I always get the chicken parm with penne vodka. I love this place good is always consistent. It’s always a hit. The pasta dishes are all great. The give you a decent portion so it’s pricey but you can definitely share the food. I give this establishment a 8/10
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Old City Cafe & Grill
A hidden gem surprisingly great food I had a chicken soup / stuffed mushrooms and a ribeye steak cooked to perfection fairly priced it’s a must stop every time I am in that
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Russ T.
This restaurant is located inside the Doubletree hotel. In the area to go see the Yankees play. Had dinner after the day game....too tired to venture out in the city, and the food had great reviews....started with calamari, the wife and I love this... very large portions....then they brought us beautiful mixed green salads...a def step up from the bland ice berg mix you normally see. The wife had ravioli, and I had the seafood linguini. Mussels, clams, shrimp, calamari tossed with perfectly cooked pasta, in a light tomato sauce. Perfect!! No need for dessert, we had doubletree chic chip cookies in our room! Service was friendly, timely, average. The next morning we are in the same room for breakfast. Totally opposite....terrible buffet...service non existent....nice waiter, never around. It's a buffet, had to ask for silverware, had to ask for coffee, had to ask for check....
Pierre Here
Quality wise it’s a hampton or holiday. Restaurant is great. Be warned their shrimp scampi has no pasta. Comes with vegetables which are really good but pasta I had to order separate so total was $40+ tip. But it was delicious. Problem with the tub. The stem you pull to switch from tub to shower mode broke but they fixed it right away
Dennis R.
With the outside traffic being so bad and having already traveled for hours, I decided to eat here with my girlfriend and her daughter who is 6 years old. We stayed at the Double Tree hotel and had just finished swimming and were hungry and anxious for a good meal. We dressed up for the occasion and were warmly greeted by the host and hostess. Our server Arian was a friendly gentleman from Albania. Excellent waiter. They had mozzarella sticks so my 6 year old was happy, which made me happy and chicken tenders for her, so they do have some kid friendly items. My girlfriend ordered the lamb and she was happy and impressed with the presentation, quantity and quality. I ordered the fillet mignon at the recommendation of our server Arian who also suggested a nice bottle of wine. We had a nice chocolate cake and ice cream to finish off the meal. An excellent dining experience in a hotel restaurant which is rare.
Justin Gervais
Great food and great service!
Marty R.
We had dinner here last evening and both us enjoyed it very much. The food was fair priced, deliciously prepared, (even for special dietary needs) and our waiter was FANTASTIC! He was very attentive, patient, and pleasant. The atmosphere was comfortable and clean.
Tim K.
Didn't feel like jumping back in the car to try to find something to eat so figured we would try the restaurant here at the hotel. Typically not a big "restaurant at a hotel food guy" but the experience and food here we're both pretty good.There's a nice choice of seating if you prefer a bar experience or a sit down restaurant experience. We chose to sit down restaurant experience.Our waiter was very friendly and quite attentive. After mulling over the menu we were set for dinner. My colleague had the fillet mignon, medium rare with mushroom and Bolognese sauce. I got the rigatoni with eggplant.The dinner starts out with two rolls and butter. Be sure to ask for a choice of rolls as it appears, there are three or four different options to choose from. They were OK, not warm, a bit on the stale side.My colleague enjoyed the steak saying it was tender and filling. It was juicy and had a lot of flavor to it. The overall feedback was positive. My rigatoni was Al Dante, perfect! The red sauce was just right. Not too sweet nor too tangy. There was a fair amount of eggplant and balls of mozzarella cheese. I added Parmesan cheese sprinkled on the top. Every bit of my meal was eaten.Not all meals include a salad. The filet did include a salad. I had to get a side salad. The salads were a bit small and lacking variety but overall OK.Overall this restaurant is a good choice.
David K.
Haven't been here awhile but I'm happy to report that this place still hasn't lost a step. The ambience is great and the staff are very experienced. I always get treated great there and last but not least the food is outstanding. They don't have a kids menu but honestly this is the perfect place to ween my kids off of chicken fingers and fries and onto real pasta dishes. My favorite is their roasted duck with wild rice, I hope they keep that on the menu forever.
Sophia Kade
We are staying at the double tree and stopped down for beers and late night food. Svetlana was so sweet and welcoming. They were closing shortly and she made sure we were taken care of. Thank you again dear!
I came for the PEEPERS and SALSICCI? and they told me they don't make that kind of food. ?
Jeffery M.
Service and drinks were good, food ok nothing that makes me come back! Server said house salad is complimentary so I said if I didn't order an entree I'd still get the salad he said no you have to order entree so it's not complimentary! Asked if I could get a Caesar instead he said sure for $8.00 more, what really!! No thank you, how about soup instead no for $7 more you can, I said that's the regular price, he said I know..
WalterKopiske
Went here as it is part of the doubletree hotel and i didn’t feel like getting into my car. Had the chicken marsala and it was good. Had the apple strudel for dessert and was disappointed Overall i have no issues recommending the restaurant
Francis Y.
I have enjoyed many meals over many years at Caffe Milano. It is a reliable "go-to" for gatherings among family, friends or co-workers. The food is excellent, the servers are attentive, and the drinks are always poured "to the brim." There is a casual bar/lounge area with TV's, and a more formal seating area as well. While most menu offerings are terrific, I especially recommend the chicken parmigiana, cavatelli bolognese, rack of lamb, chicken milanese (specials menu) the DoubleTree burger (bar menu), or spicy chicken wings (bar menu). The portions are typically generous. There are different specials offered each week. The DoubleTree's coffee happens to be quite exceptional, so be sure to save room for dessert and a little caffeine after your main course.
AcademyBiz
Surprisingly good for a hotel restaurant. Sea bass was delightful, waiter was polite and helpful to my well-behaved tween, and it was really nice not to need to leave the hotel when traffic is awful outside.
I always get the chicken parm with penne vodka. I love this place good is always consistent. It’s always a hit. The pasta dishes are all great. The give you a decent portion so it’s pricey but you can definitely share the food. I give this establishment a 8/10
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
A hidden gem surprisingly great food I had a chicken soup / stuffed mushrooms and a ribeye steak cooked to perfection fairly priced it’s a must stop every time I am in that
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
This restaurant is located inside the Doubletree hotel. In the area to go see the Yankees play. Had dinner after the day game....too tired to venture out in the city, and the food had great reviews....started with calamari, the wife and I love this... very large portions....then they brought us beautiful mixed green salads...a def step up from the bland ice berg mix you normally see. The wife had ravioli, and I had the seafood linguini. Mussels, clams, shrimp, calamari tossed with perfectly cooked pasta, in a light tomato sauce. Perfect!! No need for dessert, we had doubletree chic chip cookies in our room! Service was friendly, timely, average. The next morning we are in the same room for breakfast. Totally opposite....terrible buffet...service non existent....nice waiter, never around. It's a buffet, had to ask for silverware, had to ask for coffee, had to ask for check....
Quality wise it’s a hampton or holiday. Restaurant is great. Be warned their shrimp scampi has no pasta. Comes with vegetables which are really good but pasta I had to order separate so total was $40+ tip. But it was delicious. Problem with the tub. The stem you pull to switch from tub to shower mode broke but they fixed it right away
With the outside traffic being so bad and having already traveled for hours, I decided to eat here with my girlfriend and her daughter who is 6 years old. We stayed at the Double Tree hotel and had just finished swimming and were hungry and anxious for a good meal. We dressed up for the occasion and were warmly greeted by the host and hostess. Our server Arian was a friendly gentleman from Albania. Excellent waiter. They had mozzarella sticks so my 6 year old was happy, which made me happy and chicken tenders for her, so they do have some kid friendly items. My girlfriend ordered the lamb and she was happy and impressed with the presentation, quantity and quality. I ordered the fillet mignon at the recommendation of our server Arian who also suggested a nice bottle of wine. We had a nice chocolate cake and ice cream to finish off the meal. An excellent dining experience in a hotel restaurant which is rare.
Great food and great service!
We had dinner here last evening and both us enjoyed it very much. The food was fair priced, deliciously prepared, (even for special dietary needs) and our waiter was FANTASTIC! He was very attentive, patient, and pleasant. The atmosphere was comfortable and clean.
Didn't feel like jumping back in the car to try to find something to eat so figured we would try the restaurant here at the hotel. Typically not a big "restaurant at a hotel food guy" but the experience and food here we're both pretty good.There's a nice choice of seating if you prefer a bar experience or a sit down restaurant experience. We chose to sit down restaurant experience.Our waiter was very friendly and quite attentive. After mulling over the menu we were set for dinner. My colleague had the fillet mignon, medium rare with mushroom and Bolognese sauce. I got the rigatoni with eggplant.The dinner starts out with two rolls and butter. Be sure to ask for a choice of rolls as it appears, there are three or four different options to choose from. They were OK, not warm, a bit on the stale side.My colleague enjoyed the steak saying it was tender and filling. It was juicy and had a lot of flavor to it. The overall feedback was positive. My rigatoni was Al Dante, perfect! The red sauce was just right. Not too sweet nor too tangy. There was a fair amount of eggplant and balls of mozzarella cheese. I added Parmesan cheese sprinkled on the top. Every bit of my meal was eaten.Not all meals include a salad. The filet did include a salad. I had to get a side salad. The salads were a bit small and lacking variety but overall OK.Overall this restaurant is a good choice.
Haven't been here awhile but I'm happy to report that this place still hasn't lost a step. The ambience is great and the staff are very experienced. I always get treated great there and last but not least the food is outstanding. They don't have a kids menu but honestly this is the perfect place to ween my kids off of chicken fingers and fries and onto real pasta dishes. My favorite is their roasted duck with wild rice, I hope they keep that on the menu forever.
We are staying at the double tree and stopped down for beers and late night food. Svetlana was so sweet and welcoming. They were closing shortly and she made sure we were taken care of. Thank you again dear!
Restaurantji Recommends
I came for the PEEPERS and SALSICCI? and they told me they don't make that kind of food. ?
Service and drinks were good, food ok nothing that makes me come back! Server said house salad is complimentary so I said if I didn't order an entree I'd still get the salad he said no you have to order entree so it's not complimentary! Asked if I could get a Caesar instead he said sure for $8.00 more, what really!! No thank you, how about soup instead no for $7 more you can, I said that's the regular price, he said I know..
Went here as it is part of the doubletree hotel and i didn’t feel like getting into my car. Had the chicken marsala and it was good. Had the apple strudel for dessert and was disappointed Overall i have no issues recommending the restaurant
I have enjoyed many meals over many years at Caffe Milano. It is a reliable "go-to" for gatherings among family, friends or co-workers. The food is excellent, the servers are attentive, and the drinks are always poured "to the brim." There is a casual bar/lounge area with TV's, and a more formal seating area as well. While most menu offerings are terrific, I especially recommend the chicken parmigiana, cavatelli bolognese, rack of lamb, chicken milanese (specials menu) the DoubleTree burger (bar menu), or spicy chicken wings (bar menu). The portions are typically generous. There are different specials offered each week. The DoubleTree's coffee happens to be quite exceptional, so be sure to save room for dessert and a little caffeine after your main course.
Surprisingly good for a hotel restaurant. Sea bass was delightful, waiter was polite and helpful to my well-behaved tween, and it was really nice not to need to leave the hotel when traffic is awful outside.