Costello's Pizzeria & Wings

You should definitely try pizza. I love it. The most important thing for me is the pizza dough , whenever I try pizza my throat get hurts because of the dough. ı get serious sick. thats why ı am sensitive and picky but ı love pizza. ı wanted to give it a try to this place and ı am in love with the dough. it is soft and delicious. ı appreciate you guys!. Great job !!

We recently won a gift card to Costello‘s so we went order a few subs we had a $25 gift card. It came to 24.49 so we let the girl have the $.51. I don’t know if that was a bad thing or a good thing because The subs were the worst subs I’ve ever had in my life. I had a half a turkey there was one piece of turkey on the whole thing and it was something so uneditable in there. No mayonnaise like I asked for it was dry. My wife’s Italian was so bad even a dog wouldn’t eat it so I highly recommend don’t eat there or don’t get a gift card they will rip you off! We will never go back.!!!!

Ordered chicken cutlet hoagie There was 4.oz of chicken in the hoagie. Ridiculous...

Great pizza!

This place is a staple in our area. The Stockton bomb is by far my favorite sub. Their chicken wings and buffalo ears are hands-down, the best around. Anyone who says they don’t like this place is a moron and I suggest you seek help immediately.

Has A Big slice of pizza, also had some penne with sauce on the side, a great snack!

Cheese steaks are very dry and literally no cheese and they always forget my side of fries otherwise food is good

The fuggeddaboutit pizza is so good at the smithville Costellos, better than the Costellos in Hammonton. We figured out that you can add parmesan garlic sauce to dip it in. But, I'm so bummed that we bought 3 pizzas already and didn't get any credit cause either they're not taking the slice app or the slice app isn't working or they have gift cards sitting there at the hammonton one that I thought said rewards cards. I thought u could use to get the free pizza. Now we already bought 3 and didn't get any credit.

Disappointing. Ordered a large pizza and wings and everything was mid. I was recommended this place and the wings didnt even look appetizing.

Stockton Bomb Pizza was loaded with boneless Buffalo wings, Fries, and exploding mozzarella sticks. Was very filling and tasted good. 2 sides a blue cheese. Said 45 minutes for delivery but took a little over an hour. I was 15 minutes away. Tuesday night dinner. Worth it

Food is ok, my teenagers like their pizza. Service is lousy but what happens when it’s kids running the place. Constant issues with orders wrong or items missing. Again tonight they forgot my sub. They told me I have to come get it after we just got home, this is after they told my son it was in the bag. They would not refund my money either. They could have a driver drop it off but it wouldn’t be for an hour. So now I’m out my meal and $9.

Small but good part of a historic land market...

It was just ok

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 3

Service: 3

The description says crispy wings when I received them via delivery 2 hours later. They were like raw, very undercooked.Nothing crispy at all disgusting.Don't ever ever ever order from here.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

We loved this place for years until recently they hired rude incompetent people too work inside they don’t pay attention when you order and play around very unprofessional

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 1

Recommended dishes: Buffalo Tails