Costello's Pizzeria & Wings

Great food and very fair prices. Never have been let down, the buffalo tails are the best anywhere. You have to try the Chicken cordon blue sandwich, its awsome I highly recommend.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Steak, Pizza, Buffalo Tails

You just can't beat the service 1st of all!! Everyone who works there are very polite, pleasant and always willing to help 😊! On top of that the food (especially their salads) are always a treat to eat 😋😀😉!! Keep them in mind when you want something really good to eat and enjoy!!!

Dietary restrictions: I've recently had to change my diet which includes eating more salad and lower fat content!! So I went from their awesome cheese steaks and broccoli bites to their specialty salads and I'm not disappointed what so ever!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chicken Wings, Steak

Chicken tips

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Buffalo Tails

Great pizza and wings

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chicken Wings, Buffalo Wings, Pizza, Buffalo Tails

They have the absolute best wings and hot sauce!! Everyone I bring here is impressed with the wings and the hot sauce is the best hot sauce I’ve ever had!!! 10000% would recommend their wings!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Buffalo Tails

Ordered from the place and the fries were soggy and has no flavor as for the pizza it was so uncut that when you pulled it apart the cheese would come off the pizza and it all costed 65$ never ordering from here again

PROS: Located right in Smithville. Beautiful view of the lake and picnic tables outside. They have a large menu and a variety of huge slices to choose from when you want a quick bite. They have daily dinner specials. Their spinach and artichoke dip was delicious. They gave it to me as a to-go order by accident but it came out very fresh and I think that's the secret to this place.. order everything to-go even if you plan on sitting. The girl behind the counter was very sweet, patient, smiled and made recommendation. They do bring the food to your table instead of calling you back up to the counter.
CONS: I am a buffalo chicken pizza connoisseur as I get it everywhere I go. I can't stress enough how many buffalo chicken slices I've had in my life. Unfortunately, it wasn't good at all for me. I wish my review was different as they say they're known for this type of pizza. The buffalo sauce was sweet, the chicken was chewy and the slices were very limp. I did not expect the sweetness but kept an open mind about it. When I was almost done eating my slice, I couldn't finish it because it was too sweet for me. I can appreciate how they put a spin on it like (sweet heat.) Lastly, I know flies are annoying and hard to handle in the summer, but several of them swarming around our table was ridiculous. Eating while swatting flies off our food and face the whole time was not my idea of dining in.
Overall it wasn't that bad and I might give it another try one day.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Buffalo Chicken, Sauce, Pizza, Buffalo Chicken Pizza

The food is always delicious when it’s correct, and it seems lately that is the issue. The past three times I’ve ordered take out I’ve been nothing but disappointed and inconvenienced. I have ordered a white pizza before to get home to find out that it’s red and due to an allergy issue cannot consume tomatoes which was made aware to the counter girl upon ordering. When calling back no one answers the phone to make the order correct. Another issue was a dinner order, when my husband went to pick up the order they had given us the wrong food and my husband was instructed to bring back the food and come and get the correct order which the staff didn’t seem to care that they had made the mistake in the first place. Today I ordered lunch and it will be the last time I will order from this location, I called and the girl who answered the phone stated pick up or delivery I say delivery she says I’m sorry we are a pick up only location…. Ok but your menu and even the advertising on the building states you offer delivery as well as what I ordered states on the menu it comes with a side of fries which I ask to confirm and the same counter girl says no I can add it for $2.00 more dollars. I’m not sure if the manager/owner is aware of how this business is being run but it’s a shame I will not be ordering from here again.

Again the food is always delicious when it’s correct!

After a long drive from Virginia I was looking forward to eating pizza and wings I usually buy from Nino's down the road but decided to give Costello's a shot. Man I was disappointed the cheese and sauce was runny like soup. Then to top it off I returned the pie and the YOUNG girl accuses me of dropping it. I can assure everyone that I did not drop it I was offended by her comment needless to say that was my first and last time I will spend my money at this establishment

delicious Stromboli with Pepperoni!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Sauce, Pizza

My go to for lunch, not only is the staff amazing but so is the food. Large authentic portions and nicely priced. Absolutely I adore the young lady in the front she is such a doll. Favorite is their pizza next to their salads !

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

My go to for lunch, not only is the staff amazing but so is the food. Large authentic portions and nicely priced. Absolutely I adore the young lady in the front she is such a doll. Favorite is their pizza next to their salads !

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I ordered a pizza with a lot of sauce and light cheese. The pizza didn't seem to have any sauce on it. The girl who took the order quite rude when we questioned her about it. Had the nerve to try and charge me for extra sauce which I didn't get.

Fast, friendly service and excellent food!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Ordered tails for superbowl this past weekend. Got mild and hot tails. The mild was almost at hot level. The hot was nuclear. I like hot stuff so it wasn't that big a deal to me but my wife could barely eat the mild so beware if you get the hot. Also we ordered for pickup at 345. The tails were barely warm when we got them and had obviously been made well ahead of time. Not a big deal they were still good but I'd rather have them hot and fresh when i pick them up and not have to reheat at home.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 3