Humphrey's Tavern

161 Main St, Glen Gardner
(908) 537-7272

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Brianne Sousa

My boyfriend brought me here for my birthday dinner and oooooh it was so good!!! We ordered a bunch of apps but I have to say my favorite had to have been the buffalo egg rolls. I've never had anything like that before. I fell in love instantly and I highly recommend

Raul Chavarria

We went on a Saturday with no reservations at 730pm. It was busy and we waited a little bit. All the employees were very busy but still nice, we were given an honest wait time also. When we were seated, we were treated to a cozy environment, we were served drinks immediately, and when our food came out it was really really good. The prices were as expected for a dinner at a restaurant, I did not break the bank and we had an appetizer and both ordered a dinner. I would say if you do go make reservations if waiting is not your thing, but if not, it's totally worth the wait. I would recommend and return to Humphrey's without a doubt.

Ryan Hockenbury

Nice spot. Great environment to it. All age groups. Great food.

jennifer jasniewicz

Always enjoyed the meals! Excellent food excelent service

Meghan Mount

Re-did the entire menu. Got rid of all their best dishes. Ahi Burger, Short Ribs, no longer offered. Not sure why they seemed to have removed all the good options. Either way, I won't be back. The large menu was nice and they did have something for everyone. There are plenty of other places in the area where you can get more for less.

Elizabeth Whiffen

Good place to go for dinner. Food excellent and great server. Atmosphere perfect.

Robert Shupp

Happy to have found this place on Google maps, right off of 31. Nice beer choices, nice atmosphere in a great setting. Food was very good except that my wife's burger was "so-so" but we really liked our Buffalo Chicken egg roll appetizer. Will definitely visit again when in the area.

Dana

I recently hosted my sisters baby shower at Humphrey's, and it was a fantastic experience! The food was awesome, they were kind and courteous, and really made you feel at home. If we needed something, they were fast to respond. Coordinating the event overall was a great experience, and I would definitely recommend it to host a party at! Thank you all so much :)

Dimitrios D

Humphrey's Tavern is an awesome addition to the area.

Karen Sferra

Came here with friends for drinks. Really cool place. It got very busy quickly. Get here early! We shared a cauliflower appetizer that was absolutely delicious! Can't wait to come back for dinner.

Scott Bermingham

Food is delicious! Great service! Beautiful inside!

Regina Foran

Great country setting gorgeous old stone building with outdoor patio and porch. Food is hood but on the pricey side...small filet mignon 32.00.

Dennis Silance

A true town gathering place....Excellent vegan menu! This place is a landmark dating back to the late 1700's. Recent renovations to the main floor are impressive and capture the ye olde Town tavern Inn look. Yoga classes offered.

Andrew schneider

Full Vegan Appetizer, entree and dessert menu. Nice old tavern vibe. Bar area separate from quiet dining area. The squash risotto was great, cauliflower steaks we're good but could have used a little more sauce. Vegan Treats dessert options. Entrees are high teens, sandwiches in the low teens price wise.

Danielle Miller

Really neat old building. It was ten degrees outside and we were cold inside. The food was good. The atmosphere was laid back and subdued in the dining area and had a nice party scene in the bar area. We were in the mood for a quiet night out without the kids so it was perfect for us. Staff was very attentive and friendly.

Loading...