Found this place looking for some good pizza and was not disappointed! Tried 3 different varieties and each was delicious! Will definitely be back!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 4
Gina Rosas
Brooklyn is the Absolute BEST!! Its all about quality not quantity. Wonderful Family . I highly recommend it. They never disappoint.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza
Michael Herdeen
Spent a couple of hours at Tonewood Brewing in Barrington last weekend and we were incredibly hungry. I asked one of the bartenders what he recommended for delivery and he suggested Brooklyn Original. We were not disappointed.We ordered the Bella Luna that's sliced sausage, mozzarella, ricotta with Mike's hot honey. It was amazing. The pizza was huge and tasted delicious.Can't wait to get back to try more of the menu.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Old Fashioned Tomato Pizza
Carleena Lara Bregatta
About 10 years ago, on a wonderful NYE, i was staying at an adorable air bnb in Brooklyn. This was a grand time, aside from when my professional camera was stolen from my apartment, but I was there to see the band Phish, which made it all okay.I digress.Around the corner from our spot, there was this classic lil New York pizza shop. Doing as I do, late night pizza was in order. I was flabbergasted by the caliber of the pie I ravenously engaged with that evening.At the time, I had naïvely declared that it was most notably the best pizza I’d ever had and would ever have. For many years I grieved those perfectly crispy and cheesy slices that I had gotten to know & enjoy all those years ago. I lamented that upon my next trip back to Brooklyn, the air bnb listing was not able to be found, as that was the only surviving clue for me to find my way back to the gods of all pizza gods.And then, one day, my life changed.Brooklyn Pizza — OUR NJ neighborhood friends of Brooklyn Pizza — moved into town.Please know that the owners of Brooklyn Pizza are NOT the same as the mysteriously named pizza shop I’ll never find again.How do I know?Because THIS PIZZA is BETTER!I don’t know if many of us recognize just how lucky we are to have Brooklyn Pizza - THIS Brooklyn Pizza.So many in this country will never get to know what a real pizza tastes like, because you can only make it how NJ & NY makes it…well…here on the East coast! I hope we thank the pizza Lords each day for how blessed we are. I mean, we did always have access to somewhat above average pizza in our area beforehand, which I appreciated back then.But now…NOW that Brooklyn Pizza moved in a few years back, they totally changed the game.Sometimes I cry when I get that overwhelming craving, only to see that it’s Monday and they’re closed. They ruined pizza anywhere else around here because I realized that I was selling myself short and accepting food that was well below my self worth. I’m sorry folx, but I am no pleb. I’d rather go hungry on a Monday, or ditch my plan for pizza than settle. These guys raised my standards that I cannot and will not go back to slightly above average pizza, you see. I hope that you remember your worth today, and refuse to settle for anything less than pizza luxury, too. You deserve it.Now that story time is over ~ here’s the review on the actual food ?THIS Brooklyn Pizza is the absolute best pizza of my life. When you call to order, I promise you the entire transaction will be the fastest phone call you make in your life. They are efficient, swift and get down to business.They are ALWAYS consistent with their cooking times, quality, service and food. I’ve NEVER had a subpar pizza, or anything from them for that matter. The pizza is “Well done but NEVER burnt.” The way the Pizza Lords always intended.They actually slice the slices all the way through, because who the hell has time to be cutting it the other 1/4 of the way when I’m just trying to eat!?There is also a special twist that you they add, with the Sicilian culture that I adore so much. The salads and dressings are always fresh, they have my favorite cannolis in all the land, and I don’t know where they source your ingredients from but they’re in another league entirely than these broke a$$ joke a$$ other pizza places, in terms of everything ~ quality, dank ingredients & a care for the actual CRAFT of food. They care about what they do, and that to me is everything.Sometimes, I’ll be driving en route to my home with no plans of getting pizza, sometimes not even being hungry, when my brain subconsciously processes the visual cues of their brick and mortar, right there, staring at me. At times I forget who I am and where I was going. My eyes gloss over and the next thing I know, I’m back in my car, gleefully eating a hot slice, right from the oven.Order the pizza. Get the dessert pie. Eat at your own risk, though & Don’t say I didn’t warn you.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
cyndy wulfsberg
Really good square pie. Call to determine when to call in your order but best to walk in and see them in action. You can buy by the square or the pizza. This is not skinny flatbread. It's the real deal!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Boardwalk Pizza, Veggie White Pizza
Johnny Johnson
Very busy, popular pizza shop. I like to call ahead and see the availability of their slice pizzas, and then dine-in. Everything they make is really yummy!
By far the best pizza in South Jersey. The food, staff, and ownership are a 10/10. We used them to cater our daughter’s bday party and the spread was done impeccably well! Look forward to their pizza every
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Heath Gravener
Ordered the pani hoagie. I was told they didn't have vinegar or mayo. I said ok I'll try it anyway with the oil and seasonings. Not great in my opinion. Also chunks of lettuce should have been shredded. But hey I'll try anything once. But not for 30.00 but that was with a soda and tip. 5.00 delivery charge a little high. Sorry just being honest. Wish I could have posted pics.
Very friendly atmosphere and staff. ordered a large pizza pie.while waiting the Hostess gave us a sample of garlic knots that was to die for, gravy/sauce was a hit. definitely will be back. must try the Aramciata as a beverage . Delicious!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Old Fashioned Tomato Pizza, Garlic Knots
C K
Don’t overlook traditional
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza
Steve Panichelle
My brother and I and our wives stopped by for lunch. My brother and I had been here a few weeks before for the first time--I had a Brooklyn Large pizza and he had a Caprese panini and the owner treated us to their mouth-watering garlic knots, and everything was great--but this was the first time for our wives. We were going to order one or two whole pizzas, and were a bit overwhelmed with all of the delicious looking choices, but the owner suggested we try a bunch of slices which she warmed in the oven and cut in halves so we could sample them. The Old Fashioned Tomato Pie and the slice with broccoli rabe, roasted red peppers, cherry tomatoes and garlic were my favorites, but White Spinach Ricotta, and the Potato Pie were also very good. The owner and the staff made us feel welcomed-- the service is first-rate which amplified our overall 5-star experience. We raved about it all the way, and look forward to next rendezvous at Brooklyn Original Pizza. Thank you!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Old Fashioned Tomato Pizza, Spinach & Ricotta, Old Fashion Tomato Pie
Very easy going place, ordered the Brooklyn style square pizza and it was phenomenal! Not from the area but will definitely be revisiting!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Absolutely delicious pizza. Highly recommend the Drunk Grandma and Honey Moon squares. So good.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Drunken Grandma Pie, Cheese Pizza
Found this place looking for some good pizza and was not disappointed! Tried 3 different varieties and each was delicious! Will definitely be back!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 4
Brooklyn is the Absolute BEST!! Its all about quality not quantity. Wonderful Family . I highly recommend it. They never disappoint.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza
Spent a couple of hours at Tonewood Brewing in Barrington last weekend and we were incredibly hungry. I asked one of the bartenders what he recommended for delivery and he suggested Brooklyn Original. We were not disappointed.We ordered the Bella Luna that's sliced sausage, mozzarella, ricotta with Mike's hot honey. It was amazing. The pizza was huge and tasted delicious.Can't wait to get back to try more of the menu.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Old Fashioned Tomato Pizza
About 10 years ago, on a wonderful NYE, i was staying at an adorable air bnb in Brooklyn. This was a grand time, aside from when my professional camera was stolen from my apartment, but I was there to see the band Phish, which made it all okay.I digress.Around the corner from our spot, there was this classic lil New York pizza shop. Doing as I do, late night pizza was in order. I was flabbergasted by the caliber of the pie I ravenously engaged with that evening.At the time, I had naïvely declared that it was most notably the best pizza I’d ever had and would ever have. For many years I grieved those perfectly crispy and cheesy slices that I had gotten to know & enjoy all those years ago. I lamented that upon my next trip back to Brooklyn, the air bnb listing was not able to be found, as that was the only surviving clue for me to find my way back to the gods of all pizza gods.And then, one day, my life changed.Brooklyn Pizza — OUR NJ neighborhood friends of Brooklyn Pizza — moved into town.Please know that the owners of Brooklyn Pizza are NOT the same as the mysteriously named pizza shop I’ll never find again.How do I know?Because THIS PIZZA is BETTER!I don’t know if many of us recognize just how lucky we are to have Brooklyn Pizza - THIS Brooklyn Pizza.So many in this country will never get to know what a real pizza tastes like, because you can only make it how NJ & NY makes it…well…here on the East coast! I hope we thank the pizza Lords each day for how blessed we are. I mean, we did always have access to somewhat above average pizza in our area beforehand, which I appreciated back then.But now…NOW that Brooklyn Pizza moved in a few years back, they totally changed the game.Sometimes I cry when I get that overwhelming craving, only to see that it’s Monday and they’re closed. They ruined pizza anywhere else around here because I realized that I was selling myself short and accepting food that was well below my self worth. I’m sorry folx, but I am no pleb. I’d rather go hungry on a Monday, or ditch my plan for pizza than settle. These guys raised my standards that I cannot and will not go back to slightly above average pizza, you see. I hope that you remember your worth today, and refuse to settle for anything less than pizza luxury, too. You deserve it.Now that story time is over ~ here’s the review on the actual food ?THIS Brooklyn Pizza is the absolute best pizza of my life. When you call to order, I promise you the entire transaction will be the fastest phone call you make in your life. They are efficient, swift and get down to business.They are ALWAYS consistent with their cooking times, quality, service and food. I’ve NEVER had a subpar pizza, or anything from them for that matter. The pizza is “Well done but NEVER burnt.” The way the Pizza Lords always intended.They actually slice the slices all the way through, because who the hell has time to be cutting it the other 1/4 of the way when I’m just trying to eat!?There is also a special twist that you they add, with the Sicilian culture that I adore so much. The salads and dressings are always fresh, they have my favorite cannolis in all the land, and I don’t know where they source your ingredients from but they’re in another league entirely than these broke a$$ joke a$$ other pizza places, in terms of everything ~ quality, dank ingredients & a care for the actual CRAFT of food. They care about what they do, and that to me is everything.Sometimes, I’ll be driving en route to my home with no plans of getting pizza, sometimes not even being hungry, when my brain subconsciously processes the visual cues of their brick and mortar, right there, staring at me. At times I forget who I am and where I was going. My eyes gloss over and the next thing I know, I’m back in my car, gleefully eating a hot slice, right from the oven.Order the pizza. Get the dessert pie. Eat at your own risk, though & Don’t say I didn’t warn you.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Really good square pie. Call to determine when to call in your order but best to walk in and see them in action. You can buy by the square or the pizza. This is not skinny flatbread. It's the real deal!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Boardwalk Pizza, Veggie White Pizza
Very busy, popular pizza shop. I like to call ahead and see the availability of their slice pizzas, and then dine-in. Everything they make is really yummy!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Drunken Grandma Pie, Rigatoni Alla Vodka Pizza, Cheesesteak Pannini
By far the best pizza in South Jersey. The food, staff, and ownership are a 10/10. We used them to cater our daughter’s bday party and the spread was done impeccably well! Look forward to their pizza every
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ordered the pani hoagie. I was told they didn't have vinegar or mayo. I said ok I'll try it anyway with the oil and seasonings. Not great in my opinion. Also chunks of lettuce should have been shredded. But hey I'll try anything once. But not for 30.00 but that was with a soda and tip. 5.00 delivery charge a little high. Sorry just being honest. Wish I could have posted pics.
Food: 2
Restaurantji Recommends
Very friendly atmosphere and staff. ordered a large pizza pie.while waiting the Hostess gave us a sample of garlic knots that was to die for, gravy/sauce was a hit. definitely will be back. must try the Aramciata as a beverage . Delicious!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Old Fashioned Tomato Pizza, Garlic Knots
Don’t overlook traditional
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza
My brother and I and our wives stopped by for lunch. My brother and I had been here a few weeks before for the first time--I had a Brooklyn Large pizza and he had a Caprese panini and the owner treated us to their mouth-watering garlic knots, and everything was great--but this was the first time for our wives. We were going to order one or two whole pizzas, and were a bit overwhelmed with all of the delicious looking choices, but the owner suggested we try a bunch of slices which she warmed in the oven and cut in halves so we could sample them. The Old Fashioned Tomato Pie and the slice with broccoli rabe, roasted red peppers, cherry tomatoes and garlic were my favorites, but White Spinach Ricotta, and the Potato Pie were also very good. The owner and the staff made us feel welcomed-- the service is first-rate which amplified our overall 5-star experience. We raved about it all the way, and look forward to next rendezvous at Brooklyn Original Pizza. Thank you!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Old Fashioned Tomato Pizza, Spinach & Ricotta, Old Fashion Tomato Pie
Way too expensive. Pizza was burnt.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 1
Amazing every time! Great prices for huge serving
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Boardwalk Pizza, Half Drunken Grandma Pizza Half Honeymoon Pizza, Cheese Pizza, Baked Ziti with Ricotta Mozzarella & Tomato Sauce, Cheesesteak Pannini, Sicilian Arancini