night food run possible!
Vegetarian options: My go-to is the #14, where I request the early morning cheese that they cut and store separately before they slice the meats on the slicer.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Big Kahuna Cheese Steak
So I love Jersey Mike's sandwiches, trying not to eat these too often as I want to drop a few pounds. So "it's a treat" when I order here via the app. Sandwiches tonight were good, BUT . . . more often than not when I order at this location via the app, they ignore the request for whole wheat or garlic rosemary bread, as they did tonight. And ignored my request for banana peppers. It would not take much to do this right. When you're filling orders, how about reading details, and giving customers what they asked for? Consider that for some customers, they might eat one good sub per month and look to Jersey Mike's for that ultimate sandwich experience. Not in Flemington. Meh.
Great subs made to order
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great classic sub sandwiches... high quality deli meats, fresh rolls.... get it "Mike's Way".
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...