Attilio's Pizzeria

4345 US-9, Freehold
(732) 462-2303

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Matthew PT Casserly

Grabbed a quick slice to carb up for a 15k race…pizza was a corner cut of freshly prepared goodness! Counter staff are on top of their game here!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Leah Tomasetti

Came here because I went shopping in the surrounding area and wanted a quick slice. Never been before. All three staff members were super nice and my chicken bacon ranch slice was probably one of the best I’ve had.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Chelsea Foendoe

They sent me spoiled Alfredo. The smell hit me as soon as I opened the container! I cant believe they still sent this. I’m beyond disgusted! Do not order from this place !!

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

valentino coppola

i love this place, i got lot memorie in this place i work for twenty years

ALEXANDER ZAMORA

Where to start… the price did not match the quality of the pies and food in general… the sauce was watery and had no flavor, the distribution of toppings and cheese on my pies was as if the cook did not care enough to be there. If I knew I was going to spend 90+ plus dollars to throw it all away and have my family be unhappy I should have just bought frozen pizzas instead at least then I would have known what I’m getting from the beginning. Do not recommend … save your money .. go to McDonald’s instead

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Sandra Neto

Ordered through door dash .pizza was mediocre , Cesar salad was soggy . Pasta fagole was disappointing . This soup
Involves some tomato not chicken soup with beans and pasta .
No thanks

Food: 3

Milana Sharipova

It was my first time grabbing a bite at Attilios and I completely appreciated the customer service here. Food was great and Pete was a pleasure. It’s nice to come into a place where people aren’t miserable and leave you with a smile. High recommend!

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots

Persephone Kore

Service was extremely nice but felt like compensation for freezer burnt/stale tasting food.. very disappointing, I used to love this place.

Shai Lalush

This pizzeria scores 10 out of 10
The service is amazing the food is delicious the drivers are polite I highly recommend recommend ordering food from here.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Tiffany P

Owner is so friendly nice and welcoming. I go here every Sunday after dog training class at petco with my puppy. Best white slice I’ve ever had! My son favorite is the chicken roll it’s amazing! I highly recommend

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

David Gunther

Was charged $7 for 1 plain slice and an ice tea. Outrageous prices and the slice was a greasy mess. Do not recommend

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 3

Amada Delgado

It’s our local pizza ? stop !!
We order at least 2/week !!
The owner is lovely and goes out of his way to make it the best experience. Pizza is good !!
We love our local pizzeria !!
Easy to order, quick and good !!

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza

Peter Seha

Their stromboli is the best

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

jsner69

Called for 2 pies and the manager was not paying attention to my order as he was talking to someone else at same time so he goes $40 . I said ok im using my card to pay he goes ok im putting the order and get right back at you . So here I was waiting for the call to pay and half hr later this delivery boy came with my order I said I'm sorry I don't have cash im using the card and I've been waiting for your manager to call me back so he called the irresponsible manager and he asked to talk to me to tke card info and said $44.80 I said you told me $40 oh because I didn't know you using card ,so then I said if you were paying attention what I was telling you this confusing would be prevented, I paid ,and on top he asked aren't you add delivery charge? I said No you already included it in my order then I apologize to the kid for not having cash to give him but it was first and also last time I dealt with Atilios Pizza. No professionalism what so ever . And Pizzas were bread and sauce sprinkled cheese and taste of chicken , bad , bad Never again

Heather Bishop

We ordered 8 different items for an office lunch amd we were all blown away! They were friendly on the phone, delivery came right at the time we sked for, the serving sizes were so big and everything was delicious! This will now be our go to place for Italian food.

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...