Casa Maya

615 Meyersville Rd, Gillette
(908) 580-0799

Recent Reviews

Sort by
chris f

Love this little gem. Great food, staff and atmosphere.

Brandon Chacon

Good food every time you go!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

matt caine

Best mexican food in the area. Its tight inside, not very big. No reservations BYOB.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

John Grosso

Fantastic food. Unbelievable lunch specials (until 2:30). Regular menu offers anything you might want, but it is a bit pricey and worth it. BYO. Last time we did that we shared our home made sangria with the staff. We made friends for life. This is going back to 1997 for that incident. Go! And enjoy

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Susan Goodman

This restaurant is Wonderful!!! The food is Always Delicious and Plentiful. The staff is friendly, knowledgeable and efficient. The options are Great and they are willing to work with your dietary needs and requests. Atmosphere easy to have a conversation in. Please give this restaurant a try. You Will Be Pleased!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Diana Corrado

solid food. note that the one star reviews are mostly from people who want the kitchen to accommodate tons of dietary restrictions and make omissions and substitutions based on their whim

Wyatt Murphy

Excellent food. Service was friendly and efficient. Parking was a bit difficult. Maybe I just didn't find the right lot as there were plenty of people there. I'll be going back!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Cathy M

Called to order takeout, it was hard to get someone on the phone, no answer, then on hold over 10 minutes so hung up, tried again and finally got someone. The Jalisco combo was great, the tamales were possibly the best I’ve had, moist and tender inside with very good sauces. Chili relleno I wish was cooked less, the pepper had kind of dissolved. Puerco guisado tasted delicious, I just wish there was sauce because the flavor on the pork was amazing. Chicken soup was 10/10, hearty, completely full of veg and chicken. Portions are well worth price too.

Food: 4

Service: 4

Kajal Patel

Absolutely worst. Cheese and bean quesadilla was watery refried beans inside a soggy tortilla and no sight of cheese. We asked for vegetarian version of combo platter with cheese and onion enchiladas, burrito and taco. One of the enchiladas had stuffing; the other one was basically an empty tortilla. Bean burrito and taco were tortillas stuffed with that watery refried beans-no other toppings like cheese. When the server saw us investigating what we got, he simply shrugged his shoulder and walked away when we said the crispy taco was soggy tortillas and wasn’t what we expected. Salsa was watery with little flavor and chips tasted days old.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 1

John Neubauer

Food was excellent. Service was outstanding; they were warm, friendly and seemingly on top of everything.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

santosh dandu

Worst food ever ate.
Don’t go

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Larry Alvarado

This food is not authentic at all. I Am a full blooded los angeles mexican and this food was microwaved tex mex. I was disappointed immediately when I saw the overpriced menu. No shot that 2 tamales are 18 dollars and they were old, sour and microwaved. The beans and rice are days old. Nothing was fresh. The damn 3 leches was the only thing that was good. I guarantee you, the chef cooks the food days in advance to save time. Look at the other reviews photos. The beans and rice are literally microwaved.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 3

G R

Always a solid bet for local Mexican food. Love the fajitas. And the people are always pleasant.

don rodriguez

Authentic Mexican food a dd atmosphere. The owners used to operate restaurant of same name in Clinton

Matt Ellison

Very authentic food, right but cozy space, delightful service

Loading...