Romeo’s pizza Italian American

A fantastic family run Italian Restaurant with a nice atmosphere and consistently delicious food. Pizza is a classic, but when it comes to sandwiches I recommend the Montague (a breaded chicken and roasted pepper sandwich) and the meatball sub. All of the staff and the cooks are amicable and welcoming.

I recommend signing up for their benefits so that you can get discounts and coupons.

The restaurant has a decently sized menu and someone could likely find anything they want to eat.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Honestly just wanted to enjoy some good Italian food with nothing to worry jokes on me I ordered here, if I could give no stars I would, here's my order went Ordered a Large fries first and for that we just wanted a cup of cheese sauce on the side the kid said sure let me go check with them 5min,10min,15 min he comes back yeah we can do that I was happy that my dad really wanted he said he'll even go back to make sure he would put it in the bag and make sure it's a good size we, come back to the Cheese thing after ward we also ordered a large meat ball parm, a burger with Swiss we finally get are food the large fries we ordered was plopped into a paper bag kinda schechy and look at that we never get are cheese sauce on the side I call them back and they tell me oh we don't do that here I said I wanted my money back for the cheese sauce and my large fries is this how you guys handle your food and your customers close down already

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

was excited to try but ended up disappointed. owner and counter guy didn’t even acknowledge me even though I was right in front of the register. food was okay. Vinnies next to Acme is better. 0 stars here.

Place order 30 mins in advance and young kid at the counter looked clueless or it was his first day. Tells me he forgot and i waited another 20 mins and didn't even apologize for inconvenience he caused me. There plenty of pizzeria in NJ to get pizza.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 2

Service: 1

Be careful if you pay with a card here. I was charged a surcharge on my debit card, which is illegal under NJ law (P.L. 2023, c.146). Surcharges can only apply to credit cards, never debit.

I’ve already filed a complaint with the NJ Division of Consumer Affairs. Customers shouldn’t have to fight to avoid unlawful charges

The absolute best pizza around

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 3

Food is incredible here! The pizza is delicious, but have you experienced the outrageous bar pie? Large thin well done crust with great tasting toppings of choice. The white truffle pie is killer. Also had their dinners that include a house salad. Excellent vodka sauce. Owner, Lino comes. around to meet you and make sure you are enjoying. This is a class act casual dining at reasonable prices. Highly recommend,

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Amazing pizza spot! They have a pizza for every taste, from classic favorites to creative options. You can really tell the owners care about their customers — they go above and beyond to make sure everyone leaves happy. Highly recommend!

Food: 5

Service: 5

Awesome!:Thin crust Sicilian Xtra cheese

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Got take out food is amazing

Food: 5

Love the pizza here always go when I come back to Jersey

Edit: came back again 2 years after this review and it was phenomenal as always, simply the best pizza.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Delicious 😋 pizza, outstanding customer service and has gluten free pizza 🍕

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Moved to Virginia, this is the only place we come to for pizza now. This is the best pizza we have ever had, the staff is amazing and super friendly! The food is consistently delicious, highly recommend!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Mosquitos feasted more than we did.
All three of us in the party got multiple mosquito bites during the evening. Service was a bit slower than expected considering the restaurant was not packed.
Order garlic knots to start and they looked “well done “, ended up not being as charred as they looked.
By the time dinner arrived we’ve already had a few mosquito bites and we’re itching to leave. Definitely had to swap some sort fruit fly looking thing bug, was darker and slightly bigger than a fruit fly, off of our food. Ended up not taking the side salad home because of that.
Ordered an olive and cheese pie and it was very salty ( briny).
Ordered a penna alla vodka with peas and the peas were unevenly cooked, hard and tasted frozen. Brought some of the pasta home to revive it considering it would be a waste to leave after spending money on it. Seems salvageable.
Grilled chicken was tough and also very salty, was given almost 1.5 breast barely ate a half.
Not sure if we ordered take out from here before, but we just moved to the area and had higher expectations unfortunately.
Friends have had take out, not sure what their verdict was.
Seems like take out was much more popular, you may have luck there.
Good luck

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 3

Im coming to see that comedian dude!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5