Bay Ave Bakery & Cafe

111 Bay Ave, Highlands
(732) 291-3480

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Greg Scott

best crumb cake and oatmeal cookies in NJ

stephen

This place seems to be out of business. Went there today at 7:30 and they were "closed", even though their posted hours are from 6:30 AM every day. Had to drive some time to get there. If they're running a real business they should show up or shut down.

Atmosphere: 1

Service: 1

Susan Torrone

I am giving 5 stars for the crumb cake! Yum!! Best ever!

Ken Weston

Great sandwiches and baked goods. Sadly today is the last day in that location, landlord did not renew lease.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Stephen Nelson

Food is top notch and service is always good and consistent and the service is great the everyone that works there is very friendly

Kid-friendliness: They have high chairs available

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Scrambled Eggs

Mekayla Dale

Grabbed lunch here when arriving in the area and it quickly became my regular stop for a BEC bagel. Delish. Never disappoints, folks in here are very friendly.

Food: 5

SUPER STOCK Robert

Awesome place!

Mark Skandera

Good sandwiches and pastries. Nice bikeride from the Sandy Hook lighthouse.

Mary Connolly

I got a ham and Swiss cheese on ryeToday. And it was the worst Sandwich I ever had. The bread was stale and the ham was very thick and slimy. I have been going there for over 20 years and I'm so disappointed with them

L R

pork roll, egg, & cheese on a bagel ~$7.xxwith small coffee totaled $10.13Bothered my stomach a little - not sure if it was the coffee or sandwich.Lots of baked good items that look good and perhaps worth a look Prices are slightly elevated but then again so is everything. Pics posted, so you can decide for yourself.

BC

Holy cow I had the best cookie ever!! Seriously good baked goods here

Michael Antico

Best bakery around!!! From cakes, to cookies, to brownies, crumb cakes so tasty!!! Don’t forget the cafe that also has good sandwiches and small area for eat in breakfast lunch !!

Sabrina Elkington

Very delicious and well-made breakfast sandwiches

S Torbati

Always delicious, always friendly. Best breakfast sandwiches and crumb cake!

Elena R.

We had omelette and two pastries for breakfast. Everything was of excellent quality. It was early in the morning and they were cooking bagels and other sweets. We loved the family atmosphere. Portions are generous and prices modest. Top place!

Loading...