Three Star Bagels

270 Columbia Ave, Fort Lee
(201) 224-3745

Recent Reviews

Jesus Rodriguez

HORRIBLE SERVICE !!!!!!!!!!!!! Nasty

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Rubel Bhuiyan

Best . Tuna sandwich I

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Thomas Juiliano

The employees are superstars. Fast service and very personable.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Taylor Ham Egg and Cheese Bagel

Tannia Arias

Fast service and fresh bagels! I tried the brownie for the first time, and it was delicious.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Dave Rotes

Well I do wish this place actually lived up to the 3 stars in the title, but I was not pleased with my experience here. I will clarify I only tried the bagels, and am not sure how the other food is (sandwiches, coffee). I came in the afternoon, maybe that is not the right time to go if you want your bagels fresh? I asked for an everything bagel and they did not have any. I asked which ones they did have, and was directed to what was on display. Personally, I like my bagels to be soft and hot. The hot part I can fix myself because I have a microwave, but they just did not seem fresh. I had trouble even cutting through the bagel when I tried eating it; it just seemed old. I have been eating bagels for decades and know that a bagel should also be alright the next day. I saved one of them for my sandwich the following day, and the thing was almost a rock. I have been able to easily slice bagels up to 3 days old without issue prior to this location, so this rock-like thing was a surprise to me. The bagels were not terrible, just tough to bite into and not really soft. This place is in a pretty convenient location, it is just a bit of a let down that I was unable to get what I wanted. I would recommend going to one of the other local spots for a bagel.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 2

Silver Man

I found one eyelash set, u know the kind that women put on.? In my bagel sandwich I bought from 3 star bagel today Jan18 2024I threw up immediately. I was chewing on it and spit it out, and there it wasA worker must've dropped it in my sandwich making itAs I'm a guy and I only ever seen commercials of these fake lashesWhere's the health dept? Don't come here unless you like chewing on used fake eye lashes, or God knows what else . DisgustingI should've stopped coming after my cousin swore when he worked here, the workers being so underpaid, would put there buggers in the bagels.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

George Richie

Good bagels and breakfast

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 5

Service: 5

Bob J.

Doesn't take much to be friendly, but after coming here for a while, each and every time I come in no one says hello, no one ever smiles, no one ever recognizes anyone who comes into their place, the older woman looks pissed off, the workers look pissed off...what gives, why so freakin unfriendly in a neighborhood bagel shop?? Then, don't even think about buying a sandwich here, because they either simply do not know how to make a decent deli sandwich or maybe they use inferior meats, cheese, etc, because I've tried a few and each time the sandwich is barely edible. I've learned that their bagels are decent, but will be taking my business elsewhere because I want to be somewhere where ppl are friendly and happy and can make a decent sandwich.

Kenia Brizuela

Very good quality.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Sergio Jimenez

Food and service good price a little

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Bacon Egg and Cheese on a Salt Bagel

Emmaunel Dumenh

Italian sub is no good bread is always stale

Brad Weiner

Best Bagels in fort lee, but only when they have them. The operations of this place is maddening. They will run out of bagels during the rush and then have steaming hot bagels at noon. My bagel routine is I drive to this place and if I don't see everything bagels or see 4 or more people on line, i go to my second bagel

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 4

Service: 2

A S

Edited to better reflect the business quality and service, since i thought i had done so last week. Last review was gravely incorrect!Best bagels around.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

R K

Probably the best tasting bagels in the tri state. If not top 3 for sure

Client Updates

Best bagel and service in town. Always a line but that’s because the food is worth it! And it moves fast. They’re efficient and helpful.BEC on a Blueberry Bagel

Load More